Cottage holiday rentals in Anastasia Island

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 387 reviews

Unique mid-century modern Lemon Tree Cottage

Bright and cheery Mid-Century modern inspired cottage located in the northern section of St. Augustine. Tucked away on a quiet street, only 2 miles from the heart of historic downtown and 2.5 miles away from the pristine Vilano Beach. All new tile flooring, countertops, fridge and stove, bathroom vanity, linens and area rugs. Meticulously curated to be a unique and fun stay with vintage decor. Great Value Stay for a single family home while being close to downtown. Plenty of off street parking.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Little Sister's Carriage House w/ Parking

Welcome to Little Sister's Carriage House, a bright and delightful historic cottage located only steps from all St. Augustine has to offer. Beautifully furnished and full of vintage touches, this home is the perfect blend of modern comfort and historic charm. With a personal garden, full vintage kitchen and tons of character, it's a one of a kind stay. Sip coffee on your porch, or take a short stroll into town. Park your car and walk everywhere! Locally operated by lifelong St. Augustinians

5 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

~Romantic Historic 1888 Cottage~Walk to Downtown

Come live in history! This cottage traces its roots back to humble beginnings: built by freedmen, it still stands today as one of Lincolnville's original historic treasures. Nestled in the heart of America's oldest city, this endearing historic 1888 cottage offers an intimate, refined escape with a boutique ambiance. This is the ideal retreat for travelers seeking a romantic getaway or guests who wish to be transported to a more graceful time. Discreet in scale but grand in experience.

5 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Historical Cottage in Heart of Town! Park & Walk

Welcome to Groveside Cottage on one of historic streets of St. Augustine! In 1920s Grove Avenue was the home of several families of cigar makers and two cigar manufacturing companies. This lovingly restored cottage offers modern comforts while maintaining the character and charm of a circa 1900 home. Our coziest porch and fenced courtyard are great for a cup of coffee or a glass of wine to enjoy outdoors. Park and walk to discover all the wonderful things this historic downtown has to offer!

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 184 reviews

Coastal Cottage -firepit, pet fence, kayaks, bikes

Located in the historic Lighthouse Park neighborhood, this charming 1940s coastal cottage is easy strolling distance to the Lighthouse, Alligator Farm, mini-golf, cafes & more! It is only a 0.8-mi walk to the Bridge of Lions, where you can walk over the Bay to downtown St. Augustine. You couldn't ask for a better location! It's on Anastasia Island so you're a short walk/bike/car ride from the beach & Ampitheater. It's cozy, pet & kid-friendly with a big backyard. Kayaks & bikes available!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

Fun Waterfront Retreat, Heated Pool, Rooftop Deck

You've found your waterfront oasis tucked under the White Birds of Paradise! This spacious retreat was formerly a commercial art gallery. Two queen beds, one full bathroom & full kitchen make for comfortable living! You have a fenced path leading you down to the beautiful waters of Salt Run where a rooftop deck & salt water in-ground pool invites you to relax and slow down. Less than a mile to downtown St. Augustine, a little over a mile to the Amphitheater and about 3 miles to the beach.

5 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Walk Historic Downtown! “Blue Heaven”

Stunningly renovated cottage combines modern amenities with vintage charm... * 2 master suites with queen beds * Quiet neighborhood walking distance to explore The Nation's Oldest City * Clawfoot tubs inside and out (along with showers, of course!) * Big screened-in porch with hanging daybed * Off-street paved parking * Fenced yard, Weber grill, gas fire pit * Fast Wi-Fi and Smart TV * 2 blocks to Fish Camp, Ice Plant and LaNuvelle * 10 minute walk to central downtown St Augustine

Superhost

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

The Shire on 1 acre marshfront with dock and Spa

One of a kind 1930s historic home, newly renovated and transformed into a beautiful secluded getaway. new luxury finishes, while holding its traditional charm. No Events allowed. Rooftop deck, sunrise views of the Atlantic ocean, Downtown, and sunsets over the river. The new dock with covered roof hosts a national geographic like eco system. It’s short walk to the beach and 3 miles to downtown St George street. Follow along @carcabaroad for weekly content of the home.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Enchanting courtyard, quiet cottage by beach

Very comfortable, relaxed island breezy appeal. King and queen bedrooms, additional quality blow up queen mattress. Open living space with French doors leading to back deck. Spacious kitchen, dining & breakfast nook. Gorgeous private courtyard with string lights for magical night time ambiance. Expect everything you may need with complimentary wine and baked goods upon arrival. Local dining scene is incredible! No smoking inside! *See house rules for pet info.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 355 reviews

Sea La Vie Beach Studio

Our renovated studio is on a quiet cul-de-sac, one block from the beach! It is one side of a duplex and is perfectly located within walking distance to restaurants, family-friendly activities, nightlife, and public transport. It is across the street from the pier and the piers weekly farmers market. It is a short drive to historic downtown St Augustine. The neighborhood is quiet and safe. Our place is good for couples, solo adventurers and business travelers.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

Couples Boho Bungalow close to Beach and Downtown

Enjoy St. Augustine – the nation’s oldest city – and everything it has to offer from this cozy, Boho themed 1 bed / 1 bath getaway. Located near the heart of the city, it is close enough to walk to the historic St. George Street while also maintaining privacy and quiet comfort. With new, modern amenities, a back porch, a yard, and ample dedicated parking, this home is everything you could want on your trip to beautiful St. Augustine, Florida.