House holiday rentals in Bay Shore

My family and I had a beautiful stay and I couldn’t have asked for a better rental. The Airbnb was huge with more than enough room for everyone and the backyard was large and spacious enough to have everyone eat comfortably. If I ever need another large rental you can bet I’m gonna check here first.

Sarah is an amazing host - super quick responses to questions, friendly, helpful, it was such a pleasure to stay at her house! The house is more than that - Sarah makes it feel like home! From the countless comfy reading nooks that our teenagers loved and used, to the awesome outdoor space, the pool table & wine cooler and well stocked kitchen all the way to the nice touch of live plants (because let's be honest, at how many AirBnBs have you have live plants before?!). We felt right at home and are definitely planning on coming back! Highly recommend!!

As newlyweds, my husband and I booked Erol's AirBnb to have a different experience from the standard hotel bookings for weddings. The house was the same as the photos and even more gorgeous in person. We had a lot of room to move around while getting ready and taking photos. The bathroom also felt luxurious with the heated toilet seat and rain showerhead. Thank you so much for having us!

We had a great time and the house was beautiful! Very close walk to the bellport country club for a wedding. Pool was awesome. Hosts were very responsive when we had any questions. Would definitely recommend.

This Home was Amazing!! Anastasia is Phenomenal, I could see why they are Super Hosts. Their home is Beautiful and very clean. It’s filled with amenities! all that are in the description. So much so we didn’t even get a chance to take advantage of them all. We were only there for two days. Next time it’ll be much longer. I love this place!

We we’re going to Port Jefferson for a family wedding. Our Airbnb was perfectly situated. There is a pool area that we never used because we just didn’t have time. But it looked very inviting. The town of Port Jefferson had plenty of nice restaurants and shops. This house was perfect for our situation. We had six adults, all family members.

This is by far the best Airbnb I have ever been to. I usually don't write reviews, but this was truly an exceptional experience. Not only is house very comfortable, the host, John, is also very, very generous and thoughtful. The amenities were very well-stocked and so much detail went into making this house comfortable. Not to mention the backyard is huge (with a dock leading directly to the bay), the pool is perfectly heated, and there's so many things to do inside the house that we hardly even wanted to venture out of it the whole 4.5 days we were there! I highly recommend booking a stay here especially with family - it was a good experience for everyone from the young kids to the grandparents to the dogs.

Cindy’s place was exactly as described and the communication was great when I did have questions. The backyard and pool were really nice, clean and well manicured. There were plenty of towels and the kitchen had everything I needed to cook dinner. The house was clean and the bed was actually pretty comfortable so that was nice! I would for sure stay here again, thanks again Cindy!

Very nice place we loved

Well equipped! Enjoyed our stay :)

The house has a such an amazing vibes and location is great as well. Chris is absolutely amazing, friendly and caring person, made everything better and easier! Definitely will be back in the future, really beautiful and comfortable house with such a lovely atmosphere! Big thank you to Chris for everything!

The home was perfect for us, we were visiting for a concert at Jones Beach. We explored the area including outlets & mall all within 25mins from the home. I listened to other reviews and brought a small sound machine, this was helpful as the home is on a busy/loud road. At first, I thought this would bother us, but we don’t spend much time in our rentals we’re here to have fun & be out exploring. Beds were comfy, everything was clean, kitchen was very nice to add leftovers & store drinks. Living room was comfy & clean. There is no backyard access, no washer/dryer but that was ok. You park on side of home in driveway, and walk to front & up the front stairs if you have anybody with difficulties walking that would be the only downfall. Enough towels for 4 ppl as well. Had 1 small hiccup and it was resolved immediately, very responsive host. Thank you for providing us a safe, and comfy place! The next concert we attend, we will come back!

The process to check in was self check in and was clear and easy to do. The place was impeccably clean and very well decorated. The items in the Airbnb were well thought out and useful, (cooking utensils, salt & pepper, coffee, etc). The location was a nice neighborhood. There was a weather issue that occurred and Shekeva was incredibly professional and immediately responsive to the situation and my concerns. I would stay here again!

I truly loved this place! Rosalina is phenomenal!

For a low and fair price, we received a beautiful and welcoming house that was perfect for our getaway with friends. The kitchen and living room area had an amazing vibe, and we were greeted with a fully stocked and clean kitchen, ready for us to use. Wally and his wife are wonderful people; they were very accommodating and ensured that everything was taken care of. I would recommend this home to anyone, as it offers great value and is suitable for any purpose. It’s just a quick walk to the beach in one direction and to cute restaurants and bars in the other. There’s also a playground nearby if you want to bring your kids! The area is very peaceful, but it also has nightlife options if that's what you're looking for. I highly, highly recommend it!

Tanay was a great host. Clear concise info for how to best make use of the space. Fast, helpful responses. We stayed for an entire month and it was comfortable and had everything we could need to make it feel like home for a while.

Efielou’s place was exactly as described with some extra bonuses! She had waters, snacks, fresh towels, extra toiletries, and a well lit path to the door. The backyard was stunning and it was a very nice block. It was quiet and it felt extremely safe. Efielou responded quickly to all messages before and during my stay. I am originally from Long Island and this will be where we stay from now on when we visit family!

We loved our stay at The Stella, particularly the location (super walkable to everything!), cute retro kitchen, record player, helpful guidebook (including a curated house playlist!), lux linen linens, easy parking, easy check in / check out, and the responsiveness and helpfulness of the host!

Perfect place for a weekend of beach walks !

The house was perfect, confortable and clean. We enjoyed our time on the nice terrasse with a stunning view. John is very helpful and reactive.

Frank was a great host, highly recommended his airbnb.

Carol's place is clean and well taken care of. very nice just a little pricey for coming from out of town

Absolutely fantastic stay! The home was spotless, beautifully decorated, and exactly as described—if not better. Cristina was incredibly responsive and thoughtful, providing everything we needed for a comfortable visit. We especially loved the peaceful back patio and the beautiful view of the canal—it was the perfect spot for morning coffee and evening wind-downs. It truly felt like a home away from home. Would absolutely stay here again and recommend it to anyone looking for a top-notch Airbnb experience.

We had a wonderful stay at the (Chel)sea. Chelsea herself met us up on arrival to showed us around, and she was super friendly & welcoming. The beds were really comfortable, the sea breeze was relaxing and despite our weather being a bit rainy, the proximity to the water and private beach made this a true retreat! Walkable area, natural surroundings and a lovely restaurant (La Plage) at the end of the road. Kudos to the cleaning staff who left sweet touches throughout. We'd love to stay here again!