Holiday houses in Cagles Mill Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top Guest favourite
A spacious modern structure is set against a clear blue sky, featuring a hip roof and large windows that allow natural light to fill the interior. The exterior is accented by stone pillars and a wide porch, surrounded by a grassy field.
Home in Greencastle
5 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Quiet Country Retreat Near DePauw University

Discover the charm of Throttle Back Ranch, a brand-new (2023) home just minutes from Greencastle, DePauw University, Cataract Falls State Park, Putnam Park Road Course, and Cowpokes Arena. Racing enthusiasts will love our unique touch - a full-size race car mounted on the wall! Enjoy country living at its best, with a fully equipped kitchen, entertainment options, and an expansive covered porch for breathtaking sunset views. Feel free to reach out with questions. We can't wait to host you!

Top Guest favourite
A cozy living area is highlighted by a stone fireplace adorned with greenery. The space features a comfortable white sofa and an ottoman, with large windows allowing natural light to fill the room, revealing scenic views of the outdoors.
Cabin in Unionville
5 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Spring Blooms & Birding: 40-Acre Luxe Forest Spa

Experience the April Awakening. Trade the city for a curated 40-acre forest reset near Nashville, IN. Perfect for mature couples or singles, seeking a nature-themed reset as the forest buds and the morels begin to pop. Hike private paths, watch the nesting bluebirds, and unwind in the forest-view hot tub. ​Includes a complimentary Brown County State Park pass. Note: As a working ridgetop, occasional host sightings or nearby construction may occur. High-speed fiber while "working from the woods".

Top Guest favourite
The entrance to the cabin features a covered porch with rustic wooden supports and decorative string lights. A welcoming outdoor seating area is visible in the background, surrounded by lush greenery and shaded by nearby trees. The path is lined with stones and small plants.
Cabin in Unionville
5 out of 5 average rating, 492 reviews

Cozy Cabin Close to University 1

The Red Rabbit Inn is located just 15 mins from the Indiana University campus and just 20 mins from Nashville, IN , this architecturally designed cabin features the works of local artisans. Beautifully landscaped on a secluded, wooded pond, this cabin includes a loft bedroom with KING bed, bath, full kitchen, gas fireplace, satellite TV & Wifi, with your own private deck, outdoor hot tub, fire pit area & gas grill. Cabin sleeps 2 guests. Located near Lake Lemon, in a beautiful serene setting.

Guest favourite
A rustic log cabin with a red metal roof is nestled among tall trees, showcasing a blend of original character and modern updates. Surrounding the cabin is natural terrain, with a spacious deck featuring outdoor seating against a backdrop of greenery.
Cabin in Poland
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Pioneer Log Cabin on the Lake

Take a step back in time to a simpler way of life! Enjoy this log cabin that was originally built in the pioneer days. While the cabin retains the charm of the 1800's, it also has been updated with basic amenities like electricity, indoor plumbing, hot water, and everything you would expect from a modern cabin. Located on Cataract Lake, yards from a public boat launch, this is the perfect spot to get out onto the lake or just relax amongst the trees. Boat parking is provided on the property.

Top Guest favourite
An exterior view of the home is captured, featuring a light gray facade and metal roof. Colorful flowers and pumpkins decorate the landscaped garden, complemented by a bench positioned under a tree. Neatly arranged windows provide an inviting look to the property.
Home in Gosport
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Maria’s Haven

Welcome to “Maria’s Haven”💕 A beautiful cozy home in the heart of a beautiful small town. This home belonged to my mother, Maria, who passed away in 2020 to breast cancer. This home was truly her “Haven”. Take a walk to the local diner, museum, Gosport playground, local shops, or to our delicious Amish bakery. We are also just a few miles from the popular “Hilltop” restaurant as well as McCormicks Creek State Park. Our mission is to make you feel like you never even left home. ☺️

Top Guest favourite
A panoramic view of the dome's interior highlights the unique wooden ceiling design, featuring triangular shapes. A dining table with blue placemats accommodates six, surrounded by large windows and stained glass accents, allowing natural light to fill the space.
Home in Bloomington
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

There's No Place Like Dome!

Come enjoy fabulous Bloomington, IN from your own private paradise! The 1400 square-foot renovated dome home boasts panoramic wooded views and sits on 6 acres of a secluded, park-like setting only 17 min. from downtown. The dome sleeps 4 guests with an open, divided, (not fully private) loft with one full bed and one queen bed. There is one full bath, dining for six, island seating and a fully equipped kitchen. It also features a fireplace, laundry facilities and front and back decks.

Top Guest favourite
Cabin in Poland
5 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

Cozy Lofted Cabin (#2) at Cataract Lake Getaway

This new cabin on a private road is a serene setting perfectly blending rustic charm and modern comfort. Only a half-mile from Cataract Lake, quick and easy access to boating, fishing, kayaking, etc. awaits! Numerous nearby attractions are sure to provide great experiences (Cataract Falls, C Bar C Event Center, Exotic Feline Rescue Center, state parks, brewery/winery, local shops/eateries, etc.) And of course, simply enjoying time in and around the cabin itself is a fulfilling getaway!

Top Guest favourite
A spacious hot tub is shown, featuring bubbling water and adjustable jets. The tub is located under a semi-covered area, surrounded by greenery, providing a tranquil and private retreat.
Guest suite in Rosedale
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 250 reviews

Getaway- hot tub, sauna, and more!

Tastefully decorated unit perfect for a relaxing retreat. Great for couples, travelers, or girlfriend getaways! Ground-floor unit (2-story unit with upstairs available for additional charge, otherwise not rented). Queen bed + sleeper sofa. 55" TV w/Showtime. Massage chair. Internet available but spotty due to rural location. Large private hot tub and firepit surrounded by woods and corn! Firewood provided at no charge. Plus a new sauna when outside temps are above 40°F.

Top Guest favourite
A modern home is positioned on a hillside, featuring a sleek black exterior and large windows that allow for ample natural light. A balcony extends from the structure, providing outdoor seating and a view of the surrounding trees.
Cabin in Nashville
5 out of 5 average rating, 513 reviews

Modern Nashville Home in the Woods

Welcome to Plāhaus - a modern home nestled in the woods of Brown County. Plāhaus is a space of solitude and relaxation for anyone wanting to enjoy the beauty of Brown County, without the typical log cabin decor. Enjoy the gorgeous view from the balcony, spend some time around the firepit, and venture into Nashville to check out the unique shops and restaurants. Come for a family getaway, a romantic retreat or simply to clear your mind from the everyday stresses.

Top Guest favourite
Cabin in Nashville
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Red Cedar Log Cabin | Romantic + Hot Tub

Cozy, secluded, and full of charm, Red Cedar Log Cabin is the perfect Brown County getaway for couples. Soak in the private hot tub, unwind by the wood-burning fireplace, and enjoy the peaceful wooded setting. With rustic character, modern comforts, and easy access to Nashville, trails, shops, and local dining, this cabin is made for quiet mornings, cozy nights, and unforgettable weekend escapes. Book your stay and experience Brown County at its coziest.

Top Guest favourite
A single-story cabin is framed by lush greenery, showcasing natural wood siding and a welcoming front porch. The porch features seating arrangements and decorative elements, while the pathway leads to a gravel driveway, enhancing the serene ambiance of the surrounding woods.
Cabin in Carbon
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 272 reviews

Parke County Dream Cabin

Come experience the serenity of country living and get away from the daily grind of everyday life. Come fish in our five-acre lake (catch & release only), paddle-boat, kayak, or stroll through the woods. A covered porch and seating lakeside for relaxing. Located close to Mansfield and Bridgeton, 30 minutes from Turkey Run State Park, and only 30 minutes toTerre Haute or Greencastle. Come explore everything Parke County has to offer! KIDS WELCOME!

Top Guest favourite
A cozy living area features a dark gray sofa adorned with yellow and patterned throw pillows. A television is mounted on the wall, with a wooden entertainment center below. A lamp stands beside the couch, and a potted plant is positioned near a window.
Loft in Spencer
5 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Carriage House 1 bedroom loft suite w/ fireplace.

Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located loft. Carriage House Guest Suite is located in a quiet neighborhood just five blocks from the courthouse square. Spencer's historic downtown offers the restored Tivoli theater, restaurants, art galleries & shops. Two miles from beautiful McCormick's Creek State Park and 3 miles to Owen Valley Winery. A convenient 20 miles to downtown Bloomington & Indiana University.

Popular amenities for Cagles Mill Lake holiday rentals