Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Captain Bill's Guest House at Cataract Lake
SUPERHOST
Entire residential home · 4 guests · 2 beds · 1.5 baths
Captain Bill's Guest House at Cataract LakeWelcome to Captain Bill's Guest Lodge at Cagels Mill Lake (aka Cataract Lake)! This gorgeous home offers modern amenities in a countryside setting. Perfect for bikers, boaters, fisherman, and anyone looking to unplug and enjoy lake life. Our guests are welcome to join Captain Bill poolside at the main house across the driveway. We're located seconds from the boat ramp and a short drive to Cataract Falls and Lieber State Park. Ask about our Airbnb alongside the Cataract Falls recreation area.
Woodland Gatherings Suite - Cataract / Cloverdale
SUPERHOST
Private room · 2 guests · 1 bed · 1 private bath
Woodland Gatherings Suite - Cataract / CloverdaleLocated on 50 acres this comfortable Guest Suite has it's own private entrance facing the woods as well as a private full bath, queen bed sleeping room and small living room. Plenty of space to park boat, RV or horse trailer. Available rental of property space for small gatherings of family or friends, gardens, fire pit, deck with covered dining area has a grill for use with room. Owner lives on property and suite is part of main home yet separated with locking doors and private entrance.
Horse barn bunk room .
SUPERHOST
Private room · 2 guests · 1 bed · 1 shared bath
Horse barn bunk room .Ready to spend the night in a horse barn?Just minutes from I70, come stay in a bunk room located upstairs near the hay loft, brand new barn built in 2020, park right out front on a gravel lot, access to a bathroom, Refrigerator and microwave,Small but quaint, be ready to go simple, no TV, no internet, no deliveries, rest on a queen size bed, in a very small room, if you enjoy different then this is for you.

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Other great holiday rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

SUPERHOST
  1. Entire guest suite
  2. Spencer
Parkview Suite at the Cataract Falls Lodge
$173 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Center Point
Relaxing Country get-away
$130 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Reelsville
"Bloomin' Acres" Peaceful Country Homestead
$110 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Cloverdale
7 Bedroom Lake House with miles of Wooded Trails
$1,677 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Poland
Woodland Gatherings Fireside Glamping
$58 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire guest suite
  2. Spencer
Bridge-View Suite at Cataract Falls Lodge
$140 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Poland
Woodland Gatherings Camp Cozy Cataract Glamping
$97 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Private room
  2. Poland
Woodland Gatherings Sunrise Glamping - Cataract
$90 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire guest suite
  2. Spencer
Bridge-View Family Suite at Cataract Falls Lodge
$181 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Spencer
Cataract Falls Lodge
$336 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire cabin
  2. Poland
Captain Bill’s Lake House
$243 NZD per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire guest suite
  2. Spencer
Parkview Family Suite at Cataract Falls Lodge
$203 NZD per night