
Holiday houses in Cagles Mill Lake
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in Cagles Mill Lake
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

“Lemon Blossom”Lakehouse by Brownsmith Studios
This home is a dream come true for me building it from the ground up. Bring your boat. No Partiers this home is being offered to families and couples who won’t disturb my neighbors or our peaceful cove. The home features a steam shower, king bed, reclining sofa, dock, kayaks,reading/social nook at signature windows over the creek/lake. The deck floats in the forest with abundant wildlife all around. premium WiFi . 15min to Bloomington. 20min to Nashville/Brown County St. Park. Newly paved lane

Elevated Wilderness | Mindful Retreat | 2 Kings
Executive Forest Sanctuary/2 King Beds, Hot Tub & Trails Escape to an architectural masterpiece set on 40 private, wooded acres. Designed for professionals, couples, and active adults seeking a high-end nature reset, Cabin Porch Paradise balances complete seclusion with proximity to Southern Indiana’s best destinations. Whether you are unwinding in the spa amenities, working remotely via high-speed fiber, or exploring the surrounding lakes and state parks, this is your ultimate ridgetop retreat.

Beach Style Lakeside Mini Cottage Idle Zone
Beds/NO LINENS Showers/ NO TOWELS Kitchen/sink mini fridge no stove outside grill, fire pit, and cast iron provided. Dishware, silverware, and cooking utensils provided. Things you will need to bring: Linens, pillows, towels, dish rags and personal hygiene items. We will provide enough trash bags, toilet paper, dish soap to get you started after that its renters responsibility. We have state certified kilm dried firewood for sale $6 bundle. Coffee Pot take both grounds and k-cups. 4 lawn chairs.

Maria’s Haven
Welcome to “Maria’s Haven”💕 A beautiful cozy home in the heart of a beautiful small town. This home belonged to my mother, Maria, who passed away in 2020 to breast cancer. This home was truly her “Haven”. Take a walk to the local diner, museum, Gosport playground, local shops, or to our delicious Amish bakery. We are also just a few miles from the popular “Hilltop” restaurant as well as McCormicks Creek State Park. Our mission is to make you feel like you never even left home. ☺️

There's No Place Like Dome!
Come enjoy fabulous Bloomington, IN from your own private paradise! The 1400 square-foot renovated dome home boasts panoramic wooded views and sits on 6 acres of a secluded, park-like setting only 17 min. from downtown. The dome sleeps 4 guests with an open, divided, (not fully private) loft with one full bed and one queen bed. There is one full bath, dining for six, island seating and a fully equipped kitchen. It also features a fireplace, laundry facilities and front and back decks.

Cozy Cabin Close to University 1
The Red Rabbit Inn is located just 15 mins from the Indiana University campus and just 20 mins from Nashville, IN , this architecturally designed cabin features the works of local artisans. Beautifully landscaped on a secluded, wooded pond, this cabin includes a loft bedroom with KING bed, bath, full kitchen, gas fireplace, TV & Wifi, with your own private deck, outdoor hot tub, fire pit area & gas grill. Cabin sleeps 2 guests. Located near Lake Lemon, in a beautiful serene setting.

Covered Bridge Cabin (on Big Walnut Creek)
Retreat and renew in this charming one-room cabin right by Big Walnut Creek and Baker's Camp Covered Bridge. Fish, kayak, or swim; hike or birdwatch in a nearby preserve; read, write, find inspiration. With sweet-smelling poplar walls, the cabin offers a full bed by a picture window, small TV, writer's desk/library, AC, fans, baseboard heat, kitchenette, toilet, sink, outdoor shower (before first frost), small porch, grill, and a fire pit. (No wifi in cabin!) Simple and beautiful.

Summer Kitchen at The Hill
Come enjoy this spacious studio that has been remodeled from an old summer kitchen. Located on 6 acres in the town of Spencer, this is the perfect place to unwind and getaway, or use it as a jumping point to adventure at nearby McCormick's Creek or Cataract Falls. Walking distance to neighborhood grocery store, coffee shop, and restaurants. Within 30 minutes of Bloomington and Indiana University! The hosts live full time in the main house with 2 great danes.

Red Cedar Log Cabin | Romantic + Hot Tub
Cozy, secluded, and full of charm, Red Cedar Log Cabin is the perfect Brown County getaway for couples. Soak in the private hot tub, unwind by the wood-burning fireplace, and enjoy the peaceful wooded setting. With rustic character, modern comforts, and easy access to Nashville, trails, shops, and local dining, this cabin is made for quiet mornings, cozy nights, and unforgettable weekend escapes. Book your stay and experience Brown County at its coziest.

Modern Nashville Home in the Woods
Welcome to Plāhaus — a modern retreat tucked into the woods of Brown County. #1 Most-wishlisted Airbnb in Indiana per Airbnb Designed for solitude, relaxation, and connection with nature, Plāhaus blends modern architecture with peaceful surroundings. Take in the views from the balcony, gather around the firepit, or explore nearby Nashville’s shops and restaurants. Perfect for romantic getaways, family escapes, or simply recharging from everyday life.

Parke County Dream Cabin
Come experience the serenity of country living and get away from the daily grind of everyday life. Come fish in our five-acre lake (catch & release only), paddle-boat, kayak, or stroll through the woods. A covered porch and seating lakeside for relaxing. Located close to Mansfield and Bridgeton, 30 minutes from Turkey Run State Park, and only 30 minutes toTerre Haute or Greencastle. Come explore everything Parke County has to offer! KIDS WELCOME!

Carriage House 1 bedroom loft suite w/ fireplace.
Keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located loft. Carriage House Guest Suite is located in a quiet neighborhood just five blocks from the courthouse square. Spencer's historic downtown offers the restored Tivoli theater, restaurants, art galleries & shops. Two miles from beautiful McCormick's Creek State Park and 3 miles to Owen Valley Winery. A convenient 20 miles to downtown Bloomington & Indiana University.
Popular amenities for Cagles Mill Lake holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Modern Cottage In Town

Cozy getaway w/close proximity

Quiet Country Retreat Near DePauw University

Addys on the creek. Located in Mansfield, IN

Cozy Cabin on Lake front with Hot tub & firepit

The Cozy Canary

Farm cabin by the lake.

Beanblossom Cottage - Newly Renovated
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Holiday rentals
- Nashville Holiday rentals
- Platteville Holiday rentals
- Indianapolis Holiday rentals
- Downtown Chicago Holiday rentals
- Columbus Holiday rentals
- Louisville Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Southern Indiana Holiday rentals
- St. Louis Holiday rentals
- Cincinnati Holiday rentals
- Milwaukee Holiday rentals
- Lucas Oil Stadium
- Indianapolis Motor Speedway
- Indiana Convention Center
- Brown County State Park
- Indianapolis Zoo
- The Golf Club at Eagle Pointe
- Eagle Creek Park
- Gainbridge Fieldhouse
- Indiana State Fairgrounds & Event Center
- Childrens Museum
- McCormick's Creek State Park
- Oliver Winery
- Broad Ripple Park
- Monroe Lake
- Butler University
- University of Indianapolis
- Shades State Park
- Circle Centre Mall Shopping Center
- Garfield Park
- IUPUI Campus Center
- Holliday Park
- Indianapolis Museum of Art
- Indiana State Museum
- Indiana World War Memorial





