Cottage holiday rentals in Cedar Lake

Wow, what a gem! This place was charming, spacious, neat, with a great backyard and conveniently situated within 15 minutes of anything you could need or want. This is not your bare minimum cut and paste Airbnb—the beds and pillows were incredibly comfortable and luxurious, the decor was unique, the space was toddler friendly, and the kitchen was very well stocked. A great stay for a group overall, we’ll be back!

We loved our stay at Ashley and Bobby’s! The yard was great for our dogs and the beach, sauna and hot tub were great for us. Perfect spot for a peaceful week away. Bobby and Ashley were extremely accommodating and responsive to any needs. They have a beautiful home and I hope we can return!!

We loved our stay! The cottage was so cute and very clean. It is in a residential area, but still feels very private. The neighborhood was quiet. The outside/backyard area is amazing. We could walk everywhere (restaurants, shops, beach, market, etc…). We did not get into our car once from when we parked it until we left. Nancy was so nice to work with. She called us on our way there to let us know the hot tub motor was not working. That was not a big deal us, but she was proactive in telling us and she had it fixed by the next day. We would 100% recommend staying here and might book it again ourselves.

Our stay was absolutely wonderful. The hosts were incredibly hospitable and flexible, making everything so easy and welcoming from start to finish. This home holds a lot of sentimental value for our family — we spent many years vacationing in this area growing up — and it meant so much to be able to return to the area and create new memories in such a beautiful, well-kept space. We couldn’t be more grateful and would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a relaxing, meaningful getaway.

Great place for a large group of people! Although it is surrounded by other homes, the trees behind the property give it a very private feel. It is a quick walk to the beach which is very convenient. All of the neighbors were very kind to our group as we walked around. We tried out the New Mexican restaurant down the street and it was delicious. This was one of Sylwia’s recommendations. She did a great job of giving us a list of things to do around the area before we arrived. There’s 2 train stations very close, which we utilized to get to Chicago. It was about an hour trip and very convenient to get the Portage/Ogden Dunes Station from the Airbnb. We were a little worried about the location considering Gary does not have the best reputation, but it was closer to Portage, and in a very safe area. We never once felt unsafe. All in all, Sylwia was great, the Airbnb was great, and I would recommend her listing!!

Donna’s home was amazing!! We felt so safe, comfortable, and relaxed during our trip. I highly, highly recommend it for your girls trip!!

Lovely home, many well thought out perks like fans in upstairs rooms and beach toys for kids! Info said it was an easy short walk to beach so I spent a whole lot more than I usually would. With children it would not be pleasant and is really not a short walk (and is on a semi busy road) & beach is down a whole lot of steps. BUT there are parking spaces so it was fine. Within the house, the steps are fairly steep at parts & there are 2?big ones going into house &!these were hard for my 70 year old mom w knee issues. So if person reading reviews is one of those people, this might not be THE place. That being said, it is very short walk to community pool & host is very responsive & house is beautiful! My mom mostly stayed within first floor including an awesome bed/bath on ground floor. There are games (although I didn’t love the Ouija board 🫣😂) . This would be a great place for multiple family / friends to split cost ;) Its very beautiful & community pool & hot tub are great!

This is our 5th year of vacationing in New Buffalo and have stayed at Missy's place on 3 of those visits! The house works beautifully for our family (7 adults and 4 kids under 6 yo) and you're never tripping over each other, which makes it so relaxing! We'll be back!!

Perfect couples getaway. We were there in off season so nice and quiet. Great lake views. Hubby was fishing off the dock everyday and I sat on the covered back porch looking at the lake and enjoying my book. Very clean! Great grocery store a few minutes away! Strack & Van Til. Great dinner at the Lighthouse just 5 minutes away. Very nice affordable winter weekend getaway. Jent was amazing. Quick response to questions. There's a piano that's in tune that I missed in the pictures. Would have brought some sheet music.

We had a great time! And enjoyed our stay! The host was very responsive and helpful!

Had a fantastic stay here (our second year in a row), and it was just as good as we remembered! Came with my husband, 2 young kids, and dog - and everyone loved our trip. The house, yard, games, and location were all perfect! And hosts were very communicative.

We really enjoyed our stay at John’s place. House was super clean and comfortable. Loved the outside porch set up as well as ability to dine outside in bark yard. We always enjoy this area as the hiking for our dog is amazing.

We had a great time in New Buffalo! Airbnb is in an excellent location, walking to Beer Church was awesome! Would totally stay again.

Patrick’s place is a rare find. Extraordinary Airbnb! It’s the most thoughtfully supplied kitchen. We enjoyed cooking brunch looking out on the park trails. We were lucky with perfect weather, which added to the loveliness. I know the area, to me the location is perfect…especially if you like long pretty walks. Thank you for sharing this special house, Patrick. Check out the home’s website.

What a beautiful location! Loved all the trees, beautiful yard to play games, super big fire pit, deck and grill was spotless! The inside was nice and spacious for the size. Great kitchen and bathrooms. The basement was large! We had an incredible time. Would come back for a longer vacation!

Great neighborhood, quiet and cozy! Easy to find and close enough to everything we wanted to do. The backyard was beautiful and we loved being able to relax with the dog. Cute house and friendly hosts.

Super comfortable place to crash. Convenient to all the activities in New Buffalo. Local golf course is super casual. Good place to take the family.

Third time staying here - we love this place. Brendon and Bryndal do an amazing job communicating and their place is always clean and in great shape. We like the walking areas near the house for our pup and the disc golf in Michigan City. Always a pleasure to visit - thanks

Stayed for a long weekend and the place was just what we needed. The location has plenty of privacy but is very close to the lake, Union Pier, Three Oaks and New Buffalo which provided plenty of things to do. Nature preserve within a 5 min walk of the house was a nice surprise. The house was well stocked with essentials, nicely decorated and up to date. I would definitely stay here again.

This is our second time staying here this summer. We enjoyed it so much the first time we booked again. Great location with tons of good local eats. Christen is very easy to work with and so communicative. The house feels like home- so much that our kids asked when we were moving here. The walk to the beach is short and the privacy of the beach is so nice.

Cozy Cottage was perfect for our long weekend beach getaway! Jodi was friendly, responsive and more than accommodating! This place and Beachwalk Resort had everything we needed and more!

Lorene was an amazing host. The home was exactly as pictured. It was stocked with everything needed plus some. Would definitely stay here again.

We had an amazing time at this beautiful cabin! The decor was thoughtfully done and made the space feel cozy and welcoming. It was also very comfortable and just a short walk from the beach, which was a huge plus. Ryan was a great host, super responsive and helpful throughout our stay. Highly recommend!

Jan’s place is fantastic! The place is immaculate and cozy. We especially loved all of the little details she thought of. Walking distance to restaurants and shops and a few miles to the beach. Private back patio was very nice. Jan checked on us through the trip and was very easy to work with. I definitely recommend you check out this spot.