Holiday houses in Horseshoe Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Cottage in Jefferson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Lakeview Cozy Cottage w/ 2 bedrooms & 1 bath

Start your morning with a fresh cup of coffee while watching the sunrise over the lake. Less than 1 hour from NYC, enjoy your staycation in this updated cottage in a peaceful lake community. Relax on the patio while enjoying the tranquility of nature and creating wonderful memories. Less than 5 minute drive to swimming, watersports, boating, farms, wineries, and lots of great restaurants & bars. Less than 10 mins to Hopatcong State Park, 10 mins from Rockaway Mall, and 30 mins to Mountain Creek.

Top Guest favourite

Castle in East Stroudsburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 400 reviews

Pocono Castle w/ Dungeon Escape Room &Private Pond

OMG! Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

Guest favourite

Cottage in Hopatcong

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Lake Hopatcong cottage with dock; Permit #2025-9

Enjoy your stay in this unique lake cottage with private dock. Kitchen, living room & 2 bedrooms on 2nd floor, 2 porches lake side, sleeper sofa 1st floor; 2 bathrooms. Includes 2 kayaks & 1 kid kayak, paddleboard & paddleboat, fishing supplies, firepit with cookware, wifi, 8ft shuffle board, 6ft billiards, electronic dartboard, spiders & bugs. Pontoon not included (negotiable). Walk to Patrick’s Pub or Beacon bar-restaurant. End of dock <4 feet deep. 3 nights min. Dock your boat upon request.

Top Guest favourite

Cabin in Millrift

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

Remote Waterfall Cabin at Swiftwater Acres

Deep in a lush oak forest, on the bank of Bushkill Creek sits this hidden oasis. This is simply THEE most private abode in the entire area. Situated just feet from the water, the falls can be seen and heard from every room within the cabin’s charming, rustic interior. This spectacular 45 acre parcel is set within a vast reserve of state land: an oasis within an oasis. Just 90 minutes from NYC, this is a truly sublime atmosphere, perfect for those seeking a rejuvenating and inspiring getaway.

Guest favourite

Farm stay in Hackettstown

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Cozy cottage, serene with views

Enjoy the lovely setting of this romantic spot in nature. Good for 2 adults, 2 children on pull out sofa.3 miles from center of Hackettstown. Also available on site are 2-three bedroom units and a 2-bedroom unit. Many food options, parks in area, grocery stores. Book and I will send video of place as site doesn’t accommodate for that. You can cancel if u don’t like it, but that won’t be the case. We strive for perfection to cleanliness, snacks, coffee choices to make for a memorable stay.

Guest favourite

Home in Hopatcong

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Stunning sun-drenched lakefront 4-bedroom house

Expansive, cheerful, and stylish house situated right on the beautiful Lake Hopatcong. Escape the city and enjoy the lake living at its best. This spacious home offers 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths on two levels with breathtaking lake views. One of a kind main bedroom features massive white marble bathroom with jacuzzi tab and walk-in shower. Divine open concept living area with huge glass doors coupled with grand deck, will be your favorite spot to chill, dine, and enjoy magnificent lake views.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Mendham Township

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Historic Cottage with Private Pond & Pool

Step back in time to 1760 with the old world charm of Colonial America. Pre-dating our country by over a decade, our beautifully renovated 260+ year old home sits on 5 acres with a detached studio and 2 separate water features. Experience the private pond teeming with koi, frogs, and other wildlife or take a dip in the refreshing pool just steps away. Whether you seek a relaxing getaway or a portal back to the days of our founding fathers, our historic home promises the ideal retreat.

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Sparta Township

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 95 reviews

Serene Surroundings: Guest Suite in Sparta

Discover a hidden gem! Escape to our private guest suite, offering a peaceful retreat with its own entrance and serene pond views. Perfect for enjoying a quiet getaway, visiting family, or exploring the best the area has to offer. Located just a five-minute drive from the picturesque Lake Mohawk and a short walk to the exciting Tomahawk Lake Water Park. Close to great restaurants, charming pubs, quaint boutique shops, popular wedding venues and scenic hiking and biking trails.

Guest favourite

Guest suite in Jefferson

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

BooneDock - lower level

Newly built in 2021 you’ll enjoy the entire basement level of this lake front home with private entrance. Hosts occupy the first floor of the home. It is located on the Northern end of Lake Hopatcong which is perfect for waterskiing, tubing, kayaking, fishing, or just sitting on the dock watching the sunset. We are minutes away from many hiking and biking trails. Rent a boat at Bridge Marina for a day and explore the largest lake in New Jersey. Only 5 miles from Interstate 80.

Guest favourite

Home in Boonton

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

The Boonton Revival- A restored treasure in NJ

The Boonton Revival is an updated 100-year-old home within walking distance of historic Main Street, quaint restaurants, and unique shops. The nearby train and bus stations can connect to the NYC Port Authority (7th Ave) in one hour. Newark Liberty Airport is a 30-minute ride; you can be at the Jersey Shore in an hour! We are avid gardeners who enjoy raising beautiful koi fish. Guests are welcome to admire our pond and sample in-season vegetables.

Top Guest favourite

Cottage in Jefferson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Lake Hopatcong hide away

Private cottage in Lake Hopatcong Nj. Cottage is NOT on the lake and there is no direct access from the property. Enjoy fishing, boating and swimming in the largest lake in NJ. Cottage is in a quiet Neighborhood less then 1/4 mile from the lake. Enjoy outside lake view dining at the many restaurants the lake has to offer. Located 30 miles from PA and 40 miles from NYC. There is a ring camera doorbell.

Superhost

Guest suite in Livingston

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Modern & luxury studio

This stylish and peaceful studio with its bathroom & kitchen and this property is 5 mins from Livingston mall, short hills mall and St Barnabas hospital. This place is suitable for healthcare professional travelers and if also just visiting the town. It is 10 mins from turtle back zoo and south mountain reservation and other shopping complexes. Note: Shared laundry space btw host and airbnb guest