Boutique hotels in Key West

Find and book unique boutique hotels on Airbnb

Quick stats about boutique hotels in Key West

  • Total holiday rentals

    Explore 40 holiday rentals in Key West

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Key West holiday rentals start at $240 NZD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 2,200 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly holiday rentals

    10 properties offer extra space and kid-friendly amenities

  • Holiday rentals with a pool

    30 properties feature pools

  • Wi-Fi availability

    30 of Key West holiday rentals include Wi-Fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across Key West rentals

  • 4.6 Average rating

    Key West stays receive an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 from guests

Top-rated boutique hotels in Key West

Guests agree: These boutique hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favourite
A serene waterfront view showcases calm waters reflecting the sky, with docks extending into the bay. Palm trees are positioned on the shore, and an American flag gently waves in the breeze. Outdoor seating is visible along the patio area.
Hotel room in Duck Key
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Conch Key Villas #2 Peaceful waterfront lodging

Studio Two's waterfront rental is located on the ground level. Each unit comes with a boat slip and parking for your trailer. We can handle boats up to 25’. There is a boat ramp just 2 blocks away. We provide outside table and chairs, and just around the corner, the barbecue grill. Our accommodations include king bed, living and dining area, futon, polished terrazzo floors, waterfront patio, literally 6 feet from the water, full size and equipped kitchens, A/C and cable TV, DVD and Wi-Fi.

Guest favourite
A bright cabana room features a spacious bed adorned with colorful pillows. Large glass doors open to a view of the pool area, allowing natural light to brighten the space. Vibrant floral wallpaper complements the light tones of the decor, contributing to a tropical ambiance.
Hotel room in Key West
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Marrero's Guest Mansion Adult Only (21+) Room 12

Adult Only Boutique Hotel (21+). Experience the grandeur of their stately Victorian home, thoughtfully updated and lovingly converted into a boutique hotel. We are located in the heart of Old Town, just half a block from Duval Street. This beautiful room is right next to our revitalizing saltwater-treated pool. Separate from the main house, this cabana room offers guests a more private tropical escape. This room features a pillow top king bed with a private bath and sitting area.

Top Guest favourite
A waterfront rental property is shown, featuring a two-story building painted in a soft peach hue. Several palm trees frame the scene, while wooden docks extend into the calm waters. A spacious balcony overlooks the dock area, providing access to the scenic Florida Bay.
Hotel room in Duck Key
5 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Conch Key Villas #1. Fun, fishing & great sunsets

Studio One's waterfront rental is located on the ground level. Our units differ vastly from other Florida Keys lodgings because our property is right on Florida Bay. If you trailer your boat, the dockage is a few feet from the back door. Our docks can handle boats up to 25’ and you can park your trailer in our front lot. There is a boat ramp just two blocks away. Studio 1 can sleep 2 adults and one child (up to 12 years). We have a king size bed and a futon.

Superhost
A well-appointed guest room features a spacious bed adorned with decorative pillows against a vibrant yellow floral wallpaper. Natural light floods the space through large windows draped with sheer curtains. A decorative fan enhances the room, while a wall-mounted TV offers entertainment options.
Hotel room in Key West
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Marrero's Guest Mansion Adult Only (21+) Room 10

Adult Only (21+) Boutique Hotel. Experience the grandeur of the stately Victorian home, thoughtfully updated and lovingly converted into a boutique hotel. Our location in the heart of Old Town in Key West, just half a block from Duval Street. This charming room is as welcoming as the friendly island locals and features a pillow top queen bed and full private bath. Its private second floor veranda overlooks the garden and pool areas at the back of the house.

Guest favourite
Hotel room in Key West
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 502 reviews

Mallory House Room #3

There is no better place for your Key West stay than Mallory House. This historic circa 1890’s home is located on Duval Street in the Gato Cigar Factory Village. Mallory House is steps away from famous attractions, restaurants, cafés, bars and shops. Stay within close proximity to the Southernmost point and beach, the Hemingway house and lighthouse. Enjoy a complimentary cup of coffee on our spacious balcony overlooking world famous Duval Street.

Superhost
A line of bright yellow and gray jet skis is seen docked at a marina. Lush palm trees surround the water, with white buildings featuring green shutters in the background. The clear blue sky reflects off the calm water, creating a serene environment.
Hotel room in Marathon

Marathon Beachfront | 2BR, Veranda + 2 Luxe Baths

Enjoy direct beach access from the Oceanfront Veranda | 2BR 2Qns 1King guestroom, a spacious beachfront retreat with a king bed, two queen beds, and two deluxe bathrooms. Relax on your private veranda, indulge in a spa-like bath with a rainfall shower and soaking tub, and enjoy modern comforts like complimentary WiFi and an entertainment system. Experience five pools, oceanfront dining, and endless adventures in the Florida Keys.

Superhost
A private oceanview terrace is presented, furnished with two comfortable chairs and a round table. Lush palm trees are visible in the background, framing the serene view of the ocean. Natural light enhances the welcoming atmosphere of this outdoor space.
Hotel room in Marathon

Marathon Oceanfront | ADA Queen + 5 Pools

Experience comfort and accessibility in the Oceanfront Balcony Queen ADA room. Designed for a seamless stay, this ADA-compliant retreat features a queen bed, a fully accessible deluxe bathroom, and a private oceanview terrace. Thoughtful details like wide doors, roll-in shower, and hearing-impaired features ensure ease and relaxation. Enjoy five pools, beachfront dining, and oceanfront luxury in the heart of the Florida Keys.

Superhost
A serene beach area is framed by palm trees, featuring sun loungers under blue umbrellas. Soft sand leads to clear water that gently meets the shore, creating a tranquil atmosphere. The landscape is complemented by lush greenery, enhancing the coastal setting.
Hotel room in Marathon

Marathon Oceanfront Suite | King Bed + Kitchenette

Escape to the Oceanfront Balcony | 1BR King (Suite), where breathtaking ocean views and luxury amenities await. This spacious suite features a plush king bed, a separate living area with a queen sofa bed, a kitchenette, and a spa-like bath with a walk-in rainfall shower. Step onto your private oceanview terrace, and experience five pools, beachfront dining, and endless coastal adventures in the Florida Keys.

An expansive pool, bordered by palm trees, reflects the vibrant sky at sunset. Sun loungers, arranged under white umbrellas, provide ample relaxation space. The backdrop features a building, offering a serene atmosphere for guests to unwind by the water.
Hotel room in Duck Key
5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Family Room in Duck Key | Sauna, Kayak & Pools

Gather the crew in the Family Oasis—a bright, roomy hideaway where bunk beds delight the kids and a plush king bed welcomes parents. Ideal for up to five guests, this relaxing space blends laid-back comfort with family-ready convenience. Located in Hawks Cay Resort, enjoy a full day of waterside fun, unwind in your oversized room, and let island time set the pace for your unforgettable stay.

Superhost
An aerial view captures a spacious resort pool shaped like a flower, surrounded by palm trees and lounge chairs. Aqua umbrellas provide shade around the pool's perimeter, while the clear blue water reflects the surrounding tropical landscape.
Hotel room in Marathon

Marathon Oceanfront Room | King Bed + 5 Pools

Indulge in oceanfront luxury with the Oceanfront Balcony | King room. Featuring a plush king bed, a spa-like bath with a deep soaking tub and walk-in rainfall shower, and a private oceanview terrace, this serene retreat is perfect for relaxation. Enjoy modern comforts, complimentary WiFi, five pools, beachfront dining, and endless coastal adventures in the heart of the Florida Keys.

A bright room features a spacious bed with a light wood headboard and crisp white linens. A round dining table with two chairs sits beside the bed. Natural light enters through large windows adorned with sheer curtains, and a pendant light adds a modern touch.
Hotel room in Key West
4.55 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Parrot Key, Garden 2 Bedroom Suite w/ Living Room

The island life awaits you at the Parrot Key Hotel and Villa in Key West. The Island getaway has an authentic ambiance with locally-inspired rooms and views of the Gulf of Mexico. Your room charge will be paid prior to your arrival. The remaining balance of taxes (12.5%) and facility fee ($51 resort fee + 12.5% tax + $30 valet fee) will be charged upon arrival.

Guest favourite
A vibrant room features a spacious bed adorned with decorative pillows, set against a botanical wallpaper. Bright yellow curtains frame a window, while a round mirror and artwork add an artistic touch. Two closets are visible on the opposite wall, enhancing the functional space.
Hotel room in Key West
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Marrero's Guest Mansion Adult Only (21+) Room 11

Adult Only Boutique Hotel (21+). Experience the grandeur of their stately Victorian home, thoughtfully updated and lovingly converted into a boutique hotel. We are located in the heart of Old Town, just half a block from Duval Street. This lovely room at the top of the stairs features a pillow top queen bed, private bath, sitting area, and a private balcony.

Popular amenities for Key West boutique hotels

When is the best time to visit Key West?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSeptOctNovDec
Avg. price$622 NZD$938 NZD$707 NZD$580 NZD$663 NZD$495 NZD$517 NZD$425 NZD$370 NZD$433 NZD$599 NZD$646 NZD
Avg. temp21°C22°C24°C25°C27°C29°C30°C30°C29°C27°C25°C23°C

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Florida
  4. Monroe County
  5. Key West
  6. Boutique hotels