Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Madeline Island

Find and book unique Holiday Accommodation with Fire Pit on Airbnb

Top-rated fire pit rentals in Madeline Island

Guests agree: These holiday homes with fire pits are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
A rustic A-frame cabin is set amidst tall trees, featuring a stone pathway leading to a fire pit with stacked logs. Outdoor seating is visible, and a patio umbrella provides shade, enhancing the inviting outdoor space.
Cabin in Herbster
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 258 reviews

South Shore A-Frame | Steps from Lake Superior

A peaceful, feel good place. Renovated rustic modern A-frame on Lake Superior's scenic south shore. Surrounded by evergreen and birch trees in an idyllic woodland setting. Enjoy walks to the beach (1/4th mile down road), breathtaking sunsets and beach bonfires, kayaking the famous seacaves, biking, hiking to waterfalls, shopping for vintage treasures or just relaxing/stargazing in the beautiful private backyard. A perfect home base for exploring the Apostle islands, Bayfield and Madeline Island.

Top Guest favourite
The cabin's striking exterior features large cedar beams and expansive windows, blending seamlessly into the natural surroundings. A screened-in patio offers a view of the woods and lake, while a gas grill is positioned nearby for outdoor dining.
Cabin in Herbster
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Cedar Ridge | Hand-Crafted Cabin with Lake Views

This newly built cabin will take your breath away. You’ll find the perfect blend of Northwoods rustic charm and creature comforts in this 3 bdrm cabin nestled in the woods overlooking Lake Superior’s Bark Bay. You’ll fall in love with all the care & attention its owners have put into every detail. From the stunning cedar beams that provide the backdrop to the incredible lake views to the hand-crafted interior woodwork and the beautiful kitchen, you will see how unique and special this cabin is.

Top Guest favourite
A private deck features a glass table surrounded by two chairs with cushions, complemented by vibrant planters. In the background, a lush garden blooms with various flowers and greenery, creating an inviting outdoor retreat.
Guest suite in Brule
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

The Bee's Balm

You'll find us tucked in the quiet woods of northern WI near the Brule River. We're remote enough to experience star-filled skies & fireflies, but not far from many premier attractions. Your space is a self-contained apartment on the lower level of our 2.5 story home. It features a private entry, queen-sized bed, kitchenette, lower level private deck, access our beautiful grounds & more! We're a family of artists who love to travel & to introduce others to our beautiful part of the world.

Top Guest favourite
Cottage in Bayfield
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Superior Sanctuary: Refined Rustic in the Woods

Escape to the tranquil shores of Lake Superior in our charming retreat! Nestled within the serene Brickyard Creek Community, this modern haven offers a perfect blend of rustic elegance and contemporary comforts.  Immerse yourself in nature's beauty, unwind on the spacious screened porch, and cozy up by the fireplace. Your peaceful escape awaits. • Screened Porch with Swing Chairs • Access to Beach and Hiking Trails • Smart TV & Streaming • Modern Kitchen  • Boat Slip Rental Available

Top Guest favourite
The cabin's exterior displays a modern A-frame design, surrounded by a lush forest. The patio area features blue adirondack chairs and a small table, inviting relaxation amidst nature. A circular window enhances the aesthetic, creating a connection between indoor and outdoor spaces.
Cabin in Bayfield
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 223 reviews

The Acorn of Little Sand Bay Dog Friendly

Modern-rustic, Aframe on 10 wooded acres; beautiful, simple décor, fully equipped kitchen, glass stove top, air-fryer oven, filtered H2O/ice maker. Enjoy a luxurious bathroom, with a heated tile floor, walk-in shower. Towels, shampoo/conditioner/bodywash are provided. King bed in loft and NEW king gel memory foam bed on main floor. Smart TV, wi-fi. Woodstove heats the cabin perfectly as the main heat source. All wood is provided for woodstove and firepit. There is a minisplit heat/ac unit.

Guest favourite
Guesthouse in Cornucopia
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 363 reviews

Sky Fire | Lake Superior Waterfront Retreat

Relax with expansive views of Lake Superior as you bask in the glow of the wood burning fireplace's radiance. Waves echoing off the brownstone cliff upon which this special home is perched, absorb the splendor of bald eagles soaring only feet away. Minutes from your nest is Meyer's Beach, the common entry point to begin your kayak or hiking excursion to the sea and ice caves of this, the greatest of all lakes. Bike, hiking, motorsports and XC ski trails abound. Rest or play. It's all here.

Superhost
A spacious cabin nestled among trees showcases large peaked windows and a welcoming deck. Sunlight filters through the leaves, illuminating the cabin's wooden exterior and the surrounding forest foliage.
Cabin in La Pointe
4.84 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

7 Pines La Pointe on Madeline Island

Looking for Island serenity? Instant Book 7 Pines La Pointe on Madeline Island today! Come see how this 2 bedroom/2 bath cabin, tucked in the woods close to beaches, town and the golf course, offers tranquility and peace in one of the more far away desired destinations in all of the country. Beautiful high peaked windows and glass doors, with a very large deck located in a forest of trees on the picturesque/historic Madeline Island, which can give guests a feeling of going back in time.

Top Guest favourite
A charming red cottage is nestled among tall trees, showcasing a welcoming front with two white Adirondack chairs placed on a natural surface. Decorative flower arrangements hang near the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and plants.
Guesthouse in Ashland
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 411 reviews

Norrsken Scandinavian Cottage

The guest cottage is painted to resemble a Scandinavian retreat. Complete with separate bedroom, extra fold-out sofa queen bed, kitchenette, wood burning stove, WiFi (the best we can find but not great!!!) and large television (DirecTV), it is a great getaway for a couple or a family. Owners live on property if you need anything. If you are a bit adventurous, we can put up a tent right next to Lake Superior. The entire property is smoke free. For a quiet stay, no snowmobiles or ATVs.

Top Guest favourite
Cottage in Cornucopia
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Borealis Cottage by Siskiwit Bay

Borealis Cottage sits on a 2-acre, private, wooded lot in the sustainably designed Sawgrass Community of Cornucopia. Light-filled cottage with open floor plan includes a sleeping loft, screened porch, gas fireplace, and fully-equipped kitchen. A quick, quiet walk from the cottage takes you to a private wooded path with access to Cornucopia Beach on Siskiwit Bay. Explore the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore--our cottage is located 4 miles from Meyers Beach and 20 miles from Bayfield.

Top Guest favourite
A sitting area features a futon draped with a cozy blanket, complemented by colorful accent pillows. A spacious bed with a patterned coverlet is positioned nearby, while a countertop with bar stools creates an inviting space for dining or gathering.
Tiny home in Saxon
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 307 reviews

Parker Creek Tiny House

Come stay on our hobby farm with us! We are in a great central location to multiple hiking trails and gorgeous falls. We have had many guests visit the sea caves in Cornucopia, spend the day in Bayfield, or hike the Porcupine Mountains. We also are only a few miles from the ATV trails if you would rather spend the day riding the trails. We have multiple places to mountain bike or kayak. We have more things to do listed in our details section! Feel free to message me with questions.

Guest favourite
A geodesic dome is situated on a grassy clearing, surrounded by trees. The structure features large, clear panels that provide sweeping views of the outdoors. A chimney rises from the dome's top, suggesting a wood stove for warmth.
Dome in Bayfield
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Twisting Twig Gardens and Orchard Geodesic Dome

Our rustic glamping dome offers a sweet retreat in the woods about 10 miles outside of Bayfield. We are located on a small working organic farm with vegetable gardens, apple trees, and rustic accommodations. We are close to great outdoor recreation near Lake Superior and are about 6 miles from Meyers Beach in the Apostle Islands National Lakeshore. Our property is located on 40 acres and is very remote. We are on the edge of thousands of acres of county land. The perfect escape!

Guest favourite
A living area features a navy blue sofa paired with a rustic wooden coffee table. A television is mounted on the wall, and light streams in through a sliding glass door leading to a balcony. A dining area with a small table is also visible.
Condo in Bayfield
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 306 reviews

One Minute Walk to Lake Superior. Brookside #3

Amazing location! Strong Wifi updated in May 2026. This Condo sleeps 4, King bed & Queen air matress. Full kitchen, balcony, AC, CableTV, fire pit wood povided. Restaurant, bar and pool in July, Aug, Sept. Bayfield is a 2.3 mile hike or bike on the Brownstone Trail. 5 minutes from Mt Ashwabay, Big Top, Bayview beach and multiple hiking trails. Ride a ferry ride to Madeline or cruise the Apostles. Sail, fish, kayak, golf, ski. $50 pet fee per stay. 🙂 No smoking allowed.

Popular amenities for Madeline Island Holiday Accommodation with Fire Pit