Holiday houses in Plum Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Plum Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top Guest favourite
Home in East Hampton
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Serene ~ 1 block to water ~ Large pool + privacy

Top 5% Airbnb properties! Escape to your serene, chic, Hamptons oasis. Perfectly located 1 block to waterfront dining + minutes to Main St Enjoy the luxury of your own home nestled in serenity + nature. You'll feel the calmness + zen @ this private property. Swim in your pool, BBQ + spark up the firepit. Walk just 1 block to Sisi, Buongiorno + Wayan for dinner, cocktails + coffee on the water… an ideal spot to watch the yachts + sunset. You'll be 8 mins. to Main St. shopping, beaches + more!

Guest favourite
The cabin exterior features natural wood siding and a large arch window. A gravel pathway leads up to the entrance, surrounded by landscaped greenery. The serene setting is complemented by tall trees, providing a sense of privacy and seclusion.
Cabin in Montauk
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 491 reviews

Tiny Cottage in Hither Woods, Montauk

A little cabin on our property in Hither Woods. A cozy hideaway conveniently located 12 minutes walk from Gurney's Beach Resort, 16 minute walk from public path to beach, and 6 minutes drive from Montauk town for restaurants and nightlife. Good for couples and solo adventurers, the space is private and homey, with outdoor shower and Chimenea fire pit. The main house is 65ft away, but we honor your privacy. The cottage comes with WiFi, window A/C and complimentary coffee or tea. Parking for 1 car

Top Guest favourite
A tranquil lake scene is captured at sunrise, featuring a wooden dock extending into the water. Soft pink and orange hues reflect on the lake's surface, complementing the surrounding greenery. Two Adirondack chairs sit near a fire pit, inviting relaxation by the scenic view.
Home in East Haddam
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 305 reviews

Romantic Getaway at The Lake!

Beautiful year round getaway! Relax and have a glass of wine by the lake. Wake early to enjoy the sun rising directly over the lake with a fresh cup of coffee. Enjoy direct lake access on a trophy bass lake including a beautiful dock. Hot tub overlooking the water open year round. Enjoy dinner in front of beautiful gas fireplace. Amazing sunrises and colorful sunsets. The location and amenities make for a fantastic romantic getaway for two! Centrally located 30 minutes from the Mohegan Casino.

Top Guest favourite
A charming wooden octagonal structure surrounded by lush green trees, with vibrant autumn leaves overhead. There are several outdoor tables and chairs arranged on a gravel area nearby, offering a peaceful setting close to the brook.
Tiny home in Norwich
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 932 reviews

Water Forest Retreat -Octagon

Water Forest retreat is a very private 122ft.² electrified and heated cedar octagon next to a brook on 56 acres of forest with a pond, waterfall, marsh and hiking trails. Cozy up in this quiet comfortable space while listening to Goldmine brook while you sleep. Fire pit, heated outhouse with composting toilet, outdoor dining area, brook, pond and trail head are just steps away. We also have a TREE HOUSE and HIKER’S HAVEN house by the brook. Please click on our profile picture to read more.

Top Guest favourite
A balcony view captures a serene beachfront scene at sunset, with gentle waves lapping at the sandy shore. A detailed metal chair is positioned on the deck, providing a quiet spot to enjoy the tranquil waters and cloudy sky.
Home in East Lyme
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Beachfront Paradise

Beautiful beachfront home available weekly in season (6/20/26-9/5/26) and nightly (2 night min.) off season. Step out the door and into the sand. Sit on the porch and watch sailboat races from Niantic Bay Yacht Club just steps away. Close to downtown Niantic with restaurants, shops, movie theatre, etc. 18 miles from Mohegan Sun Casino. Attractions within 1/2 hour: Beautiful Mystic, CT, several vineyards, Harkness State Park, Eugene O'Neill Theatre, U.S. Coast Guard Academy, golf courses.

Top Guest favourite
Guest suite in Stonington
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 360 reviews

Morgan Suite - spacious | hot tub | water views!

The Morgan Suite is a private Airbnb located in a quiet neighborhood along the Pawcatuck River. Just minutes to downtown Westerly, downtown Mystic, beaches, breweries, wineries, shops, restaurants and much more. This Airbnb a perfect for a romantic getaway or a relaxing memorable vacation with a friend. If you are looking to explore a new area and relax, the Morgan Suite is for you! The home is spacious, newly renovated with excellent amenities. Newly added - hot tub and massage chair!

Top Guest favourite
The exterior of the historic barn is featured, showcasing weathered wood siding and a welcoming entrance with double doors. The structure is surrounded by trees and a gravel pathway leading to the front door. Soft morning light highlights the natural beauty of the setting.
Barn in Essex
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

River Barn, Sidewalk Stroll into Essex Village

The Coolest Airbnb in Connecticut (Conde Nast Traveler 2021) The barn is a perfect retreat. Ideal for those looking to take a break from city life or those working remotely. Would also make for a lovely place to call home while you are selling or renovating your own home. Couples, two good friends, singles, or a family with an older child will enjoy the configuration. It will also make for a lovely getaway for a couple with a newborn.

Top Guest favourite
Tall trees frame a serene view of the Mystic River, reflecting the surrounding greenery. Gentle ripples on the water's surface contrast with the lush tidal marsh and grasslands in the distance, creating a peaceful natural setting.
Home in Mystic
5 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Waterfront Retreat on the Mystic River

This kayakers paradise is a waterfront home secluded on 2.5 wooded acres along the Mystic River. Views of the water, tidal marsh, woods, and wildlife are constantly changing. Owned by two designers, this home’s modern aesthetic has interesting art, objects, furniture, lighting & textiles. Dine & relax on the porch, paddle kayaks on the river, walk on the scenic road into downtown Mystic, or visit nearby beaches and family destinations.

Top Guest favourite
The living area features a vaulted ceiling with bright natural light streaming through large windows. A cozy seating arrangement includes a light grey couch and a comfortable chair. A stylized coffee table sits in the center, with a dining table set for two nearby.
Cottage in East Lyme
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 309 reviews

Your Nest Near The Beach

Welcome to A Shore Thing, a retro modern beach cottage. This bright and cheerful escape is perfectly located for exploring the shoreline. Whether you are visiting in the summer for sun, surf and sand or in the quieter off-season, you will find the shoreline is packed with an incredible array of inviting destinations. The cottage is just 3/4 of a mile from the beautiful private sandy beach.

Top Guest favourite
A rustic fireplace with a brick chimney is set against a whitewashed wall, surrounded by greenery. A cozy propane stove emits warmth, complementing the inviting interior. A decorative area rug enhances the space, while a wooden table sits nearby, adorned with books and a glass.
Guesthouse in Stonington
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 329 reviews

The Dacha at the Mystic Farmhouse

A Historic Artist’s Retreat Near Downtown Mystic Lovingly known as The Dacha for nearly 80 years, this one-of-a-kind gem was built in 1945 as a studio for the artist who once called the property home. Fully insulated for cozy winter stays, the unique structure is tucked away on a peaceful piece of land, just five minutes from downtown Mystic.

Top Guest favourite
Tiny home in East Lyme
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Lakeside Serenity Tiny House

Embrace Lakeside Serenity Unwind in our cozy tiny home at The Island RV Park, right on Pattagansett Lake. A retreat for relaxation, with a queen bed, full amenities, and fast Wi-Fi. Perfect for romantic escapes or peaceful solo retreats. Help yourself to our shared kayaks and watercraft (available May - Oct) to get out on the water!

Top Guest favourite
The farmhouse, constructed in 1856, is showcased with its classic white exterior and black accents. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, while lush greenery surrounds the property. A pebble pathway leads to the entrance, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.
Home in Old Lyme
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews

Modern Farmhouse with Hot Tub in Old Lyme, CT

Originally built in 1856 this farmhouse has been lovingly restored with stylish and modern amenities for a perfect vacation getaway. Nestled in the heart of downtown, historic Old Lyme the property is convenient to shops, restaurants and local shoreline activities including water sports and hiking.

Popular amenities for Plum Island holiday rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Southold
  6. Plum Island