The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island
The Case-Jennings House on Shelter Island
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
1 bath
You won’t be charged yet

The Case-Jennings House is a beautiful Shelter Island gem. "Anna's Cottage" was built in 1847 and stands proudly as one of the island's oldest homes.
In the same family for four generations, this two-bedroom treasure was newly renovated and restored in 2017. It is dressed in contemporary farmhouse decor and located within one mile of restaurants, shops, the beach, ferry and a golf course. This immaculate and comfortable space is ready to welcome you to the simpler way of Shelter Island life.


Amenities
Kitchen
Wireless Internet
Free parking on premises
Indoor fireplace

Prices
Extra people No Charge
Cleaning Fee $185 NZD
Security Deposit $1480 NZD
Weekly Discount: 29%
Always communicate through Airbnb
To protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.
Learn more

Sleeping arrangements
Bedroom 1
1 queen bed
Bedroom 2
1 queen bed

House Rules
No smoking
Not suitable for pets
No parties or events
Check in time is 3PM - 12AM (midnight)

Cancellations

Safety features
Smoke detector
Carbon monoxide detector
First aid kit
Safety card
Fire extinguisher

Availability
2 nights minimum stay

18 Reviews

Accuracy
Communication
Cleanliness
Location
Check In
Value
Michael User Profile
October 2017
Florence was a great host. All communication was clear and easy. House is in immaculate condition. A perfect size for 4 or so people to stay.
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
It was a pleasure welcoming Michael and his guests to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island. They were considerate, respectful, tidy and clean. Without hesitation, I would welcome them again! Super Guests! Florence
October 2017

Lauren User Profile
October 2017
Anna's cottage is absolutely perfect in every way. It's beautifully furnished, cozy and comfortable and stocked with everything you need. Florence's communication is great! The deli next door is a plus for breakfast and sandwiches. We only stayed for the weekend after visiting th…
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
Lauren and her family were a pleasure to host. They were respectful, considerate tidy and clean, keeping the house in perfect order. I would welcome them again without hesitation! Super Guests!
October 2017

Annie User Profile
October 2017
Adorable little cottage with a modern rustic vibe. Beautifully chic white walls and details with little pops of colors. Warm big broad floor boards. Tons if light. Easy drive to ferry (probably wouldn't walk - no sidewalks). Most comfortable mattresses ever! Will 100% stay here a…
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
It was a pleasure welcoming Annie and her guests to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island. They were quiet, considerate, tidy and clean. I would welcome them again without hesitation! Super Guests! Florence
October 2017

John User Profile
September 2017
Beautiful place with everything you need to have a great time on the island
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
Welcoming and hosting John, Gretchen and Eileen to my grandparent's home and Shelter Island was a pleasure. They were friendly, quiet, considerate, tidy and clean. I would welcome them again without hesitation! Super Guests! Florence
September 2017

Alexander User Profile
September 2017
Perfect from check in to check out. Great location, clean/cozy home, nice back yard and everything you could possibly need is provided. Location is ideal, 5 minutes from greenport ferry, 1 minute from great beach and amazing food (eat at the flying goat, you won't be disappointed…
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
It was with great pleasure being your host and being able to share something so special to me; my grandparent's home and Shelter Island. I am thrilled your stay was special and hope you return some day! Florence
September 2017

Matt User Profile
September 2017
Staying at Florence's is an excellent way to see shelter Island. The house is centrally located and really allows you to orient yourself to getting around the island. You are walking distance from Crescent Beach, a short car ride or bike ride from smaller, hidden beaches along Pe…
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
Matt and Abby are a lovely couple who were a pleasure to host. They were quiet, considerate, tidy and clean. I would welcome them again without hesitation! Super Guests! Florence
September 2017

Debbie User Profile
September 2017
Fabulous rental, clean as can be, nice furnishings, close to everything. Everything was exactly like the pictures and more. Besides being clean and pretty, there were fresh flowers in the rooms to nice dishes, pots and pans even Saran Wrap. Needless to say - way above expectati…
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response from Florence A:
It was a pleasure welcoming Debbie and her family to my house and Shelter Island for their first Airbnb experience. They are a lovely family who were quiet, considerate, tidy and clean. I would welcome them again without hesitation! Super Guests! Florence
September 2017

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United StatesJoined in May 2017
Florence A User ProfileFlorence A is a superhost.
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within an hour

The neighbourhood

Similar listings