Living RoomDining area
Restored Vintage Modernist Gem
Restored Vintage Modernist Gem
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
2 baths
4 guests
2 bedrooms
2 beds
2 baths
You won’t be charged yet

Unique Vintage 60's modern completely restored w/ magical pool overlooking 2.3 acres of peace and privacy on Lily Pond. The house is in close proximity to the South/North Ferry, Vine Street Cafe, Sag Harbor and Greenport. Come swim, chill and relax. Please inquire about length of stay as the Town of Shelter Island has new short term rental rules that require a 2 week minimum stay.

The space

Privacy, setting and unique architecture.

Guest access

Boating, Beach, Swimming, Fine Dining. Most anything you can imagine.

Other things to note

Higher rates apply for summer months and holiday weekends. Please inquire. Pets will be considered individually and if accepted there will be a $150 non-refundable per pet fee.


Cable TV
Air conditioning

House Rules
No smoking
Not suitable for pets
No parties or events
Check in is anytime after 3PM
Check out by 11AM

Respect and appreciation for home and furnishings. Have a great time!

NOTES for care of house:

There are chaise cushions(black) as well the orange cloth covers for the buffer fly chairs by the BBQ area in the grey shed right side. Open barn slider and then door.

A few things to that are important to the house:

My home is non-smoking. As per the nature of the untreated clear cedar throughout the home, special attention should be given to make sure it is not touched with anything that might stain them. In particular oil or lotions of any kind. Same applies for the concrete counters in both the kitchen and bathrooms . Please put anything oily or greasy, wine, etc or anything that could stain the grey tile cutting boards. Thank you.

Please do not put anything wet on the dining table or any wood surface in the house as it will stain the veneer. Please use wooden coasters.

At the end of your stay please put black
chaise cushions and orange cloth butterfly chair covers back in the grey shed and close entrance wooden driveway doors.


5 Reviews

Check In
Maryana User Profile
September 2016
Upon arrival Joseph had fresh flowers/greenery in every room and left a lovely surprise of a Birthday treat even with candles, fresh fruit, sparkling wine and water! Truly special and really kind. The action of kindness was not wasted and the house was a perfect space to escape the craziness of the city and feel enveloped by nature and the view. I would go back again...

Cat User Profile
August 2016
Really fantastic home. Beautiful inside and out. Wonderful interior design and attention to detail. The views are spectacular. Joseph was great with communication. There was an issue with the air conditioning and although it had not been fixed during our stay (which was a weekend) Joseph was very communicative and helpful.

Adriaan User Profile
July 2015
Joseph is a very responsive and polite host who made it easy to rent the house. While the house is beautifully designed with a need to be careful with wooden tables, and concrete countertops I was told it was fine for a family with children (2, 11 and 14). The house was very comfortable and cozy, and quiet, and the older children loved the design. There is a great cabana that can be used a bedroom. The pool and the garden with the view are also beautiful, and we loved sitting out at night at the fire pit listening to frogs and what have you... I would certainly recommend this place to others.

Jeremy User Profile
July 2015
Loved our stay at Joseph's home on Shelter Island. The view from the pool is like being in a Monet painting! Everything was as described and pictured and Joseph was very quick to respond during correspondence.

William User Profile
July 2014
This place really is a gem. Beautifully restored and with amazing attention to detail. The place is small but well laid out. Its worth a visit just to see the great interior design job Joseph has done. Feels private even though other houses are close by and a great view of a large pond. Located in centre of Shelter Island. Joseph responded fast to my emails and questions and was very helpful.

This host has 2 reviews for other properties.

View other reviews
New York, New York, United StatesJoined in March 2014
Joseph User Profile
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within a few hours

The neighbourhood

Similar listings