Skip to content
The pool is brand new, gets lots of sunlight and is super refreshing.  The pool is completely private and right off the deck, for super fun bbq and swimming days.A photo of the brand new pool, not heated but very refreshing, take a plunge!
Entire cottage

Shelter Island Cottage with pool and fenced yard

Shelter Island Cottage with pool and fenced yard

6 guests
4 bedrooms
5 beds
2 baths
6 guests
4 bedrooms
5 beds
2 baths

The space

This sunny cottage with a pool is perfect for any cosmopolitan looking to get away from it all. However, high speed internet and cable TV means you are never too far away.....

Enjoy this summer wonderland, cozy up by the fireplace at night, BBQ outside or cook indoors. Take your loved ones to the beach every day on Sheter Island or to East Hampton (only short drive away) or enjoy dinners on the island or in Sag Harbor.

Enjoy delicious summer luxe dining at The Vine on the island or the new locavore Isola restaurant with fresh ingredients from the East End.

This 4 bedroom near St. Mary's has it all. The open living, dining and kitchen has lovely Mexican tile and a floor to ceiling brick fireplace.

En Suite master and smaller bedroom complete the first floor of this adorable Holiday cottage. The basement has two additional bedrooms with a queen size bed and one twin bed. House is completely fenced to keep your loved ones safe inside and the deer outside of your home. The cottage is situated on a peaceful cul de sac road, just a short bike ride to town or the beach. Take Sunset walks at Mashomack Preserve and enjoy the nature that Shelter Island has to offer.

Please bring your own sheets for your stay.

It is a beautiful, friendly neighborhood with lots of quiet families, so if you are looking to relax and have some peace and quiet, this house if for you! If you live to party and love loud music, this is not the house for you. The noise policy is strictly upheld to maintain quiet, peace and serenity. Garbage and recycling will need to be disposed of before you leave at the town facilities.

The house is yours, you won't see us. However, the noise policy is strictly enforced.

Please bring your own bath, beach and pool towels. Please bring your own sheets. Also, trash and recyclables need to be taken with you after your visit. Please respect the community, it is a quiet neighborhood, please keep the noise level down. NO SMOKING!


Free parking on premises
Cable TV

Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1
1 queen bed
Bedroom 2
2 double beds
Bedroom 3
1 double bed
Bedroom 4
1 single bed

House Rules

No smoking
Not suitable for pets
No parties or events
Check-in is anytime after 12PM (noon)
Check out by 12PM (noon)
Self check-in with lockbox

15 Reviews

Jessica User Profile
August 2017
Lauren's house was perfect for our Shelter Island long summer family weekend. The pool was a treat. And the back deck was an awesome place to grill and enjoy the evenings.
Roya User Profile
September 2016
We had a great stay at Lauren's Shelter Island home. It was very central and convenient. We were attending a wedding, so didn't spend much time in the house, but it was very well equipped with anything that one might need.
Rebecca User Profile
August 2016
Lauren answered any questions immediately and was super helpful to the run up of our holiday. The house was in a quiet street and the neighbours were really friendly. The photographs are an accurate view of the house and the swimming pool. We had a super time on Ginny Drive.
Juan User Profile
July 2016
We loved our stay at Lauren's summer cottage with my family. Lauren was very communicative, answered all our questions and in good time. We found the house to be even better in real life than in the pics posted, the pool is bigger than it seems in the photos, and the same with …
Christine User Profile
June 2016
Lauren's cozy home on a quiet street was the perfect amount of sun and lounging my friends and I were looking forward to on Shelter Island. The house was spacious, clean, and had all the amenities one could need for a long weekend. The large deck with bbq grill in the backyar…
Jon User Profile
June 2016
The host canceled this reservation 7 days before arrival. This is an automated posting.
Ann User Profile
July 2015
We loved our stay in this beautiful Shelter Island home. It is in a peaceful, lush neighborhood. It was perfect for adults and kids alike. The pool was lovely and used several times a day. The kitchen, dining room and back deck were great for entertaining. I would highly rec…

Hosted by Lauren

New York, New York, United StatesJoined in August 2012
Lauren User Profile
15 Reviews
Can't live without: Shelter Island, Stars Coffee in Shelter Island Heights, Running by Sunset Beach, Dinner at Vine and Pilates at Dering Harbor Inn. Can't live without the ferry to Sag Harbor, East Hampton, Bridge Hampton....
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within an hour
Always communicate through AirbnbTo protect your payment, never transfer money or communicate outside of the Airbnb website or app.

The neighbourhood

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check In

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Check Out
You won’t be charged yet

Similar listings