Holiday rentals with a kayak in Spanish Wells

Thanks for letting us stay in the lovely one bedroom studio. Everything was clean and fresh. Just like the photographs. It was easy to communicate with June, she was super helpful. Responded within 4 hrs typically. The walk to Gaulding’s Cay beach is only 3 minutes from the cottage. The beach is gorgeous with crystal clear water in a lovely cove. We used the paddle boards a couple of times and went out to the big rock. Great swimming and super quiet. My husband wanted to fly fish, but no fish scene at this spot. I’d definitely recommend Daddy-Joes restaurant, Taco Tuesday. An easy walk from the cottage. Good food and more reasonable than other restaurants. Live music some evenings as well which was fun.

We loved our stay at Mark and Susan's place. They provided lots of info in advance to help with directions, what to do's, where to go, etc. House was amazing, and Eleuthera was beautiful, peaceful and relaxing. Locals were friendly and delightful to interact with - as were the sea turtles! Would love to visit again and will be sure to come in pineapple season (best ever!).

We loved our week at Serendipity! The view from the porch is gorgeous, the interior was comfy and cozy and had everything you needed. The location is central to the island, and the stairs into the ocean were awesome. We hope to be back soon!

We enjoyed having a private beach with an amazing view. It was an easy drive to the ferries. We recommend getting a car. The house manager, Agatha, and the hosts were very quick to respond to any questions prior to and during our stay. 5 of us stayed comfortably.

Amazing place to stay in Eleuthera. Absolutely stunning panoramic views of the ocean, and great living space with everything you need. Very well equipped kitchen which is appreciated as we cooked most of our meals, and a gas stove that came in handy as we could still use during an island-wide power outage (there was only one during our stay). Local caretaker (Derrick) was a phenomenal help, even helping my husband and I track down some local fish and lobster to cook. Would definitely stay here again!

Blue Moon was an absolutely amazing right on the Beach at Gaulding Cay Beach. There are no other rentals directly on the beach here. The water was amazing crystal clear just a few steps through the coconut tree. (Not many bugs) We used the SUP and double kayak one afternoon. And everyday we snorkeled the rock everyday. Hanging out listening to the water and coconut trees in a hammock was extremely relaxing. The house has loads of books and a great collection of art. Daddy Joes was just a short walk down the road. Gregory town is just a 4 minute ride in the car. We are looking forward to our next stay. I am dreaming about that beach and hammock!!

We really enjoyed our time at Siren Song as we celebrated our friends getting married at the Other Side Hotel. We chose this place based on its proximity to the resort (walkable during low tide) but ended up so happy with the space. The beach access is perfect, we often felt like it was a private beach just for our party. We watched plenty of sea turtles, birds, and rays. We took the paddle boards out every morning and cooked several meals at home. We were greeted every time we returned by two sweet kitties who even followed us down to the beach. We were a very short drive to lots of beautiful sights - twin sisters beach and queens bath were our favorites. The area was buggy but Dani provided bug spray with the home. Lots of clean towels and we enjoyed some puzzles during down time. Checking in and out was a breeze. Thanks for a wonderful stay. We all agreed we had it much better than the folks paying a lot more down at the resort!

Three little birds is absolutely magical. The house has so much charm, is decorated with so much love and comforted all our needs. We loved waking up hearing the birds, drinking coffee in the garden and watching the sunset from the roof terrace. The location was fantastic, away from the craziness but literally 5 min walking to get somewhere. The beach access was great, the access to ramora bay beach bar and marina was beautiful and the all the helpful tips from Tim made our stay truly incredible. Ow, did i mention the comfortable beds? And perfectly silent working AC? The spacious kitchen en all the boardgames in the livingroom? 5 stars and beyond❤️

This is our second time staying at Buttonwood and it was just as wonderful! The cottage is cozy, clean, and perfectly located. We loved waking up to the ocean breeze and spending our days exploring the island. Marielbys is an amazing host—responsive, kind, and thoughtful. We’re already looking forward to our next visit!

My wife and I just returned from our week at Villa Sorenti. We can say without reservation that this home and surroundings were as close to perfect as we could have hoped. As great as the pictures look, this villa with its breathtaking view of the crystal clear blue Caribbean were even more spectacular in person. Toni & Alex were very helpful, accommodating, and communicative, as was and property manager who lives close by. And the location... Rainbow Bay is the most beautiful part of the island, from what we saw and we did quite a bit of exploring and visited many beautiful spots. Rainbow Bay is also right in the middle of the island, allowing for excursions to the north or south without too much driving. This being our first visit to Eleuthera, we were flying somewhat blind, so we definitely feel like we lucked out in every respect.

really great. everyone is so friendly and helpful

Our family could not have had a better time. Jody’s place did not disappoint and exceeded expectations. Taking my family of 6 to Spanish Wells kids aged 14,13,9,4 (turned 5 on the trip) was quite the adventure with a long journey to arrive. Because of this I had no shortage of questions for Jody. His responses were perfect, thoughtful, made sense, and most of all extremely quick. The house is beautiful, about a 1 minute walk to a beach you feel like is all yours, or 30 seconds if your one of my kids. But the walk was pleasant, peaceful, and was beautifully decorated for Christmas! Lit up wonderfully at night as well. So happy we picked Spanish Wells and could not recommend Turtle Cottage or any of Jody’s cottages on this stretch of heaven. I honestly could go on and on, they were helpful and flexible with travel woes, gave advice that was on point and just good people. Go here and don’t miss opportunity to be here during Christmas.

Fish Fever is a charming waterside bungalow. The accommodations were perfect for a family of four and were exactly as described. We enjoyed lazy days on the beach near the house, fun waterside restaurants, and our nightly helping of Papa’s Scoops! We would strongly recommend booking a charter boat tour, it was the highlight of our trip! Book early if you want to get in with Christy/Shane. All in all, a great trip and we hope to be back!

Wonderful stay, relaxing. Quite neighborhood. There is a nice beach, saw very few people. Rocky so bring your water shoes - like most of Eleuthera. Nothing really to do near by, will need a car.

Gail and Austin were both fantastic hosts. Very responsive and accommodating. The rental was next to their personal home on Russell island. Awesome private water access at the end of their road. Austin showed us around their garden and cut fresh fruit for us to try. The cottage is exactly as shown in the photos. Ac in every bedroom is nice. We really enjoyed our stay and hope to be back!

I’ve stayed here multiple times over the years, and with the recent renovations it’s even more beautiful than ever! Bonnie is super responsive, helpful, and kind. I highly recommend this rental, and will happily stay here again next time I’m in SW.