Cottage holiday rentals in Hither Hills

I had a wonderful weekend at Andrew’s place in East Hampton. It was gorgeous, perfect location, perfect layout, and such a central location to everything. It was incredibly clean and organized and the backyard was beautiful for relaxing. Andrew was also a terrific host- he left us beverages, was super communicative and flexible and I’m so happy I stayed here. Hopefully I’ll rent again soon!!

beautiful house, great location and very nice and peaceful neighborhood close to the beach and the vineyards the house is very well equipped ! Richard was very nice and even find a little bed for our baby boy ! thanks !

Ivana and John are the most wonderful hosts! This was truly like staying at a family cottage and everything was just beautiful. John greeted us upon arrival and even had a bottle of wine for my husbands birthday! We loved staying here from the city because it was only a little over a hour to arrive and less than a hour to South Hampton where we had dinner. Also the little town is so so cute and we were able to walk over so quickly! We can’t wait to stay here again. Thank you again Ivana and John!

The place was charming, quaint, and exactly as described. It had a cozy vibe that made it feel like a home away from home. The location was perfect, with easy access to everything I needed. The host was incredibly responsive and helpful throughout my stay. Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking for an enjoyable experience!

Tabitha's place was perfect for our group stay. Right in the middle of town and perfect for what we needed for the week!

Amy was fantastic from start to finish. The house has four good bedrooms. The bottom floor is very private. Great kitchen and we loved the fact there were cooking basics like olive oil, spices, etc all there.

We had a great stay! The house was pristine and the kitchen was very well stocked. The cottage was very close to beaches, restaurants and grocery stores! I would definitely recommend to anyone looking to get away for a beach vacation!

The beach house was great. Instead of being on a road, it was on a green commons area that gave it a really relaxed neighborly feel. It was a very easy and pleasant 1 minute stroll to the beach, where was a great pastry and shop, and restaurant, and some simply amazing views. Deb's communications were also great and check in went amazingly smoothly. Also the town of New Suffolk itself is quite charming, and is a perfect base for exploring vineyards, beaches, hiking trails and whatnot.

Our visit was utilitarian. We needed accommodations for us, our grown children and grandchildren and a dog. But the site of the cottage, its charm, its comfort made us wish we were staying another week. James' thoughtfulness went beyond any other Airbnb hosts' that we've experienced. Everything we might need if we were staying 10 days was there, clean, labeled. Thank you, James.

Jeanne's place was perfect for my trip to Guilford. Excellent location, close to the Green and to the water, quiet, peaceful. The house had everything I needed and more, Jeanne was super responsive and kind, and the bed was comfortable.

Erin Leigh’s cottage was everything we hoped for and more. She was proactive, responsive, and kind from the start — making sure everything was smooth before and during our stay. The setting is peaceful, cozy, and thoughtfully designed, with unique touches throughout the home. It was the perfect base for exploring both the eastern and western sides of the North Fork — whether by bike or by car. We loved how close it was to town, beaches, and vineyards, yet still felt tucked away and relaxing. Truly a gem. Highly recommend!

Angela was a great host and very accommodating after an unfortunate personal event we encountered just after arriving. The cottage was very comfortable and immaculately clean. Love the keyless entry. Neighborhood is quiet and we felt extremely safe. Deer pass through the yard throughout the day and what's more beautiful than that!!! We absolutely recommend Angela as a host and would not hesitate to book again in the future.

Meghan's place is exactly as posted it is absolutely beautiful, cozy, comfortable and did I say beautiful? one of my favorite things to do was sit in front of the big windows and read. You have everything you can think of close, at least 4 to 6 minutes away. There are restaurants, super market and pharmacies. But if you are like me and also like to cook sometimes on vacation the kitchen was equipped with everything you need. Highly, highly recommend.

We absolutely loved Michael's cottage. It is a ~15 minute walk from the village and is on a quiet street. The cottage feels like a beach house but is very well appointed and homey. We loved our stay and would absolutely stay here again!

Meredith’s cottage in Jamesport is the perfect North Fork getaway—spacious yet quaint, with incredible charm. The beach views are spectacular, offering peaceful sunrises and relaxing evenings. Meredith was a fantastic host—super attentive, thoughtful, and made us feel right at home. The location couldn’t be better: quiet and serene, yet close to everything from wineries and farm stands to local restaurants. It’s a quintessential North Fork home, and we can’t wait to return.

Great, beachy location within easy driving distance of a bunch of great waterfront restaurants. Easy, clean, and very comfortable.

I stayed at Margaret’s place over Memorial Day weekend, and everything was perfect. The property is beautiful and surrounded by greenery, making it a peaceful and relaxing escape. Margaret was an exceptional host who truly made us feel welcome. She even invited us to join her family for a Memorial Day barbecue, which was a special and memorable experience. We had a wonderful time and I would absolutely recommend staying here! Thanks Margaret!

Susan is a fantastic host and the cottage is a lovely place to stay. Steps from the beach and a quick drive into town plus pool access right out your door. Susan was great to interact with. We definitely plan to come back.

I had a wonderful relaxing time in this charming, well-apportioned cottage. There is a beautiful view over the marsh to short beach and it’s a great spot to see local birds - herons, red-winged blackbirds, etc. A trolley line that’s been converted to a hiking trail runs through the marsh and makes for a great walk. Lots of other fun walks nearby. it’s very quiet and cozy but still just a quick 10 minute jaunt to New Haven The piano and turntable were neat features and the house was nicely maintained and decorated. You can tell the host is very attentive to detail and committed to keeping things pristine. He was also super friendly and responsive I would gladly return to this spot next time Im in the area and heartily recommend to anyone looking to relax and recharge

My family were coming to the commencement so we stayed at John’s place for several days. The house is at a very quiet place surrounded by woods yet easy to find from the main road, and has easy access to I-95. The house was bigger than we thought and can accommodate six or even more people. It has everything we need like dishwasher, washer and dryer, etc. John also kindly provided grounded coffee and drinks in the fridge. It was an excellent experience!

I can’t say enough wonderful things about this spot and Monika. This is our second stay- my husband, toddler, dog and I loved it last summer and came back. The back sliding doors open onto a porch where birds chirp and visit all day. The bright green lawn under towering trees is perfect for playtime or a family picnic. Little touches of thoughtfulness and charm are just everywhere. Monika’s hospitality is unparalleled- snacks and a handwritten note upon arrival, homemade treats throughout our stay, and nearly instant responses. Without being asked, she even sent us a hand-drawn walking route for a dog and baby and directions for getting there. Beaches, playgrounds, town centers, bagels etc are a short drive. The street is busy so wouldn’t go for a nearby walk necessarily but thats pretty standard throughout the Hamptons. For parents of young kids: FYI there isn’t laundry, but truthfully I just packed more- that’s how much we liked it. A laundromat is also nearby tho!