Cottage holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

Karen’s place is a beautiful location right on the lake! The space was pristine and Karen was so kind and accommodating!

Karen communicated well and was extremely accommodating. She had great suggestions for our stay. I’d likely stay here again.

Your home was beautiful. From the moment we walked in we could smell how clean it was. Everything was spotless and it was very warm and cozy. The backyard is adorable! They have done a great job with this place. We really enjoyed our stay and had no issues. Walkable to restaurants and coffee shops. Great location! Highly recommend.

This place rocks! Karen and her husband did a phenomenal job of reimagining this space and turning into a destination. All the units are well thought out and furnished with everything you might need. The pool and hot tubs were huge hit with my boys, along with the generous amounts of pool floats available to use. The location is perfect, with one of the best views in all of Catawba. Sipping coffee on the porch swing every morning, as you look out at the lake was bliss. You can sit in the hot tub or on one of the many deck chairs and have a perfect location for the sunset every night. As someone who comes to Catawba frequently -- there is no competition for this place. I wish I could keep it all to my self -- and not tell everyone how good it is, as I fear soon this place will be sold out for the foreseeable future.

We had a wonderful stay at the Love Shack. Great amenities, place was as described and more. Everything was set up for us when we got there and was a great location for a wonderful little place just outside of downtown Port Clinton but close enough to walk to anywhere downtown. 10/10 would stay again!

We arrived late and left early on our trip cross country, so didn't get to enjoy to beauty of being on this lake, but appreciated the location and the comfortable accomodations.

Cottage in sandusky is a great place to stay and within walking distance of 2 restaurants. Quiet neighborhood. Open lot next to house is great for parking a boat or extra vehicles. House was clean and had plenty of amenities.

We enjoyed our stay, and despite the chilly weather, the kids enjoyed the pool and hot tub! Karen was an absolute pleasure to work with. Our cottage was newly renovated and just like the description. We look forward to coming back soon!

This little cottage exceeded our expectations. We immediately felt right at home and the neighborhood is so charming. We walked to the gazebo every night at sunset, definitely a must do if you stay here! Only about a 10 minute drive to cedar point which was the main reason for our stay. We would absolutely stay here again!

Melissa was wonderful. Will stay again.

House was clean and comfortable. Our family enjoyed staying here.

We stayed here before. Great place! Great host!

Peaceful cottage right on the beach with the sunrise to welcome your morning. Friendly people in the neighborhood. Great value, especially if you occupy all three rooms. I appreciated that the host met me on the premises to give a brief overview and thanked me for my business. Guidebook was very helpful. Lot of amenities provided. Unfortunately, I did not read the part about the garbage removal in a timely fashion, and the waste transfer station was closed when I left, so I took the garbage with me. Thankfully it was not much and I had my car.

Terry's home was perfect for our family and pets. Comfortable, clean, and stocked with all of the amenities we needed. Terry was super helpful and even sent some helpful info a few days prior to our arrival. He lives close by, and is readily available for any issues (we had none). We look forward to our stay next summer!

"This Old Lake House" was just what we needed for our R&R and visit to the area. Perfectly located as our base of operations during our visit. The house was clean and the charm that made our stay so enjoyable. Linda the host was always responsive to our messages. Thank you!

I stayed here for a week to attend the Biggest Week in American Birding Festival. I found the space comfortable and it suited my needs well. Elliott was responsive and kind. We did not meet, but he responded promptly when I notified him about an issue with the water heater and fixed it as soon as he was able. I was particularly impressed with his respect for my privacy since he needed to enter the house during my stay. Thanks, Elliott!

The house was very nice and well supplied. The fire pit and red chairs were beautiful. Andrea was very responsive and helpful!

Thank you so much! Had a great time!

We had a wonderful stay at this cozy cottage near Lakeside and Marblehead! From the moment we walked in, it felt like home — everything was spotless, and the amenities were truly top-notch. You can tell Amber put a lot of care into the space and they genuinely want their guests to enjoy their stay. Communication was excellent throughout the entire process, from booking to check-out. The location is great — close to both Lakeside and downtown Marblehead. While it’s walkable, be aware that you’ll need to use the main road, which can have a fair amount of traffic. We opted to drive and also rented a golf cart from Moke America Ohio, which made getting around super easy (and fun!). We would absolutely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a comfortable and convenient spot in the area!

Lisa’s place was exactly what we looked for. It was easy driving distance to cedar point as well as Cleveland. The neighborhood was very quiet and welcoming. Everything was very comfortable for our three night stay. Lisa was very communicative during our stay to make sure we had the best night possible. I’d highly recommend her as a host!

We had a wonderful stay Everything was so clean and the beds were super comfy. The cottage had absolutely everything we needed as far as an equipped kitchen. The fire pit made for a great night of marshmallow roasting. The deck gave great views of the lake and both sunrise and sunsets were beautiful. We would definitely love to come back , in fact we didn’t want to leave!!

Cindy was lovely and very friendly, felt right at home at the cottage which is well appointed and very close to the beach as an added bonus. thank you.

Great island house for family. House was very clean and spacious. Communication with owner was also good. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay!

Nice location, feels like a cottage: ideal for a few nights.