Holiday houses in Lake Poygan

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Lake Poygan

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top Guest favourite
A rustic log cabin is surrounded by greenery, featuring a charming wraparound porch with steps leading up to it. The exterior displays wooden beams and a welcoming front, while a small fence encloses the area, creating a cozy, nature-integrated ambiance.
Farm stay in New London
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 188 reviews

Irish Acres Farm Charm Glamping: FAIRY CABIN

Irish Acres Farm is host to guest friendly activities. Sit & relax or join in farm chores, hike, fish, meditate. Light a camp fire and enjoy Nature at her finest. Experience the coziness of a rustic "tiny house" off-grid log FAIRY CABIN set beside a 1 acre spring fed pond. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, & families (with kids). No pets or therapy animals allowed. We strive to be a tech free zone (NO WIFI or TV's). A true authentic connection with Nature and each other.

Top Guest favourite
A fire pit is surrounded by six gray Adirondack chairs, positioned on a well-maintained lawn. In the background, a tranquil pond is visible, complemented by trees and landscaped areas, creating a peaceful outdoor space for gatherings.
Cabin in Fremont
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews

Wisconsin Waterfront Getaway

Cabin on Lake Poygan channel! Direct access to the lake, with two boat lifts and docks for all your water toys. Kayak, stand up paddle board, or just relax by the fire (indoors or out) while the lake life washes over you. All modern furnishings, one king bed, one queen, three bunks and a trundle. Fish from the dock or take the water toys out to the lake. Lake Poygan is over 14000 acres of fun. Winter offers ice fishing, ice skating, and snow mobiling (snow mobile trail accessable by lake).

Top Guest favourite
Cabin in New London
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Secluded Cabin with Sauna

Place yourself in nature. Put down your phone and pick up a book. Clear your mind, focus on your breath, connect with your inner self. Sleep like you’ve never slept before accompanied only by the sound of owls and wind in the pines. The Belden Farm offers land that is a true retreat. Enjoy the privacy and quiet of our cabin in the woods. Extensive, well-maintained trails for hiking, skiing or Fattire biking lead you through towering hardwoods, cathedral white pines, and golden meadows.

Guest favourite
An open second-floor area is depicted, showcasing a sleek wooden bookshelf filled with books and decorative items. A spacious bed is positioned near a window, while a cozy seating area with black leather sofas invites relaxation. Natural light streams through the windows, highlighting the wood flooring.
Cottage in Neshkoro
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Pet Friendly Antique Schoolhouse with Fenced Yard

Pond Lily is truly a unique stay; a historic schoolhouse among tranquil surroundings. Beautiful traditional craftsmanship meets all the comforts of a modern home. Pet friendly with a fenced yard. A well-stocked kitchen makes for easy home-cooked meals. The layout is ideal for small groups looking to enjoy a peaceful getaway. Snuggle up by the wood-burning fireplace in the cold months or enjoy the firepit in the warm weather. For the outdoorsman, public lands are 5 minutes away.

Guest favourite
Home in Green Bay
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Charming 1870s Downtown Loft

Like your favorite cup of coffee, this sunlit haven energizes and comforts. Just steps from downtown's vibrant pulse, this thoughtfully restored 1870s duplex is crafted for connection, creativity, and relaxation. Work under high ceilings bathed in natural light, or gather with friends in the spacious, open kitchen and dining area. Modern amenities ensure a home-like experience in a space that seamlessly combines the warmth of history with the ease of modern living.

Top Guest favourite
Home in Appleton
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Modern, Freshly Renovated House Near Downtown

Escape to our stylish, art-themed home in a quiet Appleton neighborhood just minutes a few minutes walk to downtown! This newly remodeled house is perfect for families or remote workers. Enjoy a dedicated workspace, a fun playroom, and a private patio. You're just a 10-minute walk from downtown College Avenue, Lawrence University, Mile of Music and the Performing Arts Center. Fully remodeled Only 35 minutes to Lambeau Field. A serene and central retreat awaits!

Top Guest favourite
A lush green lawn extends towards the lake, flanked by two large trees. Two wooden Adirondack chairs provide a comfortable seating area, facing the water. The serene lake view stretches into the distance, with a small boathouse visible nearby.
Home in Oshkosh
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Cozy Relaxing Lake Home with spectacular sunsets!

On the shore of Lake Butte Des Morts Longer stays welcome!!! Awesome Lake view Beautiful Sunsets Gas fireplace Shopping/restaurants/etc… Approx. 40 miles from Lambeau Field pier/summer,sorry nothing can be tied up to pier at any time solo fire pit grill Lake view Bedroom,Living Room,Dining area Near by Wiouwash trail for hiking, biking, etc.. Near EAA Kitchen space for cooking. Washer/dryer Larger 1 bedroom /Queen Sleep Number mattress Off street parking

Top Guest favourite
A yellow cottage is depicted beside Lake Poygan, surrounded by a gravel yard. A picnic table is positioned on the grass, facing the water. Trees are visible in the background, silhouetted against a colorful sunset sky.
Cottage in Winneconne
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Cozy Year Round Lake Poygan Cottage

Note: winter/spring 2026 we have completed some landscaping which results in dirt in the yard (mud if wet) so please be aware if you staying prior to grass coming up. Year round this cottage gives you the ability to fish, swim, float or boat. Inside, there is plenty of space for your family, friends or couples retreat to play games, laugh or just enjoy some peace and quiet. Fishing guests can enjoy an onsite fish cleaning house equipped with all the essential.

Top Guest favourite
The modern home is nestled among tall trees, partially illuminated by outdoor lights in the evening. The structure is seen from a distance, showcasing large windows that reveal a warm glow from inside, creating a serene and inviting presence amidst the natural surroundings.
Home in Waupaca
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

The Raven

Nestled in a quiet, wooded neighborhood, The Raven boasts all the comforts and conveniences of home while offering the peace that only comes when you get away from it all. We're just ten minutes from charming restaurants, local shops, the chain of lakes, and only five minutes from Hartman Creek State Park and the Ice Age National Scenic Trail. Whether to relax, to recharge, or to explore, welcome to your modern escape to the woods. Welcome to The Raven.

Guest favourite
A charming white cabin is shown with a front porch and stairs leading to the entrance. Lush green grass surrounds the property, along with colorful flower beds. In the background, a red barn is visible, providing a contrast to the cabin's exterior.
Farm stay in Omro
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

Family-Friendly Cabin on 170 Beautiful Acres

The cabin rests on 180 acres of scenic farm wildlife habitat. The property includes an 1800s-era barn & blacksmith shop, a host of wild & domestic animals, miles of private canal with access to the Wolf & Fox Rivers, a hiking trail, garden, orchard, and much more! The farm has been the pride of our family for 6 generations. A converted grainary, the cabin features two queen beds, full kitchen, full bathroom, high-speed satellite Wifi and smart-TV.

Guest favourite
Apartment in Oshkosh
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 244 reviews

No Cleaning Fees! 2 Bedroom Apartment By The Lake

We’re transparent with our pricing, that’s why we don’t have cleaning fees! The price you see is the price you pay (local taxes still apply). Come stay near the heart of Oshkosh - you’ll be on the second floor with views of Lake Winnebago. If you need anything during your stay we live on-site and are only a message away. Don’t worry though, the units are completely separated so you’ll have all the privacy you desire during your stay.

Guest favourite
A comfortable hammock is suspended between two trees, offering a peaceful space to relax by the river. Lush green foliage surrounds the area, with the calm water visible in the background, enhancing the serene natural setting.
Cabin in Winneconne
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 300 reviews

Barndominium with Goats, Hot Tub, Forest & River

The Cloverland Barndominium is a thoughtfully renovated 100-year-old barn sitting on 5+ private acres of forest to explore next to a river. You'll share the land with friendly goats and chickens that you can watch from right outside your window! Outside you'll enjoy walking the trails, feeding the animals, taking the canoe down the river, making a fire in the fire pit, and exploring the forest. Escape the busy world and reset!

Popular amenities for Lake Poygan holiday rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Lake Poygan