
Holiday houses in New Lyme
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in New Lyme
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Exclusively Pymatuning Tiny Home w hot tub
This 110 acre lake side tiny home Estate will reconnect you to nature while you relax in the hot tub. The neighboring state park has over 14,000 acres with a lake and trails. This tiny home is where nature meets luxury!! The electric fireplace will welcome you while resting and watching your favorite show. There is a fire pitt and charcoal grill as well as full size kitchen appliances. Owner lives on the property, but no shared facilities. This house has star link internet but not guaranteed.

Forever Spring Cabin
This is a beautiful, brand-new cabin in a quiet wooded setting with nature trails in historic Mesopotamia, Ohio. We are about 45 minutes from Youngstown and Cleveland. Amenities include coffee, tea, juice, soda, cereals, snacks, pancake mix, and even maple syrup gathered in our own local woods. Relax and unwind at the end of the day in our whirlpool for two. Or sit on the porch and enjoy the peaceful surroundings of nature. Continental breakfast only. Outdoor campfire with firewood provided.

“Willow Ledge at Silver Creek”with Private Hot Tub
New Construction Modern Ranch House features rustic upscale design with beautiful cozy interiors and comfort at every turn. Stunning views await with floor to ceiling windows overlooking beautiful Silver Creek and surrounding nature. Private deck is spacious and inviting with oversize hot tub, concrete fire pit, gas grill, and outdoor dining furniture. A few minutes from great restaurants, the Brewery at Garrett’s Mill, and the coolest Coffee Shop. Perfect weekend getaway or business stay.

The Farmhouse
Built in 1885, stylish exposed beam updates, you'll enjoy this historic home in a picturesque, relaxed setting. Picnic on the spacious back porch, enjoy the sunrise and coffee in the airy sunroom/kitchen, or play board games with the entire family! New central HVAC, fast wifi, and smart tvs keeps you comfortable while there are plenty of beds and seating arrangements! The Farmhouse is the perfect family or group rental for winery and covered bridge tours, local festivals, weddings, and more!

Maple Grove Guesthouse
Our guesthouse sits next to our home on 8 beautifully wooded acres. Enjoy the quiet and the calm while still being located very near dozens of wineries and distilleries, and Spire Academy. We are also near the Grand River which provides nice natural areas for hiking, canoeing, kayaking, and fly fishing. Many of the area guests love taking long country drives (bike or motorcycle rides too) past countless vineyards and over the covered bridges that make the area charming and special.

The Game Cabin at Rustic River
Located on our private, wooded 27 acre estate on the Grand River and centrally located to area wineries, Spire, The Game Cabin is the perfect escape to NE Ohio Wine region. Featuring a pool table, vintage pinball machine, gaming/bumper pool table, and a unique and one-of-a-kind wine barrel bar! The kitchen is newly remodeled in 2024 and now features a full stove, refrigerator, and washer / dryer! Centrally located to area wineries, Spire, and 20 minutes from Geneva on the Lake!

Cozy Countryside Cabin Near Multiple Wineries
Our cozy and inviting cabin, the Eagle's Nest, is nestled in a countryside setting behind Greene Eagle Winery and Brew Pub in rural Northeast Ohio. If you are looking for charm, and quiet relaxing comfort, this 384 sq. ft. cabin with exposed cedar beams is your perfect overnight or weekend retreat. Many activities available in the area with Mosquito lake nearby, bike trails, state park, golf, shopping, wineries, breweries, and restaurants within 10 to 30 minutes.

Riverview Country Cabin
Take it easy at this unique, tranquil getaway nestled atop a scenic ridge of the Ashtabula River. Get away from it all and enjoy your morning coffee inside the cozy cabin with views that stretch up and down and across the river. Or bask in the beauty of nature outside on the custom-made porch swing. Keep an eye out for the local bald eagles as they soar above the river daily, right outside your door! This custom built cabin is the perfect quiet getaway!

Quiet Cabin In The Woods
Secluded lakefront fishing cabin on 30 acres offers the very definition of a quiet oasis in the woods. This home lays at the end of a mile long private drive on over 11 acres of manicured lawn surrounded by 300 year old oak trees. The lake, only feet from your front door, contains bass, bluegill, perch and catfish offering both adults and children alike a wonderful opportunity to cast a line and relax while blue heron and eagles nest in the nearby trees.

Outdoor Enthusiasts Paradise
Great location for all types of outdoor activities. Next to Bronzwood golf course and close to Pymatuning lake for great year round fishing. Nearby hunting, walking, UTV riding, snowmobile, biking, and many other outdoor activities. Entire house with outdoor fire pit available. We are located out in the country and it is very quiet and safe area. We offer self check-in with a pin pad lock on the door. We are close by but leave you to enjoy country living.

Little House on the Farm
The accommodation is a 2 bedroom cottage on our small farm that has been recently renovated. It is wheel chair accessible. We are in the middle of the fourth largest Amish community in the world. We are half a mile from the center of Mesopotamia, which is known for the End of the Commons General Store and the annual OX roast over the 4th of July. Cleveland and Youngstown are both approximately 45 minutes away. Lake Erie is 30 minutes north.

Peaceful Country Escape w/ 4BR Ranch + Firepit
Welcome to a peaceful escape ranch in Northeast Ohio. This charming 4-bedroom, 2-bath home features an open-concept great room and a fully stocked island kitchen, perfect for gathering and making memories. Enjoy morning coffee on the front porch or unwind in the evening around the backyard patio with firepit & grill. Exceptionally clean and thoughtfully designed for comfort, this home is ideal for families, groups, or a relaxing getaway.
Popular amenities for New Lyme holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in New Lyme

Cozy Kinsman Wooded Cabin w/Hot Tub - Pymatuning

Peaceful Rustic Entire A-Frame Cabin in the Woods

Haven by the Lake

Cabin in Pymatuning Central

4 Bedroom l Grand River Wineries I Spire I GOTL

Tiny Haven

Bearfoot by the Lake a new spacious rustic house

Cheerful 2-Bedroom Cabin
Destinations to explore
- Washington Holiday rentals
- Columbus Holiday rentals
- Pittsburgh Holiday rentals
- Cleveland Holiday rentals
- Cincinnati Holiday rentals
- Niagara Falls Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Mississauga Holiday rentals
- Baltimore Holiday rentals
- Buffalo Holiday rentals
- Niagara Falls Holiday rentals
- Brampton Holiday rentals
- Cuyahoga Valley National Park
- Progressive Field
- Waldameer & Water World
- Rock & Roll Hall of Fame
- Cleveland Browns Stadium
- Headlands Beach State Park
- Case Western Reserve University
- Mosquito Lake State Park
- Punderson State Park
- Agora Theatre & Ballroom
- The Arcade Cleveland
- Laurentia Vineyard & Winery
- Cleveland Museum of Art
- Splash Lagoon
- Debonné Vineyards
- Cleveland Museum of Natural History
- JACK Cleveland Casino
- A Christmas Story House
- Pymatuning State Park
- Geneva State Park
- The Children's Museum Of Cleveland
- Cain Park
- Conneaut Park
- Lake Shore Park





