Pet-friendly holiday rentals in Paw Paw Lake

This is our 3rd year in a row to come for an extended Labor Day weekend and bring our kids and/or grandkids. We love the setting. The pool is perfect for the younger kids and the adults appreciate the beauty of all the surroundings, including at poolside. If we could change anything at all we would add another bedroom as we can't quite get all of our extended family here at one time. That said, we would like to return for a 4th year at Labor Day weekend time next year. The combination of beauty, privacy, amenities, condition (always in great shape!), and proximity to lovely South Haven can hardly be beat!

Terry provides a clean home away from home for anyone staying in the area. Plenty of activities and every convenience that you need is nearby.

Charles and Tonja's place was very welcoming. We felt right at home. Everything that we needed was there, even had baby supplies and toys for my 2 year old. The place was able to accommodate guest for dinner, plenty of furniture. Would definitely stay there again. They replied really fast and were very accommodating.

We really enjoyed our stay at Jennifer’s house! It was clean, great location & cozy! We especially loved the automatic pool cover so we could actually relax on vacation with our little ones running around. I also loved the three separate areas outside (pool, fire pit, grassy area). The separate areas offered a nice change of scenery to break up the day without leaving the house. I also loved that it’s a spacious ranch style house, so was easy to keep eyes on the kids. Jennifer was a wonderful & accommodating host & can’t wait to get back to her house soon! Thanks for having us!

My husband, dog and I stayed for 2 nights for parents bday party nearby. Had no problems and house is fully stocked with anything you might need. Tons of dishes, towels, bedding etc.

An affordable, cute, petite place.

Beautiful home, comfortable beds, sheets, blankets. Kitchen is well stocked. Large table for games. Everyone in the group said they would come back.

Our home away from home. Beautiful inside & out. Walkable to the cute Three Oaks town. Journeyman Distillery was wonderful & very dog friendly. A must try. We found everything we needed for our stay. Comfortable beds & couch. Loved the big front porch and the fire pit in back. We will definitely be back.

If you are looking for a peaceful camping experience this is the place to stay. Beautiful surrounding and pool, pickleball court to play a game or too all that is very close to the camper. If we are ever in the area again we will be sure to book this again.

We had a lovely family reunion at St Joe’s overlook. Kitchen came with literally everything- all sorts of cooking instruments (crock pot, air fryer, toaster etc), spices/oils, and zip lock bags for leftovers. All brand new appliances and ample prep space. We got the pool heated and it was wonderful! Very large size to fit all the family kids. The hot tub was a nice save for the adults who were freezing. Beautiful views from the living room of the river with ample and comfy seating. The home was perfect for a large gathering. We appreciate Evan and Claire hosting us they were always responsive and helpful.

Lovely home, many well thought out perks like fans in upstairs rooms and beach toys for kids! Info said it was an easy short walk to beach so I spent a whole lot more than I usually would. With children it would not be pleasant and is really not a short walk (and is on a semi busy road) & beach is down a whole lot of steps. BUT there are parking spaces so it was fine. Within the house, the steps are fairly steep at parts & there are 2?big ones going into house &!these were hard for my 70 year old mom w knee issues. So if person reading reviews is one of those people, this might not be THE place. That being said, it is very short walk to community pool & host is very responsive & house is beautiful! My mom mostly stayed within first floor including an awesome bed/bath on ground floor. There are games (although I didn’t love the Ouija board 🫣😂) . This would be a great place for multiple family / friends to split cost ;) Its very beautiful & community pool & hot tub are great!

This is our 5th year of vacationing in New Buffalo and have stayed at Missy's place on 3 of those visits! The house works beautifully for our family (7 adults and 4 kids under 6 yo) and you're never tripping over each other, which makes it so relaxing! We'll be back!!

We had an amazing stay to celebrate a milestone birthday with my extended family! The house comfortably fit 4 families and a labradoodle and was excellent for the 5 kiddos. The heated pool and hot tub were fantastic for cooler than expected temperatures Memorial Day weekend and kept the kids entertained. We opted to cook and grill at the house and had everything we needed. The house is also super close to the beautiful New Buffalo beach. We will be back!

As always Linda and Kourtney were great. Second time staying here and everything was just as awesome as the first time. Thanks again

We loved our stay at Robyn’s nest! It was quaint, quiet, and so close to everything. It was nice to park the car and leave it for our stay as well, super convenient. Robyn was super responsive and clear on her directions and made the stay seamless. Would highly recommend to anyone looking to enjoy their time in Saugatuck!

The Fenn Woods retreat was a wonderful fit for our families! My brother's family stayed with my family, so we were 4 adults and 4 young kids in all. The house was everything we hoped for! We loved that the kitchen was well stocked with oils, spices, pots, pans, and dishes, and it has a huge pantry. The house has two living spaces, so it was easy for our two families to spread out when needed. The backyard and play structure are wonderful! The kids spent so much time outdoors, and we appreciated that the yard was set back from the road. There's also plenty of parking. We also loved that all three mattresses felt new and pretty firm. We all slept comfortably! The loft in the third bedroom is quite large, FYI - it could easily fit a queen mattress (two people). The disappointments were: 1. The pool wasn't working, due to recent storms. Probably out of control of the host, but they didn't offer a discount. 2. There is a skylight in the master bedroom, which impacted sleep and napping.

Lots of green space and wonderful fire pit area. Very clean house with perfect decorations for being a Christmas tree farm. Well stocked kitchen. Close to wineries. We very much enjoyed our stay.

We loved our Fall stay on the ranch! We walked the trails & interacted with the friendly animals. Also, visited a winery just down the road, St Joe’s downtown & Silver Beach.

Nicole was a great host. My family and I wanted an end of summer trip and this was perfect! The house was as described and as it looks in the photos. We took the boat out each day fishing. We also took the kayaks out for a bit. With a bit of rainy weather we played games. Nicole has a wide variety of games to chose from with any unfortunate weather. When reaching out to Nicole she answered very quick with great recommendations.

Great place and great weekend. Very responsive with questions when we needed anything at the house. Would recommend to anyone looking for a peaceful weekend away with family and friends.

Sarah’s place was very clean and extremely well equipped in every aspect, kitchen, bathroom supplies, outdoor etc. So many amenities, we felt like we were still home . The basement was such a great addition for kids and adults to play ping pong, air hockey, arts and crafts. Kids can spend hours down there. Backyard is fenced and although it backs to I-196, we were not bothered. I cannot imagine how beautiful it is once the trees are green. If you have kids and want to get away from the city with minimal planning of all the things to bring, this is the place. There is a beach nearby, 3 min drive, cannot wait to come back during summer months. Sarah, thank you for your gracious hospitality.

Wonderful hosts! House was very cleanly and spacious. I liked the multiple entry points for convenience. We had no face to face contact while staying, which most people prefer, but they were lovely over text and very responsive. Most of all I loved all of the cats and chickens! Would definitely recommend if you’re looking for a peaceful place to stay. :)

We had the best time at The Gambrel; the perfect multi-generational getaway! Johnny and Michelle have literally thought of everything you could possibly need. The house is the perfect distance away to be private yet convenient. Any tiny question we had was answered within minutes. The area is safe, quiet, and serene. Lots of areas for multiple families to congregate but also have privacy within the home. Every detail has been thought of and the primary bedroom showerhead is to die for! I will be dreaming of this vacation home and will definitely return!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Our stay at Kate’s place was absolutely incredible! The domes were stunning both inside and out beautifully designed, clean, and super cozy. You can tell a lot of thought went into creating a fun and unique experience. Whether we were relaxing inside or enjoying the view outside, everything felt peaceful and well taken care of. Kate was a fantastic host, welcoming, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed. Highly recommend this place if you’re looking for a memorable and refreshing getaway!