Cabin holiday rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

We enjoyed our 2 night stay here! Close proximity to the water, was walked behind our cottage and were there. Beautiful views. Quiet and more private than you would think. The Lounge area they have was a blast as well. We enjoyed our stay!

it's a new place. property is still being built. all the cabins are beautiful. with it being built up all the workers and Amish were super nice and just wanted to talk to us to see if we were happy. ther was little to no noise and views were great.

We had a great stay, filled with unforgettable memories and quality family time. The rustic charm of the place made it feel like a true getaway, surrounded by nature and the simple beauty of the outdoors. It was quiet, peaceful, and the perfect setting to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy time away from the hustle of everyday life.

My family and I loved our stay here! We had an extended weekend and used the Rustic Retreat as a base camp to explore the area and just relax. Highlight of the stay was the hot tub and stargazing!

I booked this for my bridesmaids and I for the night before my wedding. The cabin is beautiful and so clean. Alissa left us some snacks and toiletries in case we needed something. She was very friendly and always checked in to make sure we were okay. We went for a walk to the lake and the neighbors were all waving and saying hi to us. It was honestly a very friendly area and we felt safe. The cabin had beautiful interior natural sunlight which was great for getting ready photos.

We had a wonderful time at the cabin. Everything is just as described. The location is so quiet and peaceful. We loved using the outdoor soaker tub. What a treat! We hope to come back soon.

My dad is a builder in Montana and helping him over the years has taught me a few things about construction. I was flabbergasted at the solid construction that went into this beautiful place as well as the others. Everything designed so well, from the colors, to the layout, to the stone/rock for benches on the exterior. The hot tub and sauna were the best. The massive windows that cover 1/4 of the interior were my favorite. No expenses were spared. The Titan smokeless pit was more than great, and we came home a purchased one for our home. The kitchen had just what we needed. The property was quiet and everything and more that we were looking for. The TV was easy to use. It was super clean as well! Thank you so much, it was a wonderful 25th anniversary!

My girlfriends and I came for a mini weekend getaway to celebrate the bride to be! We didn’t spend too much time in the actual airbnb since we had plans every day so I would love to come back and actually enjoy all the amenities!

This place is a gem in northwestern Pennsylvania. It’s perfect for nature lovers who enjoy birding, flora and fauna identification, outdoor activities like hiking, kayaking, and biking, and for those who want a quiet escape. The quirky decor adds a lively and entertaining touch of nostalgia while being accommodating in every way. Lee and Windle are excellent hosts communicating before, during and after our stay. We enjoyed the wood stove, metal roof and porch as it rained most of our stay but we were kept cozy and comfortable while still being a part of the outdoors. Highly recommended and we will return to check it out during different seasons of the year. Thank you for opening the is space for others to enjoy.

Loved this rustic retreat! It was Soul cleansing. Gwen is an amazing host. If you want to get AWAY, this is the perfect place. I stayed here between places while I was moving, but can see myself going just to take a break. Thanks for everything Gwen!

this was our second stay here and certainly not our last. Jessica is an awesome host with a magical cabin. This area is so peaceful and private. The cabin has everything you need to make it a home for your stay. The lake is amazing and we caught so many fish !! You will not regret this cozy cabin ❤️

The photos don’t do this place justice. It was one of the most beautiful airbnbs I’ve been. It has a picturesque scenery. The house itself was spotless, smelled nice, very clean, and the beds were so comfortable! I forgot coffee creamer and Molly had creamer packets stocked in the mini fridge. Everything was perfect. The water was beautiful and clear. Bring water shoes! The water is very tempting to get into and water shoes would be ideal so you don’t slip or hurt your feet. My dogs enjoyed the water and so did our 3 year old son. We will definitely be back! We are already looking into dates for our next trip.

My girlfriend and I stayed one night in Cabin #3 at Edinboro Lake Resort, and it was absolutely perfect. From the moment we arrived, everything was effortless—check-in couldn’t have been easier. The key was waiting for us inside the cabin, which made settling in seamless and stress-free after a long drive. The cabin itself was spotless and incredibly comfortable. You can tell it’s well cared for—clean linens, cozy furniture, and everything we needed was right there. It had a warm, inviting feel that made us instantly relax and enjoy the peaceful surroundings. It was the ideal setting for a quiet getaway, and we only wish we had stayed longer. We’ll definitely be back—and next time, for more than just one night!

Stephanie and AJs responses were very prompt! It was a cute little cabin, definitely staying again!

My family was able to reconnect and enjoy the outdoors favorite part was the fire pit and the surroundings. Highly recommend booking with Jennifer.

Last minute booking but it was wonderful. The cabin has so much character, inside and outside. There was so many cool things about the place. I will definitely come back

This cabin was the perfect spot for our little weekend getaway! It was very tidy with all of the essentials and more needed for our stay. Just a short walk to the lake for breathtaking views of the sunset!

The cabin was set up perfectly, nice and private with all the home amenities you would need for a weekend with the family!

We love staying at Lorrie's cabin! We always have the best rest. It's the only time I sleep 7 hours. It's so peaceful! Thanks again! We look forward to our next stay!

We were lucky to find such a nice place to stay on a last minute trip. Interior of this place is amazing. Great location for us to drive to Spire institute for a tournament and visit Geneva on the lake after, the come back to a peaceful cabin by the park and lake. If it’s available next year when we come to the area we will be renting it again.

It was hard for me to pick what stood out at the Bent Tree cottage because literally everything was perfect. The location is great…in the vineyard and woods, near the distilleries and wineries, and close to town. The place was exactly like the pictures and was clean and inviting. One of our favorite parts was the bed linens. We’re bedding snobs and this delivered luxury :) We loved the porch and two sided fireplace too! I can honestly say this was one of the best places we have stayed. Geneva is a yearly trip for us for my husband’s birthday and this cottage is now at the top of our list for next year!

Beth's place was amazing only Airbnb i ever used that had so much for us to use the only thing we needed was ourselves and food was very impressed would recommend 100 percent looking forward to booking again in the future

Our second time there for a girls trip, Anita’s cabin was once again wonderful. Everything you could possibly need and more. Thank you again for the wonderful note and bottle of wine on arrival.

Cabin was perfect for our little weekend stay. Very peaceful (my daughter loved the tire swing), very clean and the beds were so comfy! Matthew was very fast a responding to any questions and explained everything well. Would stay there again if our journeys take us back there.