
Cottage holiday rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir
Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb
Top-rated cottage rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir
Guests agree: These cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Cozy two bedroom cottage walking distance to lake
Relax with the family or friends at this peaceful cottage. A Two bedroom one bath cottage featuring full kitchen, spacious living/dining area, and a full bath with bathtub/shower. A large private backyard with fire pit situated on a quiet street. The cottage is conveniently located a half a mile from Manning boat launch and Tuttle point and 1.6 miles from Espyville Marina. There are two walking paths in our community that will take you to the lakeshore. Both are approximately a half mile walk.

Eagles’ Wings Lake House Getaway
Completely remodeled cottage right on the water’s edge. Sightings of eagles and other birds often seen from the comfort of your living room or outdoor patio. Lakefront cottage minutes away from golfing and Lake Shore Park offering fishing, beach access for swimming, playground, picnic areas. Close to wineries, breweries, Geneva-on-the-Lake, shopping, restaurants, covered bridges, public parks.Entire cottage has been completely updated and beautifully decorated. Make this your tranquil getaway!

Charming Cottage Overlooking Lake Erie
This 1930s vacation cottage sits atop a bank overlooking the Lake providing an extraordinary respite from the hustle and bustle of big-city life. Relax listening to the waves, watch lake freighters pass in the night, watch for eagles overhead. From a recent guest, "Spectacularly cozy & clean with amazing views!!" The cottage: a porch with a spectacular view, clean, comfortable, vintage with modern amenities, great WiFi and a fully-equipped kitchen! Open all year; amazing off-season rates.

Cozy Country Getaway 40 wooded acres, safe, secure
STARLINK 150-200mbps, CENTRAL AIR PRIVATE Cozy vintage charm cottage/country setting located between ERIE, MEADVILLE, CONNEAUT LAKE, PA. Vacationers, authors, fishermen welcome. Within driving distance to WALNUT/ELK CREEK, CONNEAUT, PYMATUNING, ERIE and one mile to state game lands. Abundant wildlife. Walking trails in the woods and enjoy quiet surroundings around a campfire, STARLINK internet, stream TV, Hulu, Roku. WEEKLY/MONTHLY stays are discounted. Blueberry muffins at check-in.

Lake Escape. Cottage with hot tub & fireplace.
Unwind in our lakeside cottage with hot tub. Nestled against Pymatuning State Park, it's just a 3-minute stroll to the lake and minutes from the Marina for boat launches & rentals. Our renovated cottage is fully equipped for your stay, conveniently located near local dining, cafes, wineries, breweries, swimming spots, disc golf, and hiking/biking trails. Feel the call of nature as you bring your boats bikes, kayaks, fishing gear, and paddleboards to enjoy all the lake has to offer.

Magical Sunsets, Quiet, Cozy, Waterfront @ Li'l Love Inn
A serene, waterfront vacation home with a grand back deck featuring stainless steel appliances, A/C, 65” flat screen TV w/Roku, fast WiFi, outdoor propane fire-table & seating, fully-stocked kitchen, lots of sleeping space, and a spacious deck for entertaining, sipping coffee, or watching sunsets over the lake. Basement with ping pong. Retreat to sounds of wildlife, breathtaking views. A special place to gather. Neighboring rental properties available to sleep up to 30 guests.

French Creek Landing
Come and relax in this comfortable cottage that sits on the bank of scenic French Creek. The cottage has 4 bedrooms (sleeps 8 comfortably), living room, fully equipped kitchen, bathroom (towels included), screened in front porch and a car port for your vehicle. Enjoy your morning coffee on the screened in front porch. During the day you can fish, kayak/canoe, wade/swim or just sit and relax watching the water go by. Sit by a campfire in the evenings enjoying the fresh country air.

Edinboro Lake, Cozy Cottage, Fishermen's dream!
Beautifully cozy cottage just a few steps away from charming Lake Edinboro. Just 1.7 miles to Edinboro University and 30 minutes from Downtown Erie or Presque Isle State Park. Experience boating, kayaking, swimming, fishing on Lake Edinboro and the best Steelhead fishing in the fall and Spring on our local streams just minutes away. Enjoy the winter months at Mt. Pleasant ski resort, ice fishing or cross country skiing with many trail at our area parks.

Sunset View Cottage with the perfect lake view
If you're looking for a peaceful and quiet getaway, this is the place for you. Relax and unwind in our 3 bedroom 2 bath cottage overlooking Lake Erie. Sunset View Cottage is located at the end of a private drive with enough parking space for up to 3 cars. It's spacious and comfortable with a fully equipped kitchen. This is a must see to appreciate the quiet setting. You will love the view, and the privacy!

Lake Front Oasis with Breathtaking Lake Erie Views
Newly renovated lakefront cottage with Breathtaking Views and Private water access Located a mile away from the famous Geneva-on-the-Lake strip, wineries, Geneva State Park and the Ashtabula Harbor. This home offers scenic lake views and Lake Erie Sunsets from the comfort of the living room. Enjoy everything Lake Erie has to offer! We now have two kayaks for you to enjoy during your stay!

Edinboro Lakeside Cottage
Charming & immaculate, lakeside cottage with all amenities. Just a few steps from Edinboro Lake and minutes from the quaint town of Edinboro. Beautiful view of the lake from 2 large enclosed sun porches to enjoy your morning coffee. Brand new queen size bed in the loft. Please note that we can only accommodate 2 guests at our cottage and no pets or smoking allowed.

One Level Home-The Cottage at Mitchell Ponds
15 minutes from Interstate 80–close enough for convenience but far enough away to have a quiet night! Contact host for seasonal weekday specials! Our cottage is a cozy, one floor home with an open floor plan. It is set in the back of the property for added privacy. Come enjoy the beautiful stars and country quiet at this quaint getaway!
Popular amenities for Pymatuning Reservoir cottage rentals
Cottage rentals with a hot tub

The View! Hot Tub-Golf Cart-Beaches-Billiards-King

Staycation Lake View HUGE Year Round Spa Firepit

Geneva, Direct Lakefront, Hot Tub, Wine Country

3-Bedroom Lake House with hot tub on Lake Erie.

Booking Summer 2026 NOW Quiet Craig Beach Hot Tub

Cheerful 2 Bedroom Cottage with Hot Tub near Lake.

Kingfisher's Perch

Spacious 3BR lake front cottage at Lake Leboeuf
Pet-friendly cottage rentals

Chardonnay Cottage | Walk to Strip + Pet-Friendly

The Hickory Hut

Just another day in paradise

Quaint cottage a short walk from the GOTL strip

Sunny Side Up

Cozy 1 bdrm cottage. Furnished Living Rm & Dining area. Fully stocked kitchen w/ refrigerator, oven, microwave & coffee maker. 1 bathrm w/shower. Walking distance to Lake Shore Park. Short drive to Historic Ashtabula Harbor. Perfect for fishermen!

Charming Farm Cottage

Cottage with Private Allegheny River Access
Private cottage rentals

Mini Me at Canadohta Lake, Sleeps 8, incl: linens

River Cottage

Lakeside Cottage with Views and Charm

Rivers Nest- waterfront lifestyle

Ollie's Nook- 5 min walk to Lake

PnT: Fisherman’s favorite Family sized cottage

The Cork Cottages Unit 1, Modern, Arcade, 1K/1Q,2B

Cheerful 2 Bedroom Cottage House in Amish Country!
Destinations to explore
- Rentals with lake access Pymatuning Reservoir
- Rentals with beach access Pymatuning Reservoir
- House rentals Pymatuning Reservoir
- Family-friendly rentals Pymatuning Reservoir
- Rentals with a washing machine and dryer Pymatuning Reservoir
- Rentals with outdoor seating Pymatuning Reservoir
- Pet-friendly rentals Pymatuning Reservoir
- Rentals with a patio Pymatuning Reservoir
- Rentals with a fire pit Pymatuning Reservoir
- Cabin rentals Pymatuning Reservoir
- Cottage rentals United States




