
House holiday rentals in Shelter Island
Find and book unique houses on Airbnb
Top-rated house rentals in Shelter Island
Guests agree: These houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Silver House: 3BR Home with Private Beach Access
Located on a half-acre property surrounded by tall oak trees, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom home is the perfect getaway. The house is part of the Clearwater Beach community with private beach access. The recently renovated kitchen and bathrooms are modern and minimal. Natural light floods the space throughout the entire house. Here is your perfect getaway from the chaos of city life The fireplace is NOT available for guest use. Early check-in and late check-out are NOT available in season

Hamptons Oceanfront Oasis
Escape the hustle & bustle of city life and unwind at this stunning home in the Hamptons. The oceanfront oasis is the perfect way to wake up to ocean views, beaches and nearby restaurants. Relax on our spacious deck - perfect for morning coffees & sunset cocktails. It is just a short drive to the train station & only 15 minutes from the airport for quick getaways. For your safety, the home is equipped with Ring cameras and one-use key codes. Book now and experience the ultimate Hamptons escape!

Secluded Farmhouse - Studio Apartment Style Unit
Beautiful, quiet, studio apartment-style unit (private entrance w/full bath) tucked away in a modern farmhouse on a gorgeous, secluded North Fork farm. Guests have exclusive use of screen porch, fire pit, bbq and outdoor seating area. Jess is a private chef and yoga instructor, so be sure to inquire for services! Private hiking trails, fresh eggs, produce from garden, beach gear, Keurig, mini fridge, homemade granola, tea. Fresh eggs, seasonal veg from the garden, and meals (inquire!)

Shelter Island Getaway with Cozy Fireplace
Just 2 blocks from Hay Beach, our family & pet-friendly 3BR home offers space to relax & play. Enjoy a large yard w/ fire pits, beach gear, games, & toddler toys. Inside: open living area, fireplace, full kitchen, 2 baths, playroom, workout space, & extra sleeping options. Quiet neighborhood, perfect for families. Winter stays: cozy up by the fire & enjoy $0 cleaning fee Nov–Mar. Host lives next door for quick support. For the littles there is a full sized crib high chair and bathtub.

PICTURE PERFECT SOUTHAMPTON HOME-
Picture Perfect 3 bedroom 1.5 Bath Cottage located in the heart of Southampton. The home is conveniently located close to Southampton, Bridgehampton and Sag Harbor towns. Additionally, there is close access to both Bay and Ocean Beaches. The Newly renovated home gives you a peaceful and serene feeling everyday. Dogs are accepted on a case by case basis. Cats are not permitted. Please read the additional disclosures, guidelines, and rules. No events, no parties, no smoking –

Harbor Heights
Newly renovated 2-Family Home! Located right in Greenport Village providing walking distance to all the restaurants, bars, shopping, coffee shops, and Shelter Island Ferry, Long Island Railroad (LIRR), and Hampton Jitney. My place is close to restaurants and dining, the beach, family-friendly activities, nightlife, and public transport. You’ll love my place because of Location!. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids).

Stunning 3 bed 2 bath home W Pool
Nestled on a serene an acre off a tranquil lane, this contemporary, designer-updated residence provides an idyllic Hamptons retreat. With 3 delightful bedrooms, 2 sleek bathrooms, and a seasonal heated pool amidst mature landscaping, you're promised a calming respite. We kindly ask that you familiarize yourself with the detailed disclosures, & guidelines. We maintain a strict policy against events, parties, and smoking. our home and property grouds are smoke-free.

Sea Roost
This private, two-cottage property contains a few of the last remaining original fisherman cottages at Hither Hills built in the 1940s. Set on a lush, private knoll - South of the Highway - Sea Roost boasts mature landscaping and is located steps to Montauk's quiet and secluded Hither Hills Beach. The property consists of a 2 bed/2 bath cottage with separate artist studio (Qn bed, kitchenette & full bath). Dogs negotiable with pet fee. IG @searoosts

Modern Farmhouse Steps to Beach & Love Lane
Our home is professionally designed and set on a spacious, manicured green parcel enclosed by a Cul-de-sac with complete privacy inside and out. The home is designed with all modern conveniences and is located less than a 5 minute walk to Love Lane (Mattituck's charming downtown), Veteran's Beach (one of the best beaches on the Northfork) and the Mattituck train station. It is a place to relax, unwind and enjoy all that North Fork has to offer.

Luxury Hamptons Home with Heated Saltwater Pool
Get away from it all in this meticulously renovated Westhampton Beach home. Pull up to the cottage in the heart of Westhampton Beach, a place that delivers all the Hamptons have to offer, all while being within a two hour drive of NYC. No detail was overlooked in the renovation of this cottage… the beauty is only matched by the comfort and function. With the open floor plan, sunny kitchen, furnished open air patio, you won’t want to leave.

Greenport Beach house Mini Resort Spa & Catering
Nestled steps from the beach, and all that Greenport and the North Fork has to offer, this exquisitely charming 3 bedroom 2 bathroom waterfront home is absolutely delightful.. You’ll love my place because of the views, the location, the people, the ambiance, the outdoors space, and the Saltwater pool.. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), groups, and furry friends (pets).

Exclusive Sag Harbor Compound
A private country compound in heart of Sag Harbor. House just gut renovated with all top of line (all Wolf and Subzero appliances). The main house is 3 bedrooms, 3.5 bath main house PLUS separate large guest cottage (with a King bed, bar fridge, and full bathroom). Gunite pool (i.e., salt chlorinated which makes it feels like clean freshwater). Walk to town, bay beach, public tennis courts, 1000 acre nature preserve.
Popular amenities for Shelter Island house rentals
House rentals with a pool

Corwin House

Private Oasis W/Stunning Vinyard and Pool Views

Beach Barn w/ Heated Pool & Sauna - Dog Friendly

Stunning Farmhouse in NoFo I Heated Pool, Wineries

Classic Southampton Village Home w/ Pool

Secluded Luxury: New Gunite Pool, Walk to Bay

Explore the Water & Woods at a Relaxing Retreat

CASA GYPSEA - a chic and peaceful 3 bedroom house
Weekly house rentals

Peaceful and Private 3 bedroom home in the woods

Beach Cottage | Steps to Water| Fireplace|Firepit

Spectacular Southampton Retreat!

Historic East Hampton Home - Private Beach Access

Gorgeous home with saltwater pool. Steps to beach!

Stylish Getaway in Greenport

Stunning Central E. Hampton Home w/ gunite pool.

Kayaks ~ Bikes ~ Boards ~ 6mins> Greenport ~ 55"TV
Private house rentals

Greenport Getaway - North Fork Rental

Designer Home w/ Heated, Salt-Water Pool

Country Beach Home!

Perfect Beach Home in Sag Harbor

Lakehouse Getaway North Fork

Private East Hampton Estate

The Olde Church in Greenport

Peaceful Bright Country House
When is the best time to visit Shelter Island?
| Month | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avg. price | $845 NZD | $880 NZD | $880 NZD | $880 NZD | $1,181 NZD | $1,248 NZD | $1,317 NZD | $1,324 NZD | $1,100 NZD | $792 NZD | $910 NZD | $1,046 NZD |
| Avg. temp | 0°C | 1°C | 4°C | 10°C | 16°C | 21°C | 24°C | 24°C | 20°C | 14°C | 8°C | 3°C |
Quick stats about house rentals in Shelter Island

Total holiday rentals
Explore 110 holiday rentals in Shelter Island

Nightly prices starting at
Shelter Island holiday rentals start at $18 NZD per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 2,160 verified reviews to help you choose

Family-friendly holiday rentals
100 properties offer extra space and kid-friendly amenities

Pet-friendly accommodation
Find 40 rentals that welcome pets

Holiday rentals with a pool
50 properties feature pools

Rentals with dedicated workspaces
60 properties have a dedicated workspace

Wi-Fi availability
110 of Shelter Island holiday rentals include Wi-Fi access

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wi-Fi and Pool across Shelter Island rentals

4.9 Average rating
Shelter Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Plainview Holiday rentals
- New York City Holiday rentals
- Long Island Holiday rentals
- Boston Holiday rentals
- Washington Holiday rentals
- East River Holiday rentals
- Hudson Valley Holiday rentals
- Jersey Shore Holiday rentals
- Philadelphia Holiday rentals
- South Jersey Holiday rentals
- Mount Pocono Holiday rentals
- The Hamptons Holiday rentals
- Rentals with pools Shelter Island
- Rentals with outdoor seating Shelter Island
- Rentals with a fire pit Shelter Island
- Fitness-friendly rentals Shelter Island
- Rentals with a patio Shelter Island
- Rentals with a washing machine and dryer Shelter Island
- Pet-friendly rentals Shelter Island
- Rentals with a hot tub Shelter Island
- Rentals with beach access Shelter Island
- Beachfront rentals Shelter Island
- Family-friendly rentals Shelter Island
- Rentals with a fireplace Shelter Island
- Rentals with a kayak Shelter Island
- Waterfront rentals Shelter Island
- House rentals Suffolk County
- House rentals New York
- House rentals United States
- Yale University
- Foxwoods Resort Casino
- Charlestown Beach
- Fairfield Beach
- Southampton Beach
- Cooper's Beach, Southampton
- Ocean Beach Park
- Walnut Public Beach
- Shinnecock Hills Golf Club
- Blue Shutters Beach
- Groton Long Point Main Beach
- Cedar Beach
- Napeague Beach
- TPC River Highlands
- Brownstone Adventure Sports Park
- Woodmont Beach
- Silver Sands Beach
- Sunken Meadow State Park
- Jennings Beach
- Sandy Beach
- Wildemere Beach
- Amagansett Beach
- Ninigret Beach
- Seaside Beach




