House holiday rentals in West Milford

Such a beautiful spot on the lake!!! We had the most beautiful weekend, the kids loved he pool and the boats, nothing was missing! We would have stayed another week! Jennifer and Jose answered all our messages within a few minutes and were super accommodating. We will definitely be back!

We were absolutely charmed by this stunning house, surrounded by breathtaking nature and offering incredible views—especially over the lake. Every corner is filled with character and warmth, making it feel like a true hidden gem. A huge thank-you to our wonderful host Sandy, who was incredibly thoughtful and proactive throughout our stay. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. We’ll be back without a doubt!

We absolutely loved our stay ay Susan's place. We were celebrating our ten year wedding anniversary with our dogs and it could not have been more perfect! The private pool setting, access to the rail trail that leads directly into town, the giant windows bringing the outdoor greenery inside, the Frida Calla 500 piece puzzle, the I pad hooked up to a lovely sound system, I could go on and on. We rarely visit the same place twice, but we made need to break that streak with this place.

This property is large and roomy with plenty beds to go around including the basement with the pool and ping pong tables plus a home gym with various equipments. The outdoors were fantastic with a very nice temperature controlled pool, Jacuzzi, swings set for the little ones and enough acreage to have a soccer match. The neighborhood was nice and quiet in a great country setting with lots of wildlife to enjoy to include lots of singing birds. Our family reunion was a great success due in part to the before mentioned surroundings. Douglas was always available to resolve minor issues, very responsive and accommodating, thanks for making our stay at this property a great one.

I spent my birthday at this beautiful house and couldn’t have asked for a better experience. The place was spotless and full of natural light, with lovely views that made the stay even more special. The atmosphere was peaceful and clean, and the house had everything we needed for cooking and relaxing. I truly felt at home and appreciated all the thoughtful touches. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a cozy, well-equipped getaway!

We rented this for my brothers bachelor party and it was the PERFECT spot. Super quiet area, tons of stuff to do in the house and in the community, not to mention Masthope mountain is a beautiful spot to be at! The house was awesome and all the amenities were great, the golf sim was down while we were there which was a bummer but everything else about it was amazing!

It was a beautiful stay and everything were just like the photos! We enjoyed our stayed!

Lisa’s place was fun and relaxing for our family. Great place to relax and unwind all while being close to the great areas we visited. Lisa was a great host ❤️

We had an unforgettable stay at this magical cabin! Izzy and Joe are amazing hosts—warm, responsive, and incredibly thoughtful. Check-in was seamless, and since late checking was requested by them , they kindly offered a late checkout, which we truly appreciated and made our departure more relaxed. The cabin itself is even better than the photos—beautifully decorated, full of natural light, and thoughtfully designed. The bedroom and sunroom with lake views quickly became our favorite cozy spots. The private island with its dreamy daybed swing and breathtaking lake views felt like a hidden paradise, and our dog loved roaming leash-free on the island. Everything in the cabin is intuitively organized, with smart controls for lighting, shades, and TV—managed via an iPad that also contains a well-designed digital guide. We’ve stayed at many cabins over the years, and this one stands out in every way. We’re already planning to return and make this special place an annual tradition

Had a fun wknd stay. Clean, stylish, easy and comfortable! Would recommend.

We had a wonderful holiday weekend at the lake house. The views and outdoor space are breathtaking. It is so wonderful for adults and kids. The house looks just like the photos, it was comfortable and clean. Owners are responsive, kind and always gave us suggestions on what to do each day in the area. We highly recommended staying here and would gladly stay again!

Our stay was very pleasant and peaceful. We had all the comforts of home and more. The house was spacious and the bedrooms were placed just perfect to have privacy. We used the guide book that was arranged so that we would know where the best grocery stores were and other amenities. Thank you for such perfect accommodations!

Very clean, they provided TP, toiletries, lots of attention to detail to make the stay comfortable! We had a great time!

Beautiful well decorated place. So peaceful and relaxing. Jack was also responsive and accommodating.

Staying at Jo's place was an absolute pleasure. The house itself was just as described and sits in a cozy area steps from Greenwood Lake. My fiance and I spent a week there and honestly felt as if it could be our second home. There was plenty to do at the lake where we swam, paddle boarded, and kayaked all around the beautiful water. Jo made sure that life jackets were provided for us and that they were the appropriate size which was incredibly thoughtful. She also gave us lots of recommendations for local places to eat and to see which was also very nice. Communication with her was top notch and was always comfortable. We will absolutely consider coming back to her beautiful home.

Very nice house with great pool / outside area. House was well stocked and clean. Fanny was very responsive to any questions our group had. Highly recommend

After the hustle and bustle of working near the city, this home was a much needed peaceful retreat. Spacious; Comfortable; Large bed to sink into at the end of the night; and peaceful grounds. We had our two toy poodles with us and they had a treat running the fenced in yard. If the weather cooperated, we would have been in the pool. Next time-;)

We’ve been going to Greenwood Lake for many years but this was our first time with kids and it was the perfect home for two couples and three kids. They loved the slide and hammock and all the space to run around outside as well as the game room upstairs. We took the boat out on the lake during the day and one day a family of swans even came up to the dock. It was so special! Dana had everything we needed plus things we hadn’t even thought to bring (like extra long skewers to roast marshmallows for s’mores in the fire pit!) It was a beautiful backdrop for a lovely weekend and we wished we could have stayed longer. Overall fantastic and above and beyond!

We had a wonderful time in Elizabeth’s airbnb. It is just as described and it was the perfect size for a small family. Our kids loved the easy access to the lakes. Plus there are bunnies everywhere! The house is clean and well stocked. We would stay here again. Thank you, Elizabeth!

We had amazing stay at the cabin! Location is perfect: views of the lake are gorgeous, cabin is very private, it’s walkable to downtown, and short drive to nearby attractions. Hosts made us feel at home right away. Cabin is pretty big and freshly renovated. I highly recommend to visit drowned lands brewery (10 minutes ride) and stop by at GWL ice cream shack (walkable from the cabin). We enjoyed our vacation and will certainly book again! Thank you

Garrett and Chad were very responsive and gave a great recommendation for dinner in town. We had an issue with the microwave not working but decided not to have it fixed while we were there since we were leaving the next day. The house and grounds are very spacious and clean. Bedrooms are good sizes. You’ll even have some deer graze right near the house. Overall a great stay!

Lisa was extremely kind and helpful before and throughout our stay. The house was beautiful and we had an awesome weekend in Warwick. Would definitely come back!

Lauren and Ben's place was wonderful and perfect for my family: peaceful, clean, comfortable and functional. The interior design is beautiful and the spaces are thoughtfully arranged to offer privacy or openness, carte blanche. There are plenty of wonderful toys that my 1.5 year old absolutely loved, but they were organized and tucked neatly away, and despite being fairly child friendly the space felt refined and mature. Lauren also left a booster seat for my son to use and offered a crib and high chair. We did a lot of cooking, and the kitchen left nothing to be desired. There were even child-size utensils nestled neatly in the back of a kitchen drawer! The backyard was lovely, too: neatly groomed, with a great view of the water and plenty of gathering places. We would definitely stay at Lauren and Ben's house again.

Beautiful, private, and quiet spot to enjoy a night away. Lovely modern decor, birds chirping, and very comfy bed! We had a great time