Family-friendly holiday rentals in Honeoye Lake

What a lovely stay! The cottage's location right on Keuka Lake was absolutely perfect, offering amazing wildlife and lake activity. We truly appreciated the privacy and genuine homey feel – made us feel immediately comfortable. Highly recommend for a relaxing getaway. We'd definitely stay again!

Drift away was a wonderful cottage right on the lake. Place was extremely comfortable. Beautiful views. We didn’t have the greatest weather which would have made the trip so much better, so we hope to plan a trip back soon.

Peppermint Cottage was everything we hoped it would be! The scent of peppermint welcomed us upon our arrival. The fireplace and wide-plank floors created a perfect ambiance as we enjoyed the comfortable, cozy living room. The beds were comfy and the sheets crisp and clean. We enjoyed our stay so much that we hope to visit again someday.

My family and I really enjoyed staying here, it’s a peaceful, beautiful, spacious and comfortable place, far from the noises of the city. The only things that we heard were nature sounds, exactly what we were looking for. Our dog and cats enjoyed staying here too. David and Shannon are really kind people, they helped us in anything we needed, and responded quickly. They also brought a portable AC unit because we have an Alaskan Malamute and she needs the air to be very cold. Thanks for all your kindness. We definitely would come back. 100% recommended

Jim and Carol are great hosts. Great location, very comfortable, lots of room. I would definitely stay there again.

absolutely amazing! every single aspect of the home was incredible. humongous inside, grand master bed/bath. immaculate accommodations. beautiful backyard! pool, hot tub, the best showers, 3 person sauna worked amazing. tons of space to spread out. our party had 11 people in it and noone was near one another. we all had tons of space. the showers and water pressure was to die for. ill never enjoy a shower as much as I did being here. host was amazing. great communication. very clear and responsive to any questions. by far the best home ive ever stayed in and I'm sure ill never ever find one this amazing again. will 110% return in the future. I wish I could live here!

This place was fantastic! The far-reaching lake view was breathtaking. The huge backyard was perfect for the kids, and the basement with a pool table and TV room provided endless entertainment. The well-equipped kitchen made cooking a breeze, and we loved the hot tub and fire pit for s'mores. The BBQ grill was great for dinners. Even with rain, we found fun visiting wineries and taking a boat trip from Watkins Glen. Easy road access was a plus. Highly recommend for families!

Very nice little home which sits on Seneca lake. A beautiful view of the sunset the lake is in full view sitting in the house. Everything was there for us as far as toiletries and bath supplies and a full kitchen.

We enjoyed our time at this peaceful location in the country. The cabin was very comfortable and had all of the necessary amenities. It was a great location for visiting the many parks , tourist attractions and towns in the finger lakes region.

Very clean and great location for visiting wineries on Keuka!

Pete’s place was perfect for our short stay to attend a concert at CMAC nearby. Home had plenty of space, was very clean, and had everything we needed. Pete was an excellent host, very attentive and friendly! We would definitely book again for a future concert.

Such a peaceful place!! Definitely want to come back in the winter!

Catharine did a fantastic job setting us up with a wonderful home right on Seneca lake. She was verry attentive, and did her best to meet the requests or queries we had. Magnolia is a beautiful property and I would love to go back again. Very close to some local wineries which we indulged ourselves in, the town of Geneva is pretty cool too with some good restaraunts and friendly people. I loved this trip, it was just what we all needed before we start a busy summer season. Thanks again Catharine!

Magnificent homestead built in 1855. Beautiful grounds. Loved the animals in the barn. Lovely tennis court and swimming pool. Comfy beds! Martha was totally responsive and helpful. Peaceful and relaxing stay!😊

Very cute cabin. We loved stepping out onto the deck and enjoying our morning cup of coffee with the sound of the stream in close proximity and the lovely view of the trees. My husband enjoyed a little fishing on the pond within walking distance of the cabin. As mentioned in the description, it is very close to the road. If you're a light sleeper, take some ear plugs. Also, it is a cabin so note that there may be a critter or 2 inside the cabin and bug bites are very much a part of the experience. I woke up with several bites. The shared bathroom was clean with plenty of towels. The shared kitchen was also helpful. We did cook a little breakfast there every day. Of the 2 cabins available by this host, this one has a little more privacy. All in all, we would love to return in the future. Great hosts.

Another great stay at this perfect home away from home. Nancy has thought of everything you and your pup will need for an incredibly comfortable vacation on the lake. There is a ton to do and explore in the surrounding area. Some of the highlights this year were the Geneva Lake trail, Grounded (cute cafe that allows dogs inside or out!), The Spotted Duck (amazing ice cream and they offer pup cups), Billsboro winery (chocolate truffle & wine pairing, also dog friendly), and Dean Lane Dining (no pets) in Dundee. And then there’s the magic of sunrise from Nancy’s deck and evenings just watching fish jumping, birds flying, and ducks swimming, all from the glider on the dock. Simple pleasures abound here.

This is our third time staying at Judiths. We enjoy our visit every time. The location is perfect for a day on the water. Judith is always responsive and friendly, making sure we have everything we need. She always makes us feel at home!

Our stay at Glenora Cottage was absolutely perfect! The cottage offers a stunning view. It was the ideal spot for our group of two couples, providing just the right amount of space and privacy. The pictures online don't do it justice! The attention to detail in the cottage was amazing. From the cozy decor to the well-equipped kitchen, everything we needed was on-hand. Every aspect of the cottage was thoughtfully designed to ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay. The location was also fantastic, especially for our wine tour. We were able to easily explore the nearby wineries and enjoy some wonderful tastings. Glenora Cottage truly provided the perfect base. Overall, we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay. Highly recommend Glenora Cottage for anyone looking for a beautiful, relaxing getaway! Thank you, Scott!!

Fourth stay for a scrapbooking week at the Baus Haus. This place never disappoints from the fresh flowers to complimentary groceries (milk, OJ, eggs) and comfy bedrooms! We always enjoy the peaceful setting. Sitting out on the deck in the morning with coffee and truly being in the moment enjoying the wind through the trees and the menagerie of critters including cardinals, deer, groundhogs and chipmunks - just wonderful. We had one computer connectivity "emergency" and Tony came over and fixed things promptly. This is a wonderful airbnb home in a beautiful location. Brenda and Tony are the nicest and most accommodating hosts, putting this listing in the 5++ star category! Thanks for another perfect stay!!

Our stay on the lake was wonderful. The housing was perfect and met our needs. This would be a great house to rent during the summer months. WE had a little trouble locating the house initially as it is located among other houses and the drive down to the house is not clearly marked. If you are coming from the south you need to make a turn almost opposite the way you are coming into a steep drive to the housing. It needs to be better marked, maybe with an arrow and house number. The house could also us a little address sign on the walkway for clarification. HOWEVER, the stay was great and getting information to the person in charge was easy. The accommodations were very good. The view was wonderful. The water frontage is a bit steep but there are steps to bring you to the water. In all this is a wonderful home for vacation with amenities about 15 minutes away. I would give Nancy or Eric a call again.

Was a beautiful place. Quite had plenty of good fire wood and very clean place. Neighbors were great enclosed front porch was great to eat and be able to look at lake. Nice air conditioning though out home. Will definitely visit again. Steve was a wonderful host. 5 stars I.n my book

My aunt and I loved Christina’s house. It was beautifully restored and decorated, and it felt comfortable and homey. It was very close to stores and restaurants but the neighborhood was quiet. I will definitely return.

Just returned from our 4th visit to Jill and Mario’s absolutely beautiful house, and had another fabulous experience! Three things really stand out. First, the view of the lake and backyard is stunning. Second, the house is immaculate. And third, it is very thoughtfully well-stocked with necessities and kitchen items. We loved kayaking and enjoyed a fire and making s’mores out back. Jill and Mario are great hosts!

We wanted a quiet weekend for our 10th Anniversary, and this cabin and location was perfect. Very warm and cozy, and sitting by the pond just taking it all in was just what we needed. Communication was great, with clear information about the cabin.