Monthly Rentals in Indian Beach

Ashley was an excellent host, willing to accommodate our special needs and quick to respond. The place isn't huge, but it is cozy, dog friendly, well accommodated and a half-hearted stones throw from the beach. Would definitely come back.

We really enjoyed staying here! It was nice being closer to the beach and the marina in Psalter Path. it was our first time on the island and even though the weather was not great we had fun. Thanks David for making sure we had some snacks and necessities in the house!

Colony by the Sea is a great complex! Being able to walk straight down to the beach from the complex was very convenient. We had everything that we needed, and the condo was exactly as described. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay!

Martha was a lovely host. From booking her home to check in to our stay to check out, she was available for any information and was specific in her directions, recommendations, expectations, etc. Martha’s home was perfect for our beach vacation - the walk to the beach was SO nice and easy! And my son loved waking up to see the boats at the dock from the back balcony. Unfortunately it rained most of our trip but there were a few local things to do indoors to keep my son busy. The locals were so nice to us to also make recommendations when they noticed our NY license plate! Martha’s food recommendations were stellar. We went to a few and they all knocked it out of the park. I would definitely stay at Martha’s again in the future! ☀️🌊