Beach house holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique beach houses on Airbnb

Top-rated beach house rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: These beach houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favourite

A clear view of Lake Michigan is presented from a wooden deck. Sandy pathways lead down to the beach, framed by lush greenery. The tranquil blue waters stretch toward the horizon under a bright blue sky.

Home in Michigan City

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

Big Beach Front House 8br 5ba Fireplace/Pit*WiFi*

Lakefront 8Br 5Bath (Sleeps 24). Unobstructed views of Lake Michigan & steps to beach. Firepit, WIFI, Big Weber Gas grill, fireplace, etc. Lower level (walk-out) redone with LR, 3BR, new Bath and laundry. 1st floor open plan - new kitchen, bath, and wood floors! 2nd & 3rd floors brand new - 2nd floor with 4 BR & 2 Ba - 2 BR w/doors 2 deck facing lake! Spiral stair to 3rd floor loft/Br w/6 twins, Full Bath & deck. Beach is virtually private at this, the far end of Michigan City's public beach.

Top Guest favourite

The rear exterior of the home is showcased, featuring a spacious deck illuminated by string lights. A private hot tub is positioned nearby, and a dining area with a long wooden table is visible. Lush greenery surrounds the space, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Michigan City

5 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Beachfront Hot Tub All Year | Outdoor Grill | Wave

Beachfront Home! Welcome to Waves on Lake Michigan, your ultimate beachfront retreat—just steps from the sand and surf! This beautifully updated home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and lakeside charm for your next getaway. Step outside to soak in the private hot tub under the stars, relax on the spacious deck with a drink in hand, or enjoy a cookout in the backyard designed for fun and connection. Whether you're lounging by the water, grilling with friends, or falling asleep to the

Guest favourite

A modern home is situated on a sandy lot beside a small private lake. Large windows reflect the surrounding greenery, while a sloped roof adds to the architectural design. The outdoor seating area is visible, enhancing the tranquil setting.

Home in Stevensville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Bright & Modern Home: Heated Pool Open 5/20-10/4

The modern architecture and bright and airy design of the home provides a relaxing, inviting and luxurious space for guests. The home: -is set on an a sandy lot, facing a small private lake -has 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a den and a loft -has an 8-person hot tub and private pool -is equipped with top of the line kitchenwares -includes outdoor amenities such as kayak, canoe, fire pit, grill, yard games (Jenga and corn hole), etc. -allows pets but must be included in the booking and pay a pet fee

Guest favourite

A scenic view from the deck showcases a tranquil lake surrounded by lush greenery. A private dock extends into the water, with several boats visible nearby. A grassy area features white outdoor chairs arranged for relaxation.

Home in Paw Paw

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

The Perfect Lake Getaway!

This lake house is the perfect getaway for your family or a couple's weekend. This home is located on beautiful 200-acre Eagle Lake. Whether it's you and the wife on a weekend wine tour, a snowmobile skiing and ice fishing trip, or a family trip during the summer this cottage is exactly what you are looking for. The view is absolutely beautiful from the open living room/deck overlooking the lake. Enjoy wildlife including eagles, geese, swan and more. Property manager John Hosek Premier Host

Guest favourite

A scenic view of Barron Lake is framed by two large trees, with a white picket fence lining the foreground. A boat is seen gliding across the water, accompanied by a dock in the background. The sky is clear with a few clouds, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Niles

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Lake House - Notre Dame nearby

Come enjoy the beachy charm of Shady Point, resting on the sandy shores of beautiful Barron Lake! This 3 bedroom cottage is completely furnished. Whether you are looking for rest or entertainment, this beach front vacation home provides all you need for a cozy bonfire, water fun, or a full day of exploring the shops & vineyards! Enjoy Lake Michigan, Warren Dunes, visit Notre Dame, take a drive to Chicago, or a quick walk to our local grill when you book your stay here! See you soon!

Guest favourite

An aerial view captures a cluster of chalets arranged around a spacious parking lot near the water's edge. The surrounding landscape features lush greenery and tranquil blue waters, with various outdoor amenities visible, including pools and recreational areas.

Home in Stevensville

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Lake Michigan Beach Cottage + Pool + Games

Escape to our newly remodeled chalet that is steps away from Lake Michigan. With 6 beds, it's the perfect getaway for couples, families, or small groups. Enjoy access to a private and public beach, pools, sports courts, fishing ponds, and playgrounds. Located next to Lincoln Township Park and near Grand Mere State Park plus nearby breweries, wineries, and distilleries. Relax, explore, and create unforgettable memories at this cozy lakeside retreat. Your perfect vacations awaits!

Top Guest favourite

The front exterior of the home is framed by lush green grass and trees. Large windows provide an unobstructed view of the lake, while a stone facade adds character. A shaded entryway leads into the spacious retreat, embodying a serene, welcoming presence.

Home in Benton Harbor

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Getaway 2026: Retro Charm, Quiet Beach, Family Fun

Escape to our spacious beachfront retreat perfect for family getaways! This cozy 4-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home sleeps 10 guests and offers a range of amenities including a fully equipped kitchen, BBQ grill, patio, and stunning lake views. Enjoy private beach access via a nature trail to your own beach, and a front row seat to magnificent sunsets from the shaded backyard. Nearby attractions include wineries, breweries, and outdoor activities. 2025 was fully booked--book early for 2026!

Top Guest favourite

A lakefront home is depicted, featuring a modern two-story design with a dark roof and white siding. Soft light from string lights illuminates the outdoor space. Reflection on the calm water captures the structure and surrounding trees, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Dowagiac

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Lakefront Boardwalk

Welcome to the Lakefront Boardwalk! Here you'll find everything to make your next visit to Sister Lakes, MI the most fun and memorable for everyone. Our home offers a completely renovated space with all the amenities needed and wanted for an amazing stay on Little Crooked Lake. Wake up to beautiful sunrises right on the water and finish the day with s'mores by the campfire. Our home is conveniently located within walking distance to the local restaurants and Driftwood Ice Cream shop.

Top Guest favourite

Two yellow adirondack chairs are positioned on a well-maintained green lawn, overlooking the expansive view of Lake Michigan. Bare trees line the area, and the clear blue sky reflects on the water's surface.

Home in Lakeside

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Enjoy your own private beach on Lake Michigan

Freshly renovated Lake Michigan home with beautiful private beach. Living room, sun room and dining area comfortably fits group. Bright, new kitchen with huge island, pro range, dishwasher. Four newly appointed bedrooms sleep 10 comfortably. Two fully renovated bathrooms, towel warmer. Beachside gear hut has chairs, umbrellas, more. Walk to Whistle Stop and Roadhouse. 10 min to New Buffalo, Sawyer, Three Oaks. Year-round amenities: fireplace, outdoor fire pit, Jacuzzi hot tub.

Guest favourite

An aerial view of the three-story home reveals multiple balconies, each equipped with outdoor seating and umbrellas. The upper deck features lounge chairs, while the lower level's patio is noted for its vibrant furnishings. Surrounding greenery adds a natural border to the property.

Home in Michigan City

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Living Well: 3 Stories, Sleeps 16+, Close to Beach

Living Well has is a 3 story home with 4 outside decks, five 4K UHD TV's, and 12 speakers powered by a state of the art Sonos Stereo System! You can play different music in 4 different locations of the house! Enjoy 3 full floors of fun and entertainment, along with an outside bar and fire pit! There's also an Xbox One and triple bunk bed on the first floor, with tons of kid's movies and toys that will keep them entertained for hours! This home can hold as many as 20 guests!

Superhost

A cozy living area features a white sofa adorned with black and white striped pillows. A decorative chandelier hangs from the wooden ceiling. A large flag with stripes is mounted on the wall, and natural light enters through a window, illuminating the space.

Home in Coloma

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

Lake Michigan Beach House |Sleeps 12 Walk to Beach

Private wooded 4BR, 2BA cottage just a 3-minute walk to Lake Michigan beach access. Enjoy a large fire pit, spacious deck, and room to relax without the crowds. Perfect for families or groups, with easy access to St. Joseph and South Haven (10 minutes). Close to wineries, golf, and dining while offering quiet, private surroundings. Ideal for guests who want lake access without beachfront pricing.

Guest favourite

A wooden deck is shown with a table and four chairs, each adorned with floral cushions. Lush green trees provide natural shade, and a view of Lake Michigan is visible in the distance, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Home in Lakeside

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Lakeview Bluff

On a gentle bluff overlooking Lake Michigan with 125' of private beach. Spacious deck with magnificent views of the setting sun. Enjoy million dollar views of Lake Michigan and your own private beach at this classic family property. Relax on the spacious deck with magnificent views of the setting sun. Play all day with access to a beach house stocked with beach toys, paddleboard, and chairs.