
House holiday rentals in New Buffalo
Find and book unique houses on Airbnb
Top-rated house rentals in New Buffalo
Guests agree: These houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Couples alert! PVT beach access, hot tub, firepit!
ADORABLE LAKESIDE COTTAGE W/YEAR-ROUND HOT TUB AND A GUEST FAVORITE - ACCESS TO SEMI-PRIVATE LAKE MICHIGAN BEACH SHARED BY JUST 10 HOMES SO IT'S NEVER CROWDED! BEACH ACCESS GATE IS 7 MIN WALK FROM COTTAGE. LOFT LIKE HOME IS SUPER CLEAN WITH VERY COMFY KING SIZE BED AND ONE PULL-OUT COUCH FOR 4 GUEST (MAX). FIREPIT SUPPLIED WITH WOOD, AN OUTDOOR PATIO AND WEBER GRILL - YOU WILL LOVE IT! Bike/walking path out front and just 10 mins to New Buffalo, Whistle Stop, coffee - just steps away!! HURRY!

-The District 5 Schoolhouse-
The District 5 Schoolhouse was historically built "with not a single nail in the structure" in the 1800's. It still stands as a symbol of dedication to craftsmanship and community. Lovingly restored, preserving as much of the original soul as possible, it promises to be a luxury stay in understated sophistication with 100% linen sheets, beautiful kitchen/dining, lovely private outdoor space, tranquil idyllic work/recharge areas, and enough space to make your own history. You won't want to leave.

Beach! Hot Tub! New Buffalo! Firepit! King Bed!
Highlights: ✔ 8-person Hot Tub ✔ Sleeps 12 (10 in main house + 2 in guest cabin) ✔ 1 mile to beach ✔ 6 min to Shady Creek Winery ✔ 10 min to New Buffalo + Michigan City ✔ Outdoor firepit & picnic table ✔ Gas BBQ grill ✔ Smart TVs & board games ✔ King bed in main bedroom ✔ Luxury custom-designed home ✔ Private wooded lot ✔ 2 Adult & 2 kids' bikes ✔ Beach chairs, toys, wagon and towels ✔ Pickleball paddles & nearby courts ✔ 4 vehicle parking ✔ 2-person workstation ✔ High speed wifi ✔ Fully stocked

Designer Cottage - walking distance to downtown
Dream cottage getaway just over an hour from downtown Chicago. Walking distance from the beach, restaurants and all of downtown New Buffalo. Close to the casino, wineries and breweries. Whether driving in or taking the train, The Bradford is a relaxing yet sophisticated getaway. Eat, drink, and enjoy the beach, the pool, the shops and incredible summer sunsets, all within walking distance! Please note pool/bathhouse open late May - September and is shared with our association.Permit C22-0051

Captain's Quarters - Walk to Downtown New Buffalo!
Escape to New Buffalo and unwind at our recently renovated home! A quick 10 min walk will take you to fantastic shops, dining, and drinks. Our professionally designed 4 bed, 2.5 bath home comfortably sleeps 10. Located in a peaceful neighborhood, the large backyard includes a grill, fire pit, and outdoor dining area. Less than 1 mile from the beach & Amtrak station, 5 min to Union Pier, 15 min to Michigan City, 40 min to South Bend, 75 min from Chicago. Stay and enjoy Harbor Country in style!

Designer's Own Cozy Cottage
Kick back and unwind in this stylish getaway, ideally located in Union Pier and just a five-minute drive to New Buffalo. Tucked on the lake side of Red Arrow Highway, the Casita offers the perfect balance - close to all the action, yet a quiet retreat to call your own. Guests love visiting nearby beaches, indulging in baked goods, ice cream, local restaurants and wineries. Bike trails, hiking, pickle ball, golf and kayaking all nearby. Endless opportunities for relaxation and adventure await!

Steps to Beach & Starbucks! Private Yard, Firepit!
Walk to Starbucks! Walk to beach, cafes, shops, ice cream, grocery! 2 queen bed 2 bath home is perfect to enjoy fenced yard, grill, fire pit, & yard games! Take a few days to explore wineries/breweries, art galleries, antique stores, kayaking, casino and more! Live bands Fridays/Saturdays till around 2am Memorial Weekend to Fall, New Year's at Casey's (behind property). Noise machines in each bdrm. Pet fee $100, 2 dogs MAX. Exterior areas have video/audio cameras w/live feeds. Wp#bcnbwmech

TRYON FARM MID-MODERN SPA IN THE WOODS
Come, enjoy our Tryon Farm modern spa. A Sustainable luxurious open concept tree-house in the woods. Minutes from the beach with an outdoor sauna, Hottub, shower, and Mr. Steam. Perfect for two or a family/group adventure. A true destination with Yoga studio, Mirror by LuLu lemon and wellness elements. The house is a perfect balance of art and nature and luxury and spiritual. Treat yourself to a farm to table, hand made, locally sourced chef services for an extra special experience.

Aunt Betty's Lakeside Abode, Hot Tub Steam Shower
Aunt Betty’s Lakeside Abode offers 3 king bedrooms, 2.5 baths, 2 twin cots, west-facing beautiful Stone Lake views, screened porch with gas fire, lakeside terrace, and year-round hot tub. Enjoy multiple gathering areas, a steam shower, ping-pong. Perfect for families, couples, or groups exploring LaPorte County, Indiana Dunes or wineries, breweries, trails surrounding Lake Michigan. Sleeps 8, or book with Uncle Larry’s Lake Place next door for larger groups and shared lakefront fun!

Barn & Beach Guest house New Buffalo/Union Pier
MODERN cottage located at ground zero in Union Pier ! Location is just the BEST !! 2200sq ft , 4 bed , 2 bath , hot tub . 6 blocks to Townline beach , Timothy’s, Red Arrow Road house , Whistle stop , 1 block to Seeds Brewery ,Union Pier Social , Black Currant Bakery , 2 grocery & beach store . Bike path directly across street , plenty of bikes to use ! (Main home in front also available for large groups , there’s room for up to 25 people with both homes ).

Debs Michigan hot tub house, open all year
Our cozy, cute 3 bedroom 2 bathroom home with a large yard for summer fun and relaxation. You will be a short 6 block walk to beautiful Lake Michigan to view the magnificent sun sets. Harbor Country wineries, breweries, and distilleries are short drive away.We are 40 minutes from South Bend and Notre Dame Football. Come back and relax in the hot tub .Harbor Country has many orchards of apples and fall harvest vegetables. Enjoy the electric fireplace .

Eagles Beach Nest 2:Pet-Friendly*Fenced*Walk2Beach
Discover the charm of New Buffalo from our cozy haven, perfectly located near the beach, Marina, and Bentwood Tavern. Explore downtown's treasures by foot, indulge in nearby wineries, or venture to Four Winds and Blue Chip Casinos. Nestled in Harbor Country's heart, our retreat is ideal for weekend escapes, families, or groups. Pets? They're welcome, with a secure fenced backyard for their delight. Experience New Buffalo's allure from our refined abode.
Popular amenities for New Buffalo house rentals
House rentals with a pool

Beautiful home in Beachwalk/Notre Dame weekends

NB Getaway with HotTub, Pool & Priv Screening Room

Atomic Acres-POOL, Summer 2026 Awaits!

5 Bedroom Luxury Home In Heart of Beachwalk Resort

New Hot tub Heated Pool Union Pier

Modern Farmhouse - Walk to Downtown, beach & pool!

Cozy~Well-Curated Home•Private Pool• Dog-friendly!

Pool & Hot Tub • Walk to Lake
Weekly house rentals

Mid Century Modern A- Frame nestled in the woods

Cozy cabin for two w/hot tub

Uptown walkable, beach 1 mile away!

New Buffalo Charming Lake House CR23-0079

The Hudson 14mi to New Buffalo!

Mid Century Beauty with Huge Sunny Porch

Enjoy your own private beach on Lake Michigan

Dog-Friendly Modern Farmhouse, Beach, Restaurants
Private house rentals

The Honey Bee Lakeside

Schoolhouse- Fenced Yard & Pet Friendly, Game Room

Jenna’s Beach Retreat

Fascinating & Fun Family Haven w hot tub!

Lake Home w/ Amazing Views

Capt Whittaker’s Place! In Downtown New Buffalo!

Wooded Oasis by the Beach

For Shore
When is the best time to visit New Buffalo?
| Month | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sept | Oct | Nov | Dec |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Avg. price | $497 NZD | $428 NZD | $475 NZD | $509 NZD | $639 NZD | $842 NZD | $896 NZD | $927 NZD | $664 NZD | $612 NZD | $514 NZD | $522 NZD |
| Avg. temp | -4°C | -3°C | 3°C | 9°C | 15°C | 20°C | 22°C | 22°C | 18°C | 11°C | 4°C | -1°C |
Quick stats about house rentals in New Buffalo

Total holiday rentals
Explore 110 holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Nightly prices starting at
New Buffalo holiday rentals start at $185 NZD per night before taxes and fees

Verified guest reviews
Over 6,420 verified reviews to help you choose

Family-friendly holiday rentals
110 properties offer extra space and kid-friendly amenities

Pet-friendly accommodation
Find 50 rentals that welcome pets

Holiday rentals with a pool
40 properties feature pools

Rentals with dedicated workspaces
50 properties have a dedicated workspace

Wi-Fi availability
110 of New Buffalo holiday rentals include Wi-Fi access

Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across New Buffalo rentals

4.8 Average rating
New Buffalo stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Holiday rentals
- Northeast Ohio Holiday rentals
- Platteville Holiday rentals
- Indianapolis Holiday rentals
- Downtown Chicago Holiday rentals
- Columbus Holiday rentals
- Louisville Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Southern Indiana Holiday rentals
- St. Louis Holiday rentals
- Cleveland Holiday rentals
- Cincinnati Holiday rentals
- Lakehouse rentals New Buffalo
- Rentals with a fire pit New Buffalo
- Family-friendly rentals New Buffalo
- Rentals with a washing machine and dryer New Buffalo
- Cabin rentals New Buffalo
- Rentals with a fireplace New Buffalo
- Rentals with outdoor seating New Buffalo
- Rentals with a hot tub New Buffalo
- Pet-friendly rentals New Buffalo
- Fitness-friendly rentals New Buffalo
- Cottage rentals New Buffalo
- Rentals with beach access New Buffalo
- Beach house rentals New Buffalo
- Apartment rentals New Buffalo
- Condo rentals New Buffalo
- Rentals with pools New Buffalo
- Rentals with lake access New Buffalo
- Rentals with a patio New Buffalo
- Beachfront rentals New Buffalo
- House rentals Berrien County
- House rentals Michigan
- House rentals United States
- Lincoln Park
- Wrigley Field
- Millennium Park
- United Center
- Grant Park
- Navy Pier
- Soldier Field
- 875 North Michigan Avenue
- The Field Museum
- Warren Dunes State Park
- Humboldt Park
- Shedd Aquarium
- University of Notre Dame
- Guaranteed Rate Field
- Union Park
- University of Chicago
- Lincoln Park Zoo
- Chicago River Walk
- Washington Park Zoo
- Loyola University Chicago
- Indiana Dunes State Park
- Oak Street Beach
- Museum of Science and Industry
- Willis Tower





