Holiday rentals with a pool in North Captiva Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

My Sea Shack~ 1 minute to beach, SH Club, G-Cart

Let "My Sea Shack" be your home away from home while you recharge your mind, body and soul on our island oasis, North Captiva! We are an unspoiled, low-key tropical paradise off the coast of Southwest Florida. This means that our beaches are uncrowded, and tourists and traffic are just a mainland memory! Leave your car and your cares at the marina because this island is only accessible by water taxi, boat or private aircraft. Each day, after exploring our paradise (by provided golf cart), let this spacious property welcome you back. Our new stilt home was built in 2018 and is ready to meet all your vacation needs! It features 2 bedrooms and a pull-out couch which will comfortably sleep 6. The master’s over-sized king bed will provide a nightly hug and a warm place to dream. Not tired quite yet...put on some tv and fall asleep while watching your favorite show on the flat screen. The 2nd bedroom can accommodate 3 people eaily with a comfy queen bed and twin. This room also has a flat screen making it a little easier for guests or little ones to doze off. In the morning, start your day off with your cup of coffee or tea on our sprawling deck. Relax and unwind in this comfortable home away from home! Spend your days on our beaches or stay as busy as you’d like with four on-island restaurants, two bars, kayak rentals, fishing charters, private chefs, cabana rentals, craft making opportunities, bicycle rentals, sunset cruises and our favorite - island hopping charters! My Sea Shack also comes with resort like amenities…take a dip in the community pool, play a game of tennis, enjoy priority seating at Safety Harbor’s restaurant -> On The Water or bring your private boat and have access to a boat slip (small daily fee applies). What makes this property TRULY SPECIAL though is the fact that it is only a 2-minute walk to Safety Harbor’s private beach entrance. This beach is so secluded, you will feel like you are on your own private beach. Choose your itinerary, let us take care of the rest~ your next adventure on North Captiva awaits. HOW TO GET TO THE ISLAND AND HOUSE Island Girl Charters has a ferry that runs from Pine Island to North Captiva. At the marina, you can leave your vehicle there. The boat crew will load up your luggage and groceries onto the ferry and you will be on your way..the actual ride is only about 20 minutes long. Many times you will see dolphins trailing behind as you make your way to the island. Upon arriving at the Safety Harbor drop off, our conceirge service will pick you up and load your belongings onto a trailer. If this is the first time, they will be happy to give you a quick tour before taking you to the house. The conceirge service will also take you back to Safety Harbor upon departure. INCLUDED~ Water osmosis system Wifi Netflix, disney +, hulu, amazon prime DVD player Blue-ray player 6 beach chairs Umbrella Beach towels Beach games Sand toys Pickle ball set Grill Propane tank Pack & play Highchair All spices Courant pizza maker (for frozen pizzas) Mixer Can opener Toaster Coffee maker Blender All kitchen cutlery Blowdryer T-fal cookware Vacuum Cleaning supplies Laundry det pods Hand soap Dish soap Toilet paper Paper towels 1 bottle of wine

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Villa in Cape Coral

LAST Minute! NEW Villa-Heated Saltwater Pool & Spa

Experience Cape Coral like never before all from this gorgeous 3bedroom, 3bath villa. This elegant villa boasts a vibrant interior decorated with Italian furniture and fully equipped kitchen. Begin your day with a few laps in the private pool before heading to the Yacht Club Public Beach, Sun Splash Family Waterpark or Pine Island to soak up some sun! After adventurous days, continue making memories back home with a family barbecue and a soak in the hot tub or have a movie night with loved ones!

Condo in Fort Myers Beach

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Oceanfront Views + Balcony Sunsets Bikes Included

“Caihlin, you were a phenomenal host.” – Sandy, May 2025 ☀️ What You’ll Love: • Unbeatable Views: Floor-to-ceiling glass sliders open to the Gulf—watch dolphins, sunsets, and seabirds from your private balcony. • Free Beach Bikes: Cruise the beach or explore nearby Lovers Key with the 2 bikes we provide. • Updated Interior: Modern kitchen, stainless appliances, granite countertops, and a cozy living area with coastal decor. • Comfy King Bed: Sleep to the sound of waves in a plush king-size

Superhost

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Panoramic Ocean Views, Sleeps 10, Heated Pool

🧭 The Compass Rose | Beachfront Getaway 🌴 Steps from the island’s widest, most beautiful beach with panoramic Gulf views, a private heated pool, 2 golf carts, and 4 kayaks! Enjoy 4 king bedrooms, 5 decks (including a rooftop perch!), a gourmet kitchen, ping pong, foosball, and more. Located 50 yards from the only public Gulf beach access with golf cart parking. Explore North Captiva—Florida’s secret island paradise, accessible only by boat. Sleeps 10. Pet-friendly (case-by-case). No parties.

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

" Here Comes The Fun" Absolutely Magnificent! Home

HERE COMES THE FUN! Doo-d-Doo-Doo FUN FUN FUN HERE IT COMES! No detailed has been missed. This is truly a luxury home. HERE COMES THE FUN is a single story 3-bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home. Finished in early 2020 it was built on 2.5 lots or on one half acre of sand. Its location is only a 3.5-minute walk on a white sand path-like road past just 4 houses to the largest beach on the island. There is public access and golf cart parking available there and that isn’t always the case on other streets.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 225 reviews

Home in Cape Coral

LUX Villa w/ Private Salt Water Pool, Lanai, Canal

Are you looking to swim, relax outdoors, fish and take in beautiful sunsets on a wide gulf access canal? If so you will fall in love with this stunning newly constructed custom built home! The 2750 square foot home is bright & airy with two main bedroom on-suites & a separate family wing! The gourmet kitchen, dining room & great room open via large sliders to the lanai & pool w/ views of the canal in much desired SW Cape! Beach inspired villa! Large captains walk & Tiki! Check out our reviews!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Welcome to Paradise at CollinsCoveCaptiva!

Welcome to your dream getaway in this beautifully updated, turnkey Key West-style home located in the heart of Captiva Island within walking distance to the village. Nestled in the charming Sunset Captiva community—lined with brick-paver streets—this home offers direct access to award-winning beaches and a private marina on the Bay. Boater’s Paradise? Immediate availability for the brand-new HOA-maintained boat docks. Or spend your days relaxing in the oversized, heated resort-style pool.

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Remodeled 4 Bedroom House w Private Heated Pool

Nama-Stay is located on a barrier island in southwest Florida. In fact, the only way to get to the island by boat or private plane. This is THE spot for a relaxing beach vacation. Enjoy your own private heated pool along with all the amenities that are offered by the island's private club. The house also comes with two golf carts so you can easily explore all the island has to offer. This house is a 30 second golf cart ride to the Island Club and a 1 minute golf cart ride to beach access!

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

2/2 SandDollars, CLUB, Boat Slip

“Sand Dollars”—a 2 bed, 2 bath beach house on North Captiva, a private island only accessible by boat. A quick 30 minute trip from Pine Island, North Captiva is a golf cart only island (that’s right, no cars!) that has the best beaches and shelling in the area. Sand Dollars is located one block in from the beach (200 steps). Sand Dollars has a Island Club membership with access to 2 swimming pools, paddle boards, kayaks. BYOB—bring your own boat and park at our boat slip (extra fee).

Home in North (Upper) Captiva

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Sandy Toes Villa - North Captiva - Water Views

Enjoy a spectacular sunrise from your private lanai, relax on our pristine beach accessed via private access point, watch the sun sink over the Gulf of Mexico while enjoying an evening cocktail from the Club Gazebo, live the island life at Mango's or indulge in a locally sourced meal at OTW. Looking to splurge? We got you covered! Private chef services and in-home massage are available during your stay. Enjoy all of this and more during your stay at Sandy Toes Villa! Bring your boat!

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Blue Laguna - Vacation in paradise!

Beautiful and welcoming are just two words to describe this magnificent, 4 story home with heated private pool and sweeping 360 degree water views from the observation deck. Blue Laguna features 3 bedrooms and 3 full baths allowing this home to sleep up to 6 people. Two screened in lanai's so you can sit and enjoy the island breeze and leave the sliding doors open for a true island nature experience during the colder seasons. A golf cart for 4 persons is also included in the rental.