Airbnb your place

Boutique hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Find and book unique boutique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Guests agree: These boutique hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Superhost
A spacious guest room features hardwood flooring and a comfortable bed with neutral bedding. The room includes a wooden nightstand and a lamp, while a large mirror and a television are positioned on the wall. A small desk area and closet add functionality to the space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.75 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Somewhere in the Hamptons

Southampton LI Hotel - Your Next Vacation Destination. Conveniently located, only minutes from the world's famous Cooper's Beach and charming Village of Southampton with numerous restaurants, cafes and boutiques - Southampton Long Island Hotel will be your favorite lodging choice in the Hamptons. Open all year long - it is perfect for the summer beach getaway, business retreat, relaxing tour of exceptional wineries or just for a well deserved relaxing weekend as a treat for yourself.

The hotel name, 'The Menhaden', is prominently displayed on a sleek white wall. The modern typography is bold and minimal, contributing to a clean and contemporary aesthetic.
Hotel room in North Fork

Luxury Lifestyle Hotel, Greenport Village, NY

Located in the heart of Greenport Village, The Menhaden is a boutique hotel with high-end service and modern amenities. Enjoy the North Fork’s only hotel roof deck and easy access to all the North Fork has to offer, including local vineyards and the beach. Less than two hours from New York City, visit us by train, Jitney, boat or car.

Superhost
A spacious room is presented with warm-toned walls and hardwood flooring. A comfortable bed with neutral bedding is positioned alongside wooden nightstands and lamps. A dresser and a desk are visible, while a television is mounted on the wall, providing convenient entertainment options.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.56 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Southampton Long Island Hotel

Southampton Long Island Hotel - Your Southampton Escape. Conveniently located, only minutes from the world's famous Cooper's Beach and charming Village of Southampton. All rooms feature private baths, air conditioning, cable TV. Wireless Internet.

Guest favourite
A private outdoor space features a round wooden table surrounded by four white chairs. Bright green grass is visible, and sliding glass doors reveal a well-lit room with a spacious bed inside, framed by contemporary architecture.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Cottage Room at Topping Rose House

Topping Rose House is the most charming estate in the entire Hamptons. With a classic mansion from the 1840s overlooking the property, Topping Rose House blends the history of Bridgehampton with the new, crisp feel of contemporary design.

Superhost
A cozy room is furnished with a spacious bed dressed in neutral tones. A wooden nightstand and a desk are present, complemented by warm lighting from lamps. A wall-mounted television is visible, and a closet is neatly integrated into the room's design.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Southampton Hotel Room

Hotel - 14 rooms - different sizes (single / double and suites) - close to all beaches, parks, wineries and great places to eat. We have very clean rooms and affordable prices.

Superhost
A well-appointed room features a spacious bed with smooth linens, complemented by bedside lamps providing soft illumination. A wooden dresser and a desk are positioned against the wall, while a television is mounted for entertainment. Light hardwood flooring enhances the inviting space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Southampton LI Hotel

Hotel 14 rooms different sizes (single / double and suites) - close to all. beaches,parks,wineries,sagharbor,great places to eat. We have great rooms and affordable prices.

A well-lit studio room features a spacious bed with crisp white linens and matching pillows. A modern kitchenette is visible in the background, equipped with appliances. A glass top dining table accompanies a gray chair, while a blue sofa adds contrast, creating a balanced living area.
Hotel room in The Hamptons

Chic Centrally Located Full Service Condo

Popular amenities for Shelter Island Heights boutique hotels

KitchenWi-FiPoolFree parking on premisesAir conditioning

Family-friendly boutique hotels

The hotel name, 'The Menhaden', is prominently displayed on a sleek white wall. The modern typography is bold and minimal, contributing to a clean and contemporary aesthetic.
Hotel room in North Fork

Luxury Lifestyle Hotel, Greenport Village, NY

Superhost
A spacious guest room features hardwood flooring and a comfortable bed with neutral bedding. The room includes a wooden nightstand and a lamp, while a large mirror and a television are positioned on the wall. A small desk area and closet add functionality to the space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.75 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Somewhere in the Hamptons

Superhost
A well-appointed room features a spacious bed with smooth linens, complemented by bedside lamps providing soft illumination. A wooden dresser and a desk are positioned against the wall, while a television is mounted for entertainment. Light hardwood flooring enhances the inviting space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Southampton LI Hotel

A well-lit studio room features a spacious bed with crisp white linens and matching pillows. A modern kitchenette is visible in the background, equipped with appliances. A glass top dining table accompanies a gray chair, while a blue sofa adds contrast, creating a balanced living area.
Hotel room in The Hamptons

Chic Centrally Located Full Service Condo

Superhost
A spacious room is presented with warm-toned walls and hardwood flooring. A comfortable bed with neutral bedding is positioned alongside wooden nightstands and lamps. A dresser and a desk are visible, while a television is mounted on the wall, providing convenient entertainment options.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.56 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Southampton Long Island Hotel

Superhost
A cozy room is furnished with a spacious bed dressed in neutral tones. A wooden nightstand and a desk are present, complemented by warm lighting from lamps. A wall-mounted television is visible, and a closet is neatly integrated into the room's design.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Southampton Hotel Room

Guest favourite
A private outdoor space features a round wooden table surrounded by four white chairs. Bright green grass is visible, and sliding glass doors reveal a well-lit room with a spacious bed inside, framed by contemporary architecture.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Cottage Room at Topping Rose House

Other boutique hotel holiday rentals

The hotel name, 'The Menhaden', is prominently displayed on a sleek white wall. The modern typography is bold and minimal, contributing to a clean and contemporary aesthetic.
Hotel room in North Fork

Luxury Lifestyle Hotel, Greenport Village, NY

Superhost
A spacious guest room features hardwood flooring and a comfortable bed with neutral bedding. The room includes a wooden nightstand and a lamp, while a large mirror and a television are positioned on the wall. A small desk area and closet add functionality to the space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.75 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Somewhere in the Hamptons

Superhost
A well-appointed room features a spacious bed with smooth linens, complemented by bedside lamps providing soft illumination. A wooden dresser and a desk are positioned against the wall, while a television is mounted for entertainment. Light hardwood flooring enhances the inviting space.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Southampton LI Hotel

A well-lit studio room features a spacious bed with crisp white linens and matching pillows. A modern kitchenette is visible in the background, equipped with appliances. A glass top dining table accompanies a gray chair, while a blue sofa adds contrast, creating a balanced living area.
Hotel room in The Hamptons

Chic Centrally Located Full Service Condo

Superhost
A spacious room is presented with warm-toned walls and hardwood flooring. A comfortable bed with neutral bedding is positioned alongside wooden nightstands and lamps. A dresser and a desk are visible, while a television is mounted on the wall, providing convenient entertainment options.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.56 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Southampton Long Island Hotel

Superhost
A cozy room is furnished with a spacious bed dressed in neutral tones. A wooden nightstand and a desk are present, complemented by warm lighting from lamps. A wall-mounted television is visible, and a closet is neatly integrated into the room's design.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Southampton Hotel Room

Guest favourite
A private outdoor space features a round wooden table surrounded by four white chairs. Bright green grass is visible, and sliding glass doors reveal a well-lit room with a spacious bed inside, framed by contemporary architecture.
Hotel room in The Hamptons
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Cottage Room at Topping Rose House

Quick stats about boutique hotels in Shelter Island Heights

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Shelter Island Heights holiday rentals start at $624 NZD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 700 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wi-Fi and Pool across Shelter Island Heights rentals

  • 4.7 Average rating

    Shelter Island Heights stays receive an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 from guests

Destinations to explore