Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Sussex County

We had an unforgettable stay at this magical cabin! Izzy and Joe are amazing hosts—warm, responsive, and incredibly thoughtful. Check-in was seamless, and since late checking was requested by them , they kindly offered a late checkout, which we truly appreciated and made our departure more relaxed. The cabin itself is even better than the photos—beautifully decorated, full of natural light, and thoughtfully designed. The bedroom and sunroom with lake views quickly became our favorite cozy spots. The private island with its dreamy daybed swing and breathtaking lake views felt like a hidden paradise, and our dog loved roaming leash-free on the island. Everything in the cabin is intuitively organized, with smart controls for lighting, shades, and TV—managed via an iPad that also contains a well-designed digital guide. We’ve stayed at many cabins over the years, and this one stands out in every way. We’re already planning to return and make this special place an annual tradition

Shiying’s house was perfect for our family get together. Everyone felt comfortable, the view was outstanding, we sat on the side deck for hours. We had plenty of towels, linens, kitchen was stocked, beds were comfy and the dining table sat all of us which is very important to us. And plenty of parking which is not easy to find on the lake!

Had a fun wknd stay. Clean, stylish, easy and comfortable! Would recommend.

Spent a weekend here with friends and had an awesome time. Yevgeniy was extremely accommodating, and responded to any questions very quickly. I would 100% come back.

Lisa was extremely kind and helpful before and throughout our stay. The house was beautiful and we had an awesome weekend in Warwick. Would definitely come back!

Such a beautiful location on the lake and great home - spacious and very clean! Jose was incredibly responsive and a great host. Check-in and check-out was very easy, which is always appreciated. Hope we can come back someday!!

Susan was an excellent host, and everything was clean! The place had all the amenities we needed and more. Finding the location was easy, and Susan provided a wealth of information about places to visit with my family, especially taking the weather into account. I will definitely book again. See you soon!

We loved staying at this beautiful home in the woods. We have a family of five and my mother in law was with us, yet we had plenty of space and the yard was great for the kids to run around in. Despite the woodsy surroundings, restaurants and grocery were close by and we were only about 15-20 minutes from Legoland. Overall just a lovely in what is obviously a well loved and well taken care of house.

Julia was great at sending clear instructions for check in prior to arrival. She even let us know the room was ready a little early. The place is setup just like a hotel room with a small kitchenette, the bed and a pull out couch. Very clean. Can’t speak on the amenities, we were basically just there to get ready for a wedding & sleep. Def would recommend!

We stayed for an athletic event nearby. We appreciated that the accommodations were pet friendly so we could travel with a dog. The space was decently sized and very clean. The furnishings were very basic but workable and we had everything we needed in the kitchen. The mattresses are on the softer side (depending on your preference you may or may not like this). We were on the first floor and the walls were a little thin and we could hear our upstairs neighbors at times, which for us was not ideal because we had early evenings/early mornings. We otherwise had a very comfortable stay.

This is the second time my husband and I booked with Alev. It was just as enjoyable and beautiful, even though the sun didn't come out as much as it did last time. Fishing was good, using the kayaks was fun, enjoyed nearby stores and restaurants, and it was good to catch up with Alev, all in all a great time!

Jay is an extremely generous and thoughtful host and his place is very comfortable, well stocked with everything you might need and in a beautiful area. It may feel off the beaten path (which isn't a bad thing) but it was honestly very easy to get to all the places I need to go. I would highly recommend Jay's place and would stay there again if the need arises. Book it, you won't be disappointed.

You definitely want to stay here. Everything was wonderful and the location is PRICELESS. Book here and you won’t be disappointed.

I really enjoyed my stay. Liubov was very responsive .The house was very clean, exactly as described. I found everything I needed, very nicely decorated. I would highly recommend this property.

Clear communications, accurate descriptions, great stay.

We truly enjoyed our time in Montague. Lisa and Mark are wonderful hosts, anticipating and catering to our every need. The space met our needs perfectly and we had a most comfortable and relaxed time there. We will definitely book here again the next time we are in the area.