House holiday rentals in Fire Island

Michael’s place was amazing, means a few friends stayed this weekend for my birthday. He was always willing to help and very accommodating! The house itself is so beautiful and had everything we needed! It was our first time in The Hamptons and he gave us tons of recommendations!

We had a lively stay at David and Michiko's place. It was a perfect little getaway for 2 young familes of four. The pool was great, and it was a short drive to the beach. Lots of great restaurants around also!

The house and gardens are beautiful. We enjoyed the outdoor deck with grill and pool, as well as the outdoor seating at a table with gas heating on it. Inside is wonderful, as well. Well equipped kitchen. Nicholas was very responsive and addressed our needs quickly.

This Home was Amazing!! Anastasia is Phenomenal, I could see why they are Super Hosts. Their home is Beautiful and very clean. It’s filled with amenities! all that are in the description. So much so we didn’t even get a chance to take advantage of them all. We were only there for two days. Next time it’ll be much longer. I love this place!

This is a beautiful farmhouse setting with gorgeous gardens, chickens, a nice screened in private porch, and a very friendly and adorable kitty. Jessica was a great host and provided some delicious homemade yogurt with milk and fruit, and plenty of coffee and tea. We brought our dog and he was comfortable there, we had plenty of space to walk him around.

Our stay was stunning. The location is quiet and peaceful yet close enough to the town to get what you may need. The home itself is absolutely gorgeous. It’s clean, the layout is beautiful, and the views are out of this world. A truly incredible place to stay. The beds were very comfortable, the kitchen was perfect, and each room has a full bath which was great for our family. Overall highly recommend

Our family of 5 and pup had the best time on this gorgeous property! The photos do not do the artful design justice, it’s simply stunning and so thoughtful. Our kids swam ever day and loved the pool. We enjoyed Grace Farms, Prospect Movie Thester and a lovely Father’s Day meal at the Inn at Pound Ridge. The kitchen is incredibly well stocked for someone who likes to cook and DoorDash was also easy to use when we didn’t feel like cooking. We will definitely be back! Thank you, RJ and John!

Ben is a super host. His home is absolutely beautiful and well managed. His thoughtful recommendations and well timed check ins and reminders were the height of polished professionalism. We felt right at home, down to the bins of toys in the living room that our toddler and baby played with every day.

Kim was an incredible host! Not only is her home absolute stunning, there was such an incredible attention to detail and house is equipped with absolutely everything you need during your visit to FI!

Great weekend stay with some friends. Great location close to ferry as well as the beach. We loved the space and would definitely come back again and recommend to others.

Our stay at the house was wonderful experience. Our host Michael whom fortunately we met personally is one of the nicest person you’ll encounter in life. The surrounding and the grounds were so beautiful that you will enjoy when you stay at that house. Many thanks to our host and his well managed house. The place is very close to all lovely restaurants, shopping areas, etc. We all highly appreciated and recommend to stay at this place for any occasion and vacation. Thank you again and hopefully will stay in the future. Your guest Janneta 😀❤️

Perfect place for a weekend of beach walks !

Ashley’s house is the perfect get away. I booked this house for my family to stay for my wedding weekend. My mom had never stayed in an Airbnb before and I’ve never seen her so happy and relaxed. She truly enjoyed her first Airbnb experience at Ashley’s place. It was exactly as described and the view is beautiful. Ashley was very responsive and made sure to answer any questions I had.

The house was perfect, confortable and clean. We enjoyed our time on the nice terrasse with a stunning view. John is very helpful and reactive.

One of the best AirBnBs we've ever stayed at, and we've stayed at many! Our host was super friendly, very responsive and helpful. We had some welcome treats which were greatly appreciated. The house is really well renovated and decorated, and it's very comfortable for a family of 4 (I suspect you could be comfortable with 6 people). The backyard and especially the pool is really beautiful and we spent hours enjoying the pool. We also loved that we could walk 5-7 minutes into town to explore the cute few local shops/restaurants. Smith Point Beach was an easy 20 minute drive away, and there's lots of things to do within a half hour drive. Overall, we would likely come back to Bellport specifically so we can stay at this place. Highly recommended!

Michael’s place was in the perfect location For our needs . Very clean and great finished downstairs area . Michael is super responsive to any questions or needs . We will return!!

Spent a long weekend here with one other couple and had an amazing first trip to the North Fork. Karine's home was beautiful and close to everything we wanted to see, and her recommendations were excellent and super helpful! I hope to come back soon and would absolutely recommend this place to others. Thank you Karine!

A very nice and spacious house, quietly located in the countryside. In 5 minutes by foot you are on the water. The neighborhood is very quiet and in the morning you can hear a lot of birds. Communication in advance was great. It was even responded to the wish of a toaster. The rooms are nice and the beds very cozy. There were three of us and we had good space. The kitchen is very well equipped with everything you need. There was even water ready upon arrival. In the living room there is a large TV with Netflix.

After using Airbnb for years now no other place was a perfect 10. The lake house was simply great. Not only the physical status but the follow up and generosity of the hosts where beyond. We didn’t want to leave.

We had a great stay at the Airbnb. One thing I haven’t seen mentioned in the reviews or descriptions is that this beach had tons of sea glass! In our short stay we found over 100 pieces and my 4 year old was absolutely delighted scouring the beach for it. There are also tide pools less than a five minute walk from the house. These two things made the stay quite magical for my kids. Otherwise the location is great and the house was very clean. I appreciated the bed on the first level having a trundle as well as a door at the top of the stairs for safety. The house is minimally decorated which is honestly a plus when you don’t have to worry about your kid breaking nicknacks on coffee tables. A few nice throw blankets and nicer glassware would have added to the stay though. Overall we were very happy with this property.

I had a wonderful stay! The place was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and well-equipped. The host was friendly and responsive, making check-in and check-out super easy. The neighborhood was quiet and convenient, perfect for relaxing after a day out. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone visiting the area!

Meaghan was a wonderful host who was very prompt, kind, and respectful of privacy. The house itself was stylish, comfortable, and modern while being kid friendly which is a tough thing to achieve in any home let alone an Airbnb. The view from the house was an absolute highlight! We had a great time!

Francesca was very communicative throughout our stay and the home was exactly as pictured. We had some solid weather during our stay and spent plenty of time around the pool. We would definitely return!

We had such a fantastic time staying at this house. It truly felt like a home away from home. Everything was clean, well-organized, and thoughtfully set up to make our stay easy and relaxing. One of the highlights was how well-equipped the house was for kids. There were so many great toys, games, and especially books that kept our little ones happy and entertained the whole time. It made traveling with children so much easier and more enjoyable. The location is excellent. It's just a short walk or quick drive to several beaches. Mother’s Beach was a standout for us. Calm, safe, and perfect for kids to explore without worry. Overall, this house offered the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and family-friendly fun. We left feeling refreshed and already planning our return. Highly recommend it for families looking for an stress-free getaway close to NYC!