House holiday rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: These houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
A spacious outdoor deck is showcased, featuring two white lounge chairs positioned opposite a small glass table. Lush green hills are visible in the background under a partly cloudy sky, highlighting the serene natural surroundings of the retreat.
Home in Halcottsville
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

Spacecraft Sanctuary x Stargate Self-Care Retreat

Nestled into a private forested locus in the charming hamlet of Halcottsville, NY is SPACECRAFTX1 SANCTUARY, a transformed single wide trailer with walls of glass sliders that showcase the ultimate designer, Mother Nature with her majestic mountain vistas, perennial x calming Japanese rock gardens. SPACECRAFTX1 STARGATE (separate structure) is a wellness studio for yoga, pilates, barre x meditation with an infrared sauna with chromotherapy for a “Design Your Own” self-care retreat experience.

Top Guest favourite
Home in Roxbury
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Peaceful Designer Farmhouse~Hot Tub~Sunset Porch

Revel in the design of this recently renovated 3BR 1.5Bath oasis surrounded by the Catskills Mountains. It's a perfect base for your ski weekend or wedding party, nestled on the historic Burroughs Memorial Road, where the famous naturalist entertained Henry Ford and Teddy Roosevelt. ✔ Hot Tub & Fire Pit ✔ 3 Comfy BRs ✔ 2 Living Areas ✔ Chef's Kitchen ✔ Wraparound Porch (BBQ Grill, Seating) ✔ HD Projector with a Wide-Screen ✔ Guitars & Drum Set ✔ High-Speed WiFi ✔ Free Parking See more below!

Top Guest favourite
A serene waterfall cascades over moss-covered rock shelves, creating a tranquil pool at the base. The surrounding area is framed by dark, textured stones and lush green foliage, contributing to a peaceful, natural environment.
Home in Middleburgh
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Beautiful Farmhouse & Majestic Waterfall

The Sparrow House is a beautiful farmhouse with a private trail to a majestic 120' waterfall. With vintage wallpapers, eclectic antiques, a cozy fireplace, an outdoor cedar sauna, a large fenced in yard surrounded by honeysuckle vines and a spectacular mountain view, the house is a perfect getaway spot in unspoiled nature and still-wild forests of the Catskills. The waterfall is a truly magical place and considered a sacred site. The house is not appropriate for loud groups or parties. 🙏🦋🙌

Guest favourite
Home in Andes
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Andes Valley View

This home is a beautiful mix of cozy and modern. You’ll love cooking in the kitchen and taking in the view from the second story deck. The property is stunning, with wide meadows and dense woods. There are 140 acres to explore and utilize for events like weddings or a retreats. There is a half acre pond with a pond house at the top of the property and a trout stream running along the bottom. It’s everything you could hope for in a Catskills getaway, all nestled overlooking the town of Andes.

Top Guest favourite
A scenic view of Cooper Creek's property is captured, featuring a rainbow arching over green fields and trees. Various buildings, including the main house, are visible in the background against a backdrop of soft blue skies and hints of clouds.
Home in West Oneonta
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Cooper Creek

Cooper Creek is a valuable piece of central New York history that was built in the late 1700s. This homestead once included an outhouse, a spring house, a Cooper shed, and a proud hand hewn timber barn. Robby and Eileen Robbins purchased the property in 1984-finding it in desperate need of plumbing, electricity, as well as emergent repairs in order to preserve as much history as possible. The 18th century beams,& the wooden pegs used instead of nails helps it maintain its unique identity.

Top Guest favourite
A cozy outdoor space features comfortable seating and a modern fireplace, set against a stunning backdrop of lush trees and a colorful sunset. A hot tub is visible nearby, inviting relaxation. Soft lighting adds a warm touch to the tranquil atmosphere.
Home in Lexington
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Valley View Chalet: AC, Hot Tub, Firepit, Games

Spacious, peaceful lux cabin atop the Catskills. Enjoy mountain views and soak in the hot tub. Catch up in the vaulted room by the stone fireplace w/ a wide game selection, with a 2nd living room downstairs. Host a dinner party with our fully equipped kitchen. 20 mins to 6 towns. Visit breweries, antique shops, dine, hike, fish, golf, or relax. Great for groups, families, kids & pets. Fast 600mb internet, AC, EV charger, generator. WFH, newborn, pet friendly. 3+ nights get discounted rate

Guest favourite
Home in New Kingston
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Catskills Mtn. Retreat, Hot Tub, Sauna & Fire Pit

Escape to SOL® Catskills; sustainable opulent living, mountain retreat; breathtaking views and ultimate relaxation. Unwind in the private hot tub, recharge in the sauna, or enjoy a cozy evening by the fire pit. Minutes away from hiking, skiing, and charming Catskills towns, this modern cabin blends seclusion and convenience. With spacious interiors, a fully-equipped kitchen, and all-season outdoor spaces, it’s the perfect destination for your next adventure in the heart of the Catskills!

Top Guest favourite
Home in Deposit
5 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Couples Escape-Sauna-Cold Plunge-HotTub-eBikes

Enjoy a serene escape at the Scandi Farmhouse! Relax in the Finnish sauna, take a plunge in an antique cold tub. Snuggle by the bedroom gas fireplace. Melt away stress in the Hot Tub. Cruise a country road on an eBike. Enjoy a roaring campfire in the Solo Stove. Paddle on a nearby lake. Unwind to the sound of the tumbling brook and enjoy the wildlife. Spin vintage vinyl on the turntable, or strum an Ovation guitar. Enjoy a well equipped kitchen with a Sous Vide & quality cookware.

Guest favourite
A serene spa area is illuminated by soft evening light, showcasing a saltwater hot tub surrounded by stone walls. Glass doors provide a view of the starry sky, while the surrounding snow adds a tranquil winter ambiance.
Home in Roxbury
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Catskills, secluded, a renovated 1840s Barn w/SPA

Welcome to PostBeamLove. An idyllic private secluded 4-season dream 10-acre getaway. Stay and indulge in complete comfort in a fully converted 1840s Dairy Barn with indoor saltwater hot tub & sauna with mountain views, overlooking the northwestern Catskills in the heart of Roxbury. The property features a spring-fed pond, gazebo, stream, & a neighboring farm. A 10-min drive to Plattekill Mtn, one of the best-kept secrets for avid skiers. Or go hiking, have a picnic, even golf.

Guest favourite
A rustic cabin with a green metal roof features a spacious front porch adorned with comfortable seating. Large windows provide ample natural light, and a well-maintained lawn with trees offers a scenic backdrop. The tranquil setting invites relaxation and outdoor enjoyment.
Home in Oneonta
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Lakefront, family friendly home -Baseball campers!

- Lake/waterfront home on Goodyear Lake. - Conveniently located close to local baseball camps, SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick college - Large lake view patio and yard for games or campfires and lakeside deck and dock. - Enjoy swimming, excellent fishing, and watersports. Canoe, row boat, and pedal boat on site for guests. - Updated spacious home, including a fireplace and air conditioning. - Away from it all, but close to all amenities!

Top Guest favourite
A charming Swiss chalet is nestled among tall trees, surrounded by lush greenery. The house features a welcoming deck and multiple windows that provide natural light. A stone path leads to the entrance, inviting guests to explore the tranquil outdoor setting.
Home in Big Indian
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

10 Min from Bellayre! Gingerbread House!

Perched high among the trees, Gingerbread is a 1950’s Swiss chalet that sits on 4 acres. This is the house everyone slows down for, points and says ‘ that’s the house I would want Upstate’. Well ….she's taken. But I am so happy to welcome you as guests for a short period of time. Gingerbread comes with all the little touches making it feel like the perfect home away for a week, weekend or however long you can escape your regular life.

Superhost
Home in South Kortright
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 547 reviews

Inez's Studio

A former Catskills painting studio re-imagined as a quiet mountainside retreat on 23 acres. 16ft ceilings and walls of windows let in amazing light, uninterrupted nature, and solitude. Open floor plan with the main bedroom downstairs and a loft bed upstairs. Step out the back door and into a private backyard and lower field with views of the upstate NY mountains. Also check out our other 1br listing: Table on Ten Earth House

Popular amenities for Goodyear Lake house rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Otsego County
  5. Milford
  6. Goodyear Lake
  7. House rentals