Cabin holiday rentals in Otisco Lake

What a great stay! Adam was very communicative and helpful. The home was clean, beautiful and had everything that we needed. It was a great location for enjoying all that the Finger Lake region had to offer. It was also great for just relaxing and enjoying the lake. We would stay here again without hesitation!

The hosts were very responsive with my questions. This cabin was very clean, new structure, beautiful nature views. We rented for a night to celebrate a chill birthday, the game room was a blast! The hot tub was divine. The air conditioning was a lifesaver!!! The kitchen was a dream to cook dinner and breakfast in! We live local and hope to book again soon to escape reality!! Update: we booked (the day of checkout) for Christmas time with our entire family! Cant wait!!!

My partner and I enjoyed our stay here at the Finger Lakes! The location was perfect - no more than 15 minutes from many great activities, wineries, and restaurants, yet the space is in a rural setting that is peaceful and quiet. Loved hearing all the birds in the morning! The space was clean when we arrived. I have a food allergy so having access to such a clean kitchen saved a lot of time and stress! The kitchen was generally well stocked but note there is no microwave. Also, the hot tub specifically was also extremely clean! The bed was very comfortable, on the softer side. Would recommend others stay here!

We had a wonderful time during our visit. The cabin was secluded and private. Great location to hit wineries and breweries for us, we were within an hour or so of everything we wanted to do(we are used to a 20-30 minute drive on a daily basis for groceries). My favorite was the seating area on the dock overlooking the lake.

Kelly home was so charming and comfortable. She was very generous with all she provided in her lovely home. Perfect getaway for us to meet up with close friends halfway from CT. I would highly recommend for families and friends to consider staying at Kelly's cabin in the future!!

Great stay, a very cozy place!

This place is beautiful looks even nicer in person than on the pictures . It’s very peaceful and fairly easy to find they left little notes around the house to find extra linens toilet paper etc which was a very cute touch . has a lot of stuff to do outside and inside it is the perfect little get together cabin the host is very nice helpful and attentive with any questions you may have through the stay definitely recommend

Great value for the price. The cabin is older but maintained and clean. It matched the photos. It was perfect for our group. The kitchen was well-stocked with cooking utensils, plates, etc. The neighborhood is cute and quiet and close to Penn Yan (about 10 mins away) that has restaurants and grocery stores. There are also lots of local vineyards close by. We really enjoyed our stay!

Couldn’t recommend Craig or his locations more! Everything felt as comfortable as home while being in one of the most peaceful areas imaginable, I had sent Craig a few messages during my stay and he was always very helpful, extremely polite and puts his guests before himself. I will be saving his properties in a bookmark for my next travels and wouldn’t hesitate to book with him again.

We traveled from Indiana, PA to NY, so our son could escort his friends to Whitney Point Prom. We choose Wilma, as it looked inviting & relaxing & to be honest, it far exceeded our expectations. Once we got everyone off to Prom, we were able to relax on the back deck, watching/listening to the river. We even had a small fire & the kids decided to skip the After Prom & come crash our peaceful fire. The citronella candles that Charlene provided, was a huge help with the evening bugs along the river. Sunday, we spent all day relaxing on the back deck & got dinner from Magro's. If we ever find ourselves traveling to NY again, we would definitely stay at Wilma again. If it wasn't for our Bulldog missing the other 2 pups at home, we would never have wanted to leave.

The cabin was a great getaway for our family (dog and 5 year old included). It was exactly as described and the perfect place to unwind and get away from the busy world. Before we checked in Thomas and Shelly reached out and told us of an issue with the cabin that wouldn’t be able to be fixed before our vacation.(we had no issues with it while we were there) They were open and upfront with it and gave us the option of continuing our stay. It wasn’t a big deal to us but we were happy to have the information. We had rain in the forecast and Shelly made sure our 5 year old had plenty of activities to do inside so we didn’t have to worry about entering him. It was muddy due to the rain and they made sure we had extra towels for our dog. They went above and beyond to accommodate us with all we needed. Highly recommended staying and enjoying the cabin.

Our family of 4 and dog love this cabin- if we had our own, we’d want it to be just like this one. It’s exactly what we need to unplug, live more simply, and connect with nature for a few days. We love the woodburning stove, outdoor kitchen, stringing up our hammocks, and relaxing by or exploring the stream. Rod is a fantastic host!

The cabin was lovely. It was great to be cut off from wifi amd other distractions. I li ed that the host had a thoughtful collection of dvds, ping pong, dart and other board games. We also enjoyed camp fire and the kitchen had all the basic utensils that we needed. There is also a general store near by to get anything needed and lit of good restaurants nearby too.

My experience was excellent from the reservation to checkout. It’s a beautiful location and the home was perfect. It was better than I could’ve imagined. The description and pictures don’t do the property or cabin/cottage justice. It was very clean and we felt right at home. I needed a peaceful weekend away and it did not disappoint! Suzanne was very responsive and helpful. Great place! We’ve already talked about going back for a longer stay.

Karen's cabin was great, clean and had everything we needed for a restful evening. The property was beautiful and we wish we had more time to stay in the area for enjoy the outdoors a bit more. We will definitely stay here at a future date.

My boyfriend, 4 pups and I enjoyed our stay! We loved the fenced in yard for the dogs and the walk ability of the near by state park beach! The house was clean, well kept and easy to find. We thoroughly enjoyed the balcony off the bedroom.

John is the perfect host, I felt like a V-VIP. He made sure I was comfortable and was over and above helpful with every last detail. He has bikes for guests to get around on and would graciously pick me up when I got stuck down hill. He helped me with fires to enjoy the starry night sky, and escorted me to the cabin when I got back late after a wedding party. The cabin is delightful and serene, on the edge of his property looking into bright green trees. He’s got it set up for barbecues and has even put out sticks for marshmallow roasting. A cute outdoor shower, and an eco-toilet cabin behind the room. I enjoyed swimming in the lake, doing hikes at the National reserve & on the property, watching the cows on the pasture, star gazing, & trying out the local eatery spots. I highly recommend this elevated glamping experience with a host that will do anything in his power to make sure you’re happy.

I loved everything about this rustic cabin! It was great to have coffee all set to brew and the makings of a warm fire at the ready. Every morning and evening the birds song cheered me! I had everything I needed to cook a meal and relax. Thank you so much!

Nancy’s cottage was perfect for our little family of 4. We enjoyed card games on the back porch, meals al fresco w a beautiful lake view, and of course roasting marshmallows in the fire pit at sunset. The cottage was intimate and cozy and we hope to return on a regular basis. Thank you Nancy for being inviting and more than accommodating.

I was in for a long stay with work. This place was very peaceful and relaxing. Enjoyed the scenery of the lake and nature surrounding the house. House was very clean and up kept nicely as well. Thank you for the stay and absolutely recommend!

The cottage was absolutely beautiful and surrounding area/lake view was breath taking. Wonderful weekend with my fiancé and I’m definitely looking forward to returning.

This has been one of the best experiences that my wife and I have ever had. Edgar was very proactive and thorough in his directions and instructions. The cabin is very peaceful and cozy. We could have stayed forever just reading on the porch or at the table inside by the window. Just about everything you would need is provided or available on the property. We look forward to returning in the future!

This little home was so charming and cozy! It was quite chilly so we didn’t get into the pond but the view was beautiful and the house itself was whimsical and perfect for our needs! David was very responsive and came right over to help us light the stove our first night cooking. I would love to stay here again.

Beautiful location, just like the photos! And did not disappoint. Great location, close to Watkins Glen and many other ideal locations to visit. Kris and his wife were super responsive, gave great suggestions based on my interests, perfect hospitality. Highly recommend and already thinking of coming back!!