Cottage holiday rentals in Presque Isle

Kelly's cottage was perfect for me and my boys to get away! The stream behind the house was lovely and just a short paddle to Chautauqua Lake. My kids loved the hot tub! The cottage was fully stocked with dishes to cook with and coffee and snacks (my boys loved the mini popcorn!), as well as, plenty of fresh linens and towels. We had such a great time and are looking forward to making this a yearly tradition already!

Beautiful cottage with great amenities, especially the extra long dining table for our large group. We really enjoyed our stay :)

Overall, Amanda’s place was adorable and a great getaway for a long weekend! Amanda is very responsive and kind. We had a few hiccups with the house (technical things) and she was very responsive and willing to help as much as she could despite not being in the area. It is a tight space for more than 6 people. There were 7 total in our group so keep in mind it only having one shower and some close sleeping quarters. The beds were very comfy and clean though. It was still cool with the AC window units on too (if staying in the summer). All in all would stay again!

The home is so beautiful, I took pictures because I really want to build a home and it’s what I’m going to base it off of!!! Kathlene was so helpful. Anything we needed she was right on it.!! we will plan on coming again in the future! You will not be disappointed in this location or the home itself!!

This place is amazing, beautiful home with a great view. i couldnt have asked for a better place to stay in erie. would recommend tonys home to anyone.

We enjoyed our stay and found the process very easy from check in to checkout. Alissa and Jeff answered all questions quickly. Loved our time in the area and found this to be a perfect place for this area.

Parkside cottages are a great place to stay with easy access to the lake. Everything is always clean, peaceful and quiet! Since our last stay we were surprised to see some updates in the kitchen that were simple and nice. If you’re looking for a quick get away in a quiet little cabin environment, this is the spot!

we had a wonderful time, the place was amazing, so roomie and comfortably, so much to offer at the house, then a couple minute walk to the beach, the littles had a blast, can't wait to go again

The host was very responsive. We accidently locked ourselves out and he was quick to come help us out. The place was peaceful and we had a nice time.

We had such a great time staying here! The walk to the cliffs was super muddy, but we still made the best of it. It was shocking to see the sheer drop of the cliffside. We weren’t expecting that! It was a beautiful view at sunset. We were very comfortable during our stay, and hope to come again for even longer!

The Cove was a wonderful cottage within walking distance of the lake. The house had lots of nice antiques to make you feel right at home. The neighborhood is quiet and the house is a short walk from the lake. I’d stay here again if in the area.

WOW! That’s what we said when we opened the front door. The view of the lake was awesome and Barbara’s house was perfect for the 4 of us celebrating our 70th birthdays. We have stayed in many Airbnb’s before but this house had every amenity you could ask for. It is tastefully decorated and well stocked including paper products, shampoos, spices, etc. The beds were very comfortable and the view of the morning sunrise from the master bedroom was absolutely breathtaking! We visited the National Comedy Museum in Jamestown and walked the beautiful grounds of the Chautauqua Institute ! Barbara was the perfect hostess and even offered to mail the clothes we left in the dryer back to us. As one ages, we tend to remember the “moments” and forget the “things”🥴. Thank you, Barbara, for transforming your shack into a spectacular cottage and sharing it with us.

Angie's place was a last minute booking after a host on another site cancelled our original booking the morning of our check-in and we were very grateful to find Angie's place. Angie was accommodating and responsive, the property was clean, instructions for every aspect of the property were clear and available in a binder for reference when we got there, and overall we had a great time. Angie also proactively reached out to offer a later check-out time which we very much appreciated as it gave us more time to enjoy the area and have a calmer check-out. The cost for Angie's place was higher than our original booking but that was an understood consequence of booking last minute. We would very much recommend Angie's place and hope to stay there again in the future!

Rikki is the best host compared to all the other hosts we’ve had! She has absolutely everything u could possibly need! I was very happy to see a blow dryer which I forgot at home!!!! Our dog had a blast playing ball in a large area! Can’t wait to come back! Ty Rikki for everything!

A great place to stay! We enjoyed the space and found that we were never overcrowded with 9 people and a dog. The cottage was even more beautiful than the pictures show and the A/C was a great amenity! The host was amazing, welcoming and accommodating! It was so close to the little town with shops and restaurants! We will for sure be back! Totally worth the price!

Hats off to Clinton for his lovely place. We were 3 couples for a weekend getaway and the place was perfect. We especially enjoyed the backyard fire-pit and well-equipped kitchen. Beds were super comfortable. And the location was perfect for long walks on the beach. Loved walking an eagle nearby caring for her young ones. Well worthwhile!

This was our fourth time staying here. We always love staying here. Stephanie makes everything so cozy and clean and really knows how to use her space wisely. So close to everything. We will definitely be back again this summer!

We cannot say enough about how perfect this rental was. Gorgeous home with many amenities and right on the lake. Lots of lakefront views with three different patios and porches. Beautiful outdoor furniture. Three different sitting areas and two with lakefront views. The third sitting area is an entertainment area. The loft is amazing with four beds and a half bath. We were on the property to celebrate a family reunion and my birthday so we didn’t go to any restaurants. But the local bar was fun! Kayaks and bikes are available. Fabulous place!

We had an amazing stay for the weekend. This was the most accommodating Airbnb we’ve ever stayed at. Everything we needed was available. Rebecca personalized our stay for a soccer weekend and it was so thoughtful. It was a short walk to the lake and the private lake front was so peaceful. The cottage had a lot of space and was very clean. The amenities available at the cottage were great. We wish our stay could have been longer. If we are ever back in the area we would 100% choose to stay at the Little Shovel again. Thank you for a great weekend!

Exactly what we was looking for!

This houses a dream and spacious beautiful and very comfortable. It was a home away from home there was everything you needed to feel at home . Craig was always responsive in a timely manner and very accommodating to our needs .Needless to stay I will go back and stay there again without hesitation.

My inlaws and I had a great 3 night stay at this location! We visited the local wineries and Niagara falls! Perfect location, and a beautiful outdoor area and plenty of room for us 4. We got to see hummingbirds from the deck too!

Alyssa and Brian were great! They were very responsive! The place was just like the pictures and everything was clear!! They had everything you needed to cook! They had toiletries in bathroom! I brought my own but it was all there! Thank you! I hate to recommend bc I want it available for when we want to go again! lol! All seriousness definitely would recommend!!!

An amazing place, beautiful spot on the water with a great kitchen and amenities. We had a relaxing getaway and it felt like home away from home.