Cottage holiday rentals in Red Creek

Seldom, do you find a place where time stands still, the host is warm and welcoming and the location is beyond beautiful. This was our stay at Diane's cottage on the lake. We hiked local parks, kayaked the lake, enjoyed wonderful food, shopped and took in the view. Diane and her extended family were open, warm and delightful. Our regret is we didn't stay longer. Should we ever return, we will definitely stay at the cottage. Our many thanks and blessings to Diane and her family for making our stay remarkable.

Nice setting easy to get to all activities we were looking to do like Watkins glen and wineries. Tony provided detailed instructions and gave good recommendations!

We had the best family get away!! Great views from the house, kitchen has everything you need, the hot tub and fire pit were awesome bonuses and overall the place was excellent! We rent a lakefront getaway at least twice and year and this one was one of if not the best places we’ve stayed! Hosts are super nice, quick to answer any questions you have, and check in/out were super easy. And if you’re bass fishing, this is the perfect spot. 11/10!!

We had such a great girls weekend and it was a very short walk to the lake which had breathtaking views and the water was clean we went in with our water floats, close to some great restaurants and the home was immaculate with a great outdoor space, I think it was meant to be because I bought my girlfriends totes and beach towels that said GETAWAY just for the trip and as we were leaving we saw on the business cards that the home was called the Getaway !!! Too ironic ….. :) Thank you , would definitely stay again !!!

Very beautiful home! Amazing view of the lake, along with nice amenities and plenty of space!!! Very update to date and clean home and a perfect place to stay , especially for a weekend getaway!!

We had an amazing stay at the Oak cottage. Beautiful inside and out. Communication was quick and all our questions were answered. You can tell Jan takes great pride in her rentals. All the extra touches were greatly appreciated. Everything was as pictured and in working condition. The hot tub was amazing and the sharing system works great. The beds were very comfortable and the cottage was extremely clean. We would not hesitate to stay there again.

beautiful place to stay very friendly hosts great family atmosphere

We have stayed at this house multiple times. It is our home away from home at the Finger Lakes. You can’t beat the location! The house is absolutely perfect. It is a wonderful getaway. I can’t recommend it enough.

We traveled to Sodus Point with a small group of middle school aged kids as part of a learning adventure. We loved the house! The kids especially loved fishing on the dock, using the paddle boards and enjoying the games (like Spike ball) that were in the shed. We lucked out with beautiful weather and these crazy kids even went swimming in the water which was only 41F!!! We used the grill, had a fire outside and even made time for a movie night in the living room together. The house was also close enough to other things for us to make many day trips around the area. We even ventured to Niagara Falls from there - 2 hours away. We really enjoyed our time there. Michelle was very responsive to my questions and helpful when I needed it. Thank you!

Great peaceful space. The views were beautiful. The house had very cute touches and the beds were very comfortable!

Had a wonderful weekend getaway! Right across the street from Lakeshore Winery and not even a 10 min drive from plenty others. Beautiful location on the lake, would highly recommend and would def come again!

Jesse’s place was the perfect cozy-with-a-view getaway. Ideal location, relaxing, well-designed and stocked. Jesse was eager to offer suggestions and very responsive. Hope to visit again!

We had a wonderful stay at Anne's place. The stairs are very steep, but the handrail is very sturdy. We had everything we needed. We loved all the beautiful decor and how the old house has been redone to become this beauty. The beds were super comfortable and the house was able to fit all 6 of us comfortably for 5 days. We appreciated the availability of the kayaks and the close proximity to the pond where the water is super calm for beginner kayakers. Anne was quick to respond to any questions we had. The driveway is big enough for 3-4 vehicles. Thank you so much for letting us stay in your absolutely stunning home!

Airbnb was a perfect place to stay while we visited the area – even on a rainy day the lake looked beautiful! Listing was as described and the host was super responsive.

Absolutely stunning!!! We loved our stay here and are going to keep coming back time and time again! This place is amazing! We were able to get away for the weekend and enjoy each other’s company in the perfect setting! 10 / 10

This was the third year staying at Erica’s, and each time has been great. After a morning of fishing it is nice to return and relax on the waterfront. The house has plenty of room for 3 couples. The house is very comfortable, everything was ready for us when we arrived. Erica reached out to make sure we had everything we needed and that our stay was going well. Great Host and a great house

We highly enjoying our stay at Samantha’s cottage. It was a beautiful weekend getaway and the fall foliage made it even better!! The kitchen was extremely clean, and had everything we needed to cook meals during our stay. We weren’t there long enough to use the washer and dryer but I was grateful to have it if needed. The house has lots of natural sunlight, and the covered porch was great when it rained or when we didn’t want to make the walk down to the lake.

We enjoyed our stay at Grandma’s Cottage - Lake Canadaigua, NY. The porch was our favorite place and where we spent almost every moment while we were at the cottage minus sleeping. It was comfortable and offered all that we needed. Jamie and Renee were great hosts, very friendly, willing to help with any of our needs, and made good recommendations of places for us to go and see in the area. We are already making plans to stay there again in the future. Susan Colby, NC

Had a great stay. Loved the location and everything provided to enjoy the stay for 2 nights. Would love to return!

We came to see Goose at CMAC and wanted a full lake weekend and this definitely delivered! The place is beautiful, comfortable, and close to anything you’d want to do, would definitely stay again!

We loved our stay. Everything was just as described. We would definitely stay here again! David and Betsy were extremely accommodating and the bottle of local wine was a really nice touch! Thank you!

Clean, comfortable beds, beautiful back yard with the sounds of the river with a cup of coffee or the fire. Caught fish, ate good food both in town and on the grill, went to the farmers market, explored many of the towns and state parks near by. Owners gave clear instructions and responded quickly to questions.

This rental was super cute and comfortable right on the water. We had a girls weekend and had everything we needed at Courtney's place. The cottage overlooks the water and it is a beautifully clear lake. Beds were very comfortable and everything was neat and clean. There are a few set of stairs to get down to the cottage along with stairs to access the downstairs living quarters/bedroom so just be aware of that. We saw Eagles over the water and heard owls at night...very peaceful and private. Tons to do in the town of Skaneateles as well and lots of great restaurants. We would certainly recommend this rental to anyone and are looking forward to coming back!

We had an amazing stay at this lovely lakeside cottage! The host was incredibly friendly and responsive, going out of her way to meet a special request—truly above and beyond. The cottage was spotlessly clean, filled with cheerful, cozy decor, and bathed in natural light all day. The views of the lake were absolutely stunning and created such a peaceful, calming vibe. We instantly felt at home. The location is both relaxing and full of things to do—great outdoor adventures and fun indoor options nearby. A perfect escape, and we can't wait to come back!