Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Sylvan Beach

This home was great! The game room kept the kids busy, the kitchen had everything we need, and the house was nice and cozy. Waking up to the lake in the morning was a highlight. Brad was attentive to all our needs - and even when something minor needed a fix he showed up to take care of it right away. We had a great stay!

My sons and I had a great stay. The home was very clean and comfortable. Parking was easy even though we had three vehicles and a trailer. We had a great stay and are Looking forward to going back again.

Jessica was truly the definition of a Super Host. We’ve stayed in many places and I can’t tell you how amazing she was from check in to check out. Responsive, friendly, and very professional. The house is breathtaking and nicely organized, we had everything we needed. We cannot wait to return! Our family enjoyed staying at her space and we made many core memories. Book this, you won’t regret it.

I can't say enough great things about our stay! The hosts were awesome to deal with...always accommodating and available, the location was perfect...right on the water/ice, the residence exceeded our expectations and had everything we needed. The location is perfect with a short walk to exceptional fishing. No need to scramble trying to find parking...its all right there for you. We enjoyed a weekend of ice fishing with family and friends and definitely plan on coming back this year. On a scale of 1 to 10...this is an 11! Highly recommend!

If you are looking for a retreat in the form of a home away from home, I highly recommend Waterfall House. The landscape, scenery, and waterfall provided a peaceful environment. The home is very well appointed, which made us feel at home and comfortable. Nice amenities. The waterfall provided a beautiful, tranquil sound that lulled us to sleep—no sound machine was needed. Plan to drive a bit for groceries and entertainment, but it's worth it. We stayed at the property for our son's graduation from Syracuse, so we had to factor in driving time. Still, it was a nice respite at the end of the day, and we enjoyed sitting near the window to watch the waterfall as we relaxed in the evening and over coffee each morning.

We enjoyed our stay on the lake as our yearly family getaway. We had age ranges from 1 to 65 and was great for all ages. The screened in porches are nice to enjoy the lake view. House had all supplies and amenities that we needed for our visit.

This was a great stay. The house was beautifully appointed and comfortable. The view was OUTSTANDING! My husband and I even chose the slightly smaller bed in the back bedroom just so we could wake up to the lake view at sunrise (it would have been wasted on our son who sleeps until 2pm). Tracy was very accommodating when we made a last minute change. The decor was relaxing and the house was very comfortable for the 4 of us for a long weekend. We would love to come back.

Very nice comfy house. Peaceful and clean for a nice getaway. Natashia is very friendly and helpful. Will be returning.

Linda had everything you could possibly need and more. She even went the extra mile and provided bottled water, a snack basket and enough muffins for each of us. The house was immaculate and the beds were comfortable. There was ample, cozy seating in the family room as well. We highly recommend Linda’s place.

Great place! As my first Air BnB stay, it was a pleasure able experience with Rachelle.

The photos of the place are exactly as it is. It’s a very clean open concept stay within an hour of all of our destinations like Cooperstown and Sherborne really enjoyed our stay and it was a beautiful place.

Thank you for such a wonderful stay. Most beautifully designed Airbnb we have stayed at. This home is amazing and Heather & Lisa have thought of absolutely everything! Fully stocked! Full of natural light. Peaceful & private outdoor area with fire pit & hot tub. Beautiful bedroom with luxurious bedding, slippers, bath robes, lighted make up mirror, a perfume collection for guests to use if they wish and more! We cannot say enough good things! Thank you 🩷

This was exactly what I needed while in town for a week. It was dog friendly with super easy check in and out. I would definitely stay again. Thanks Patricia!

Such a cute place to stay! Convenient to downtown and surrounding areas and great restaurants ! Jennifer was a great host, she gave clear instructions on parking and getting inside and the place is super clean, modern and simple!! Would definitely recommend!

Absolutely loved this stay!! 10/10 will be back and will be recommending it to friends and family! such a romantic peaceful place to stay !! Christopher was an amazing host, always keeping in contact and ensuring I knew he was there for anything !!

I had a really relaxing time staying at Amanda's place. She was always quick to respond to questions. The place was very clean, and I thoroughly enjoyed the view of the water. The place is a quick drive to Hamilton where there are shops and restaurants. I would definitely stay here again.