Holiday houses in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favourite

The exterior view of Camp Havon reveals a two-story building nestled among trees, with multiple decks and large windows. The landscaped garden features stone paths and greenery, complementing the natural surroundings. The structure's varied textures and materials add visual interest to the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Maryland

Private waterfront home on Goodyear Lake!

Camp Havon - is a wonderful home on picturesque Goodyear Lake! The private waterfront is a rare find being that it is flat and grassy right by the water! That is not often the case with waterfront homes. Enjoy all the water fun swimming, fishing and or boating. You can bring your own boat or rent a kayak from the shop on the lake. When you're not indulging in water activates you can enjoy the the wonderful views of Goodyear Lake from the firepit on the patio by the house or one of the many level

LocationFamilyAccess

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Top Guest favourite

A new wooden dock stretches into the calm water of Goodyear Lake, framed by lush green hills in the distance. The surface of the lake reflects the blue sky and white clouds, creating a serene atmosphere ideal for relaxation.

Home in Maryland

Goodyear Lake Rental - Lakeside Baseball Getaway

Just 15 minutes from Dreams Park & All Star Village, Bluegill Cove is one of the best Goodyear Lake rentals. On the quiet side of the lake, enjoy 100 feet of private lakefront with a glacial pebble beach, dock, kayaks, paddleboard, giant float, firepit, and beautiful sunset views. Perfect for a family of 5 looking to relax - two porches sit over the water views. A family favorite for 20+ years, it ranks among the top 5% of Airbnb listings and often books a year in advance. The views say it all.

FamilyLocationAmenities

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Superhost

Home in Maryland

The Goodyear LakeShore Lodge

Welcome to the Goodyear Lakeshore Lodge.This quaint country style retreat is located in the heart of the Catskills playground. Just steps away from the majestic Goodyear Lake. Only 10 minutes drive to Cooperstown. A picturesque village with a sense of nostalgia through its "Norman Rockwell" charm. Visit the famous Baseball Hall of Fame. Take a stroll on the romantic streets sipping an old style cream soda . End the day around the campfire back at the Lakeshore Lodge. Enjoy your memorable stay!

FamilyLocationRiver

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Top Guest favourite

The exterior of a charming cottage is presented with navy blue siding and white trim. Large windows allow light to flow into the interior, while a vibrant yellow front door stands out. A manicured lawn surrounds the house, enhancing the peaceful setting.

Cottage in Oneonta

Tall Pines is a 4 bedroom cottage with lake access

A true lake experience! Located between Cooperstown (12miles downtown) and Oneonta (7miles to downtown) because of its central location, you can enjoy many local shops, family owned restaurants, many local breweries and on a bus route. Tall Pines Cottage has a cozy, bright atmosphere. Relax on the patio with fire pit & grill or enjoy the yard games. The lake access affords kayaking, swimming, and receive 20% off a guided fishing trip with Reels and Rods guide service. Kayaks available for use.

FamilyLocationIndoor spaces

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Top Guest favourite

A rustic cabin is set against a backdrop of lush greenery, featuring a spacious wooden deck with a dining table and chairs. Inside, a cozy sleeping area showcases a neatly made bed with soft linens, while the warm wood interior adds to the inviting ambiance.

Cabin in Oneonta

Romantic Cozy Cabin with a View of the Wetlands

Summer baseball renters please note: availability is Dreams Park tournament schedule ONLY -- not All Star! Perfect for a couple's getaway, a writing retreat, or a cozy home base to explore the area! Built in the 18th century, it now boasts an adorable fully-equipped kitchen, a charming wood interior, a vaulted ceiling, and a spacious deck with a view of the birdlife and wetlands. Swimming, hiking, and fishing on Goodyear Lake 5 mins away! Minutes from live music, cafes, and antique shops!

LocationValueCheck-in

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Superhost

A tranquil view of the Susquehanna River reflects the surrounding greenery and structures, including a mix of residential buildings and docks. Lush trees line the banks, providing a serene backdrop against the bright blue sky with scattered clouds.

Home in Portlandville

Waterfront Cooperstown Rt 28 Discounted OffSeason

Discounted OffSeason Riverfront Route 28 Cooperstown Multifamily Riverfront on Route 28. Centrally-located between Cooperstown and Oneonta. Enjoy the beautiful scenery on the Susquehanna River at the north end of Goodyear Lake. Located only : 0.2 miles from Canoe and Kayak Rentals (short walk) 3.9 miles to Jackie's Restaurant 7.9 miles to Ommegang Brewery 8.2 miles to Dreams Park 10.5 miles to Oneonta 13.0 miles to Cooperstown 13.1 miles to Baseball Hall of Fame 14.4 miles to All-Star Village

LocationFamilyCleanliness

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Top Guest favourite

Home in West Oneonta

Cooper Creek

Cooper Creek is a valuable piece of central New York history that was built in the late 1700s. This homestead once included an outhouse, a spring house, a Cooper shed, and a proud hand hewn timber barn. Robby and Eileen Robbins purchased the property in 1984-finding it in desperate need of plumbing, electricity, as well as emergent repairs in order to preserve as much history as possible. The 18th century beams,& the wooden pegs used instead of nails helps it maintain its unique identity.

ValueFamilyIndoor spaces

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Superhost

A two-story cottage exterior is showcased, framed by large glass windows that provide ample natural light. Red umbrellas shade outdoor dining tables, with a barbecue grill visible nearby. The surrounding greenery creates a peaceful ambiance, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the outdoor space.

Home in Maryland

Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to Lakeside Retreat—a cozy cottage on Goodyear Lake offering stunning lake views and all the modern comforts you need for a relaxing stay. Just minutes from Cooperstown and Oneonta baseball camps, spend your days kayaking or canoeing along over nine miles of peaceful shoreline, fishing from your private dock, and soaking in the outdoor hot tub under the stars. In the evenings, unwind fireside with your favorite drink. The perfect blend of adventure and relaxation awaits you here.

ValueFamilyNearby

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Guest favourite

The exterior of a recently renovated house is shown, framed by lush green trees. A wooden deck leads to the front door, which features a decorative wreath. The light-colored siding and multiple windows create a welcoming entryway.

Home in Maryland

The Roost: Cozy Lakefront Vacation Getaway

Relax at The Roost - your private lakefront getaway on Goodyear Lake, in beautiful Upstate New York! This recently renovated 3 bedroom / 1 bath home has large yard & private lake access: perfect for bbq, swimming, fishing or kayaking (boats provided). Located 20 mins from Cooperstown, 15 mins from Cooperstown Dreams Park/ All Star Village & 10 miles from downtown Oneonta. A perfect place to stay for baseball campers, a getaway with friends, a family vacation or a romantic weekend!

LocationFamilyHospitality

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Guest favourite

A rustic cabin with a green metal roof features a spacious front porch adorned with comfortable seating. Large windows provide ample natural light, and a well-maintained lawn with trees offers a scenic backdrop. The tranquil setting invites relaxation and outdoor enjoyment.

Home in Oneonta

Lakefront, family friendly home -Baseball campers!

- Lake/waterfront home on Goodyear Lake. - Conveniently located close to local baseball camps, SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick college - Large lake view patio and yard for games or campfires and lakeside deck and dock. - Enjoy swimming, excellent fishing, and watersports. Row boat on site for guests. - Updated spacious home, including a fireplace and air conditioning. - Away from it all, but close to all amenities!

LocationFamilyLaundry

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Superhost

An outdoor seating area is presented with bright yellow chairs arranged around a circular fire pit, which is lit with a gentle flame. Soft lights hang above, illuminating the space. A serene view of the lake and hills is visible in the background, offering a tranquil atmosphere.

Cabin in Oneonta

Stay Golden

Nestled in on a quiet part of Goodyear Lake, this waterfront home offers a peaceful retreat perfect for families or groups of up to 13 guests. Conveniently located near Dreams Park, All-Star Village, Oneonta & historic Cooperstown. Game room w/. shuffleboard table & Pac-Man, bar, 7 bed bunk room, 3 kayaks, 1 canoe, 2 fire pits, 4 bedroom, 2 bath, big dining table, washer/dryer, WiFi, A/C, coffee bar

LocationFamilyView

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Top Guest favourite

An open-concept kitchen and dining area is displayed, featuring a large island with seating for four. Sunlight fills the space through multiple windows, illuminating the dining table with chairs. Modern appliances and a light color palette create a bright and welcoming environment.

Home in Milford

Creekside: Cozy Cooperstown Retreat

Welcome! Creekside is a ranch style home overlooking a scenic pond. It is a 3 bedroom, 2 bath home with cathedral ceilings and a beautiful open concept feel. If your group would like to spread out, we have an option to add a 4th bedroom and living space with a basement apartment option. Decks on both the front & back of the home let you enjoy all the surrounding nature.

ValueFamilyIndoor spaces

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 295 reviews