Cottage holiday rentals in Long Island

Louise's place was perfect. Louise was so easy to communicate with, super responsive, kind, thoughtful and truly appreciated that she had the option of flexible dates (instead of so many sat to sat or sun to sun requirements in summer). The cottage was cozy, cute, spotless & well stocked. My teenage kids loved the hot tub (as it was a bit chilly in the evenings) and I loved the outdoor shower. We loved having the bikes to take rides around the Island and loved the location. Our only regret is that we didn't get to stay there longer! We will definitely try to stay at Old Snuggler again!

We thoroughly enjoyed our time at the cottage. It was so very peaceful and we loved being literally right around n the water! Slept amazingly well and the cottage was just lovely! Robert was also a great host. 5 stars all around and we hope to return again!

We booked the house for five nights for a group of six adults and had a lovely visit. Gabriela was a fantastic host communicating super promptly to our questions. It rained 90% of the time so we used the interior of the house to the fullest, and not the exterior (no fire pit, bikes, or hot tub) so cannot comment on those features. All appliances worked well. Kitchen is helpfully labeled and well stocked with kitchenware. The beds were very comfortable, towels fluffy, and downstairs family/game room is a great space for all ages. Furniture was comfortable, dining table was welcoming and though the house shows a bit of wear and tear here and there, everything was clean, tidy, and decorated appealingly. Tip: Bellvale Market just 7” away had great quality food products; Warwick, a quaint larger town, is just 10-15” away providing all other conveniences.

What a wonderful experience! I wanted to celebrate my wife’s birthday and this was a fantastic place to do it! We had a terrific time. The house is beautiful and well appointed. Location was great . Visited 2 Farmer’s market and enjoyed the beauty in general. We will return! Thank you for being a gracious host!❤️

Peaceful surroundings, beautiful lake, wonderful house and amazing hosts! Had an absolute ball kayaking, fishing, and enjoying nature. This was my second trip and can’t wait to go back again.

Tabitha's place was perfect for our group stay. Right in the middle of town and perfect for what we needed for the week!

Very nice peaceful places and very good service i will definitely be back soon, thank you

beautiful house, great location and very nice and peaceful neighborhood close to the beach and the vineyards the house is very well equipped ! Richard was very nice and even find a little bed for our baby boy ! thanks !

I love the fresh air flowing throughout this entire little cottage. Every room invites dappled sunlight filtered through lush summer foliage. It is truly cozy, whether enjoying a coffee on the back porch, journaling at the desk or chilling on the big comfy couch. Walk out the door and the lake and charming downtown are steps away. I find myself thinking I could truly spend a happy month, here. Stay. Return. I know I will.

Great stay, Maureen is very communicative and super helpful. Beautiful views

Very communicative and perfect description of what was expected.

Jeanne's place was perfect for my trip to Guilford. Excellent location, close to the Green and to the water, quiet, peaceful. The house had everything I needed and more, Jeanne was super responsive and kind, and the bed was comfortable.

Jamie & Rose are the consummate hosts: clear communicators, friendly, helpful and supportive of their guests' (and their animals') experience. The cottage is New England cute on steroids, and super private. All was tip top, first rate for a country cottage experience. Thanks for making our experience so smooth and relaxing.

We had a lovely stay in South Salem and enjoyed exploring nearby pound ridge and new Canaan. We loved the organic snacks provided by the host and the peaceful setting.

Robert and kiki where supper nice, went above and beyond for me!!! The cottage was super cute so cozy. Would love to go back

Meghan's place is exactly as posted it is absolutely beautiful, cozy, comfortable and did I say beautiful? one of my favorite things to do was sit in front of the big windows and read. You have everything you can think of close, at least 4 to 6 minutes away. There are restaurants, super market and pharmacies. But if you are like me and also like to cook sometimes on vacation the kitchen was equipped with everything you need. Highly, highly recommend.

Eglantine’s place was an absolute DREAM! The pictures do not do it justice, it is much bigger than expected! It really feels like you are on your own private beach. It is so private and calm and peaceful. Both indoor and outdoors are absolute perfection and no matter where you sit, it’s the best seat in the house. Eglantine is also extremely friendly and always responsive. We most certainly would recommend her place to anyone looking for a peaceful and beautiful getaway and would love to book again sometime soon!!

We had a great stay at the Cozy Cottage! It was the perfect space for our family of 3. Garrett provided great instructions and was always available for any questions. We were close to family and everything we needed to do in NY. We would stay at the Cottage again when visiting the area.

Susan is a fantastic host and the cottage is a lovely place to stay. Steps from the beach and a quick drive into town plus pool access right out your door. Susan was great to interact with. We definitely plan to come back.

A beautiful house that felt very spacious for its size. It was very stylish and super comfortable. The backyard was huge with a little bridge that went over the pond, and had daily visits from a rabbit, groundhog and turtle. This house is a great choice if you are visiting the area, with the Expressway a minute away, a Walmart at the next exit going east, and a deli, pizza place and gas station at the corners of your street. Looking forward to staying again

Will be back! Cutest spot- both inside and outside were impeccable. Felt very private and was short drive to anything you need. The 2 bathrooms were great for our family, can’t wait to visit again! Really comfortable beds and enjoyable pool and backyard for all.

We had a lovely stay at this beautiful home! It is an old house so it had its quirks, but it was nothing we couldn’t look past. Very steep stairs, a janky door- nothing major. We had young kids with us so the gates for the stairs came in very handy! There were baby gates, 2 pack and plays, a high chair and a toddler bed. Those amenities alone took so much stress off us. The towels and linens were all very nice and clean and plentiful. The views were PHENOMENAL. We took a walk along the beach at low tide and had so much fun collecting golf balls and shells. My son got to hold his first baby shrimp and jellyfish. The memories made were priceless. Water shoes are a must!! If you require a smart tv with all the apps, I recommend bringing a Firestick, as the tv capabilities were limited. I had one delivered from target within an hour. Astrid was the BEST host! She was extremely responsive, helpful, flexible, and kind. I can’t say enough good things about her and her home!

We had a fabulous weekend at this lovely cottage. Located on a remote peninsula surrounded by the glistening water we couldn’t have asked for a nicer experience. The amenities were both convenient and thoughtful. Although we chose to dine out, the kitchen was very modern with upscale appliances and an espresso machine. We did bbq on our last night and had a great end to our 4 night stay!

The house was great. Perfect location. The house is decorated beautifully. Perfect for a small group or family. Right across from Long Beach. If you don’t know the Hamptons, this is a big deal. To park at any beach, you need to have a parking permit only issued to home owners. A lot of people come out thinking they will spend their weekend at the beach and get very frustrated when that can’t happen. This location is perfect because you can walk to the beach, no sticker or parking needed and it’s the Bay which is much better for children.